Something went wrong. Try again later
    Follow

    Red Dead Redemption

    Game » consists of 23 releases. Released May 18, 2010

    Red Dead Redemption is the spiritual successor to 2004's Red Dead Revolver, featuring a vibrant, open world set in the decline of the American Wild West. Players take on the role of former outlaw John Marston, who is forced to hunt down his former gang to regain his family.

    Story, Writing and Narration

    Avatar image for twolines
    TwoLines

    3406

    Forum Posts

    319

    Wiki Points

    0

    Followers

    Reviews: 0

    User Lists: 5

    Edited By TwoLines

    Story Time

     The battle is the weakest aspect of Suikoden 2..
     The battle is the weakest aspect of Suikoden 2..

    While rummaging through the ruins of old console games,
    I have found one that hasn't aged a day in my mind- Suikoden 2.
     
    I realised this game was probably one of the best JRPGs- hell, RPGs I've ever played.
    Screw that, best story game I've ever played.



    Which bummed me out a little. I finished RDR not long ago, and the story was decent.
    Actually, it was pretty well done. But something was missing..
    And it wasn't the nostalgia- I played Suikoden 2 about four years ago.
    That's not enough time to get all mushy about it. 
     
    So, if it's not the poochie-poochie feelings, then what?
    Well let me tell you something about the characters, story and writing in this game... 
     

    Marston's love and blindness


    I didn't really like John Marston, and certainly had no attchement for...
     
    Spoilers.. 

    ...his wife and son, who the story writers desperately wanted to shove down my throat the last couple of hours of the game. 
    All they did was whine, and make me do pointless missions. Yes, after four missions of shooting damn forest animals,
    I felt waaaay closer to my "son". You know what they say, nothing makes a bond between a man and his boy tighter, than shootin'
    and skinnin' some deer!
     
    It just felt dirty. All of it.

    It felt that way because it was forced.
    John Marston may have loved his family- he lived with them for 16 years.
    I on the other hand, couldn't care less about a bunch of strangers I've met an hour ago,
    and only knew an hour before everything ended.
     
    I barely cared about Marston himself.  
     
    Don't get me wrong, Marston is clearly a more likable fellow than Niko or Carl Johnosn.
    But he's just too passive about everything. he has his moments, but mostly he just doesn't care.

    End spoilers.  
     

    Games that made you think


    So maybe it just wasn't for me. Some people enjoy it, but does it make them/you think about it?
    Does this game make you care and feel bad/good for all the people involved?
     
    Persona 4 did. Good story driven games do that.
    I'm not saying ONLY JRPGs are skillful at creating an interesting world with charismatic characters,
    no, I cared about the fate of my crewmen in Mass Effect 2.

    Except for Miranda, I mean- she has a nice ass, but man.. 
    I have no idea what someone was thinking when writing for that character.
    Oh, but she has a sister that she cares for! Bleh!
     
     Aww, cheer up! I'm actualy saying good things about your game!
     Aww, cheer up! I'm actualy saying good things about your game!
    Suikoden 2 was one of the few games with a story I cared about.
    I also got deeply invested in some of the Final Fantasy games,
    mainly FFIX- it has an amazing way of pulling me into the world it has created.
    Even if it was a lil' bit cheesy here and there..
     
    And how could I forget The Longest Journey? 
    That game was worth the time spent on looking at a faq
    (I'm not that good at adventure games).
     
     
     

    So what game made you feel for the characters and its story? What games you couldn't get into because of its writing?
    Avatar image for twolines
    TwoLines

    3406

    Forum Posts

    319

    Wiki Points

    0

    Followers

    Reviews: 0

    User Lists: 5

    #1  Edited By TwoLines

    Story Time

     The battle is the weakest aspect of Suikoden 2..
     The battle is the weakest aspect of Suikoden 2..

    While rummaging through the ruins of old console games,
    I have found one that hasn't aged a day in my mind- Suikoden 2.
     
    I realised this game was probably one of the best JRPGs- hell, RPGs I've ever played.
    Screw that, best story game I've ever played.



    Which bummed me out a little. I finished RDR not long ago, and the story was decent.
    Actually, it was pretty well done. But something was missing..
    And it wasn't the nostalgia- I played Suikoden 2 about four years ago.
    That's not enough time to get all mushy about it. 
     
    So, if it's not the poochie-poochie feelings, then what?
    Well let me tell you something about the characters, story and writing in this game... 
     

    Marston's love and blindness


    I didn't really like John Marston, and certainly had no attchement for...
     
    Spoilers.. 

    ...his wife and son, who the story writers desperately wanted to shove down my throat the last couple of hours of the game. 
    All they did was whine, and make me do pointless missions. Yes, after four missions of shooting damn forest animals,
    I felt waaaay closer to my "son". You know what they say, nothing makes a bond between a man and his boy tighter, than shootin'
    and skinnin' some deer!
     
    It just felt dirty. All of it.

    It felt that way because it was forced.
    John Marston may have loved his family- he lived with them for 16 years.
    I on the other hand, couldn't care less about a bunch of strangers I've met an hour ago,
    and only knew an hour before everything ended.
     
    I barely cared about Marston himself.  
     
    Don't get me wrong, Marston is clearly a more likable fellow than Niko or Carl Johnosn.
    But he's just too passive about everything. he has his moments, but mostly he just doesn't care.

    End spoilers.  
     

    Games that made you think


    So maybe it just wasn't for me. Some people enjoy it, but does it make them/you think about it?
    Does this game make you care and feel bad/good for all the people involved?
     
    Persona 4 did. Good story driven games do that.
    I'm not saying ONLY JRPGs are skillful at creating an interesting world with charismatic characters,
    no, I cared about the fate of my crewmen in Mass Effect 2.

    Except for Miranda, I mean- she has a nice ass, but man.. 
    I have no idea what someone was thinking when writing for that character.
    Oh, but she has a sister that she cares for! Bleh!
     
     Aww, cheer up! I'm actualy saying good things about your game!
     Aww, cheer up! I'm actualy saying good things about your game!
    Suikoden 2 was one of the few games with a story I cared about.
    I also got deeply invested in some of the Final Fantasy games,
    mainly FFIX- it has an amazing way of pulling me into the world it has created.
    Even if it was a lil' bit cheesy here and there..
     
    And how could I forget The Longest Journey? 
    That game was worth the time spent on looking at a faq
    (I'm not that good at adventure games).
     
     
     

    So what game made you feel for the characters and its story? What games you couldn't get into because of its writing?
    Avatar image for theseductivemoose
    TheSeductiveMoose

    3629

    Forum Posts

    274

    Wiki Points

    0

    Followers

    Reviews: 0

    User Lists: 3

    #2  Edited By TheSeductiveMoose
    Avatar image for twolines
    TwoLines

    3406

    Forum Posts

    319

    Wiki Points

    0

    Followers

    Reviews: 0

    User Lists: 5

    #3  Edited By TwoLines

    I've already seen a discussion about whether this should be included, and if so- where. 
    It's on the RDR forum, there are some interesting points of view on that subject.

    Avatar image for joyfullofrockets
    JoyfullOFrockets

    1206

    Forum Posts

    0

    Wiki Points

    0

    Followers

    Reviews: 2

    User Lists: 1

    #4  Edited By JoyfullOFrockets

    Kinda remember playing Suikodden 2 a long time ago, but gave up on it precisely because the combat was so boring. There was also some girl named Joey or something that to my surprise turned out to be a dude (!)

    Avatar image for ahmadmetallic
    AhmadMetallic

    19300

    Forum Posts

    -1

    Wiki Points

    0

    Followers

    Reviews: 1

    User Lists: 11

    #6  Edited By AhmadMetallic

    i think its great that the family missions were forced down your throat. you know why? because it went well with the whole "i wanna get the most out of my family's company before the bad guys are here to end my life" theme 
     
    and though i loved playing as Marston, i think Niko is a way better character

    Avatar image for ahmadmetallic
    AhmadMetallic

    19300

    Forum Posts

    -1

    Wiki Points

    0

    Followers

    Reviews: 1

    User Lists: 11

    #8  Edited By AhmadMetallic
    @TwoLines:  i guess you're right

    This edit will also create new pages on Giant Bomb for:

    Beware, you are proposing to add brand new pages to the wiki along with your edits. Make sure this is what you intended. This will likely increase the time it takes for your changes to go live.

    Comment and Save

    Until you earn 1000 points all your submissions need to be vetted by other Giant Bomb users. This process takes no more than a few hours and we'll send you an email once approved.