This game is ridiculous.

#1 Edited by zombie2011 (5054 posts) -

So i'm more than half-way through this game 5-2 and it is awesome.  
  
I intentionally skipped this game last year because of Dead Space. I played most of Dead Space and got really bored of it every level felt the same all the enemies looked alike the gameplay just got stale after a while. So after a break from the genre for a while i decided to pick up Resi 5 and man this game is so much better than Dead Space. The action is way more intense the setting is awesome and the graphics..oh man are they good. I haven't played Uncharted 2 for a while but the cutscenes in Resident Evil 5 are the best i've seen. 
 
So the question. Most the guys on this forum love Dead Space, and i'm wondering if i'm missing something. Yeah the game controls better, but didn't you get bored after a while? I mean Resident Evil 5 has varied location and enemies while Dead Space didn't. If you do you like Dead Space more than Resident Evil 5, why? 

#2 Edited by FartyMcNarly (566 posts) -

I don't have ADD so constant change isn't needed and atmosphere is superior. 

#3 Posted by Yummylee (22587 posts) -

Hurrrrry, the anticipating is killing me!
#4 Posted by TheMustacheHero (6655 posts) -

I thought it was pretty ridiculous.

#5 Edited by Darkstar614 (1098 posts) -

Maybe this is just the most clever troll ever. Thank you OP, you made my night.
 
Edit: Aw, damn.

#6 Posted by chstupid (806 posts) -

Too late MUAHAHAHA
#7 Posted by RiddleBrother (511 posts) -

This post is ridiculous.
 
/dadjoke

#8 Posted by zombie2011 (5054 posts) -

Its edited thanks for waiting *sigh*

#9 Posted by aerious (124 posts) -

I disagree completely, thought dead space was masterful and had great tension throughout and RE5 was completely ludicrous and silly.

#10 Posted by InfiniteGeass (2059 posts) -

I thought it was fun trying to unlock all the upgrades for every gun. I also really love Wesker. He's such a great villian.

#11 Posted by Heartagram (1183 posts) -

I had fun with both games. 
 
They feel very different to me and there are things i like about both.  
 
I enjoyed the ridiculousness of the story in RE5 and felt the story in Dead Space wasn't great but i wasn't there for that. 
 
Dead Space feels like a better game to me which is probably why i have played through it 3 times and gotten the full 1000 Gamerscore. 
 
RE5 was fun but not as revolutionary as RE4 for the Survival Horror genre which is why it doesn't get as much acclaim.

#12 Posted by Yummylee (22587 posts) -

I prefered Dead Space because it a much more horrific atmosphere. RE5 was supposed to contend it as a horror title, but of courses its pointing towards the actiong route. Which in that regard, the no moving while aiming does hamper it a little. Plus it has one of the most laughably terrible cover systems ever implemented. 
 
RE5's boss battles weren't too fantastic either.
#13 Posted by Yummylee (22587 posts) -
@InfiniteGeass said:
"I thought it was fun trying to unlock all the upgrades for every gun. I also really love Wesker. He's such a great villian. "

He was a great villian. For me, RE5 totally ruined him. He became more like a James Bond villian.
#14 Posted by AjayRaz (12477 posts) -
@InfiniteGeass said:
" I thought it was fun trying to unlock all the upgrades for every gun. I also really love Wesker. He's such a great villian. "
yes. what really pissed me off though, was  
 
#15 Posted by Creamypies (4091 posts) -
@Abyssfull said:
" @InfiniteGeass said:
"I thought it was fun trying to unlock all the upgrades for every gun. I also really love Wesker. He's such a great villian. "

He was a great villian. For me, RE5 totally ruined him. He became more like a James Bond villian. "
Didn't help that the voice actor who played him was absolutely terrible.
#16 Posted by ADTR_ZERO (1060 posts) -

I was so surprised at RE5's graphics. If it was a PS3 exclusive or only on the PC, or on PS3 and PC, then it wouldn't be that surprising. It's amazing how a game can look that good on the Xbox 360, just mind blowing.
#17 Posted by InfiniteGeass (2059 posts) -
@AjayRaz: Never say never.
 
@creamypies: Really? I thought his voice actor was great and fit the character well.
#18 Posted by AjayRaz (12477 posts) -
@InfiniteGeass: True, but even Capcom confirmed that he's not coming back :( 
#19 Posted by Yummylee (22587 posts) -
@AjayRaz said:
" @InfiniteGeass: True, but even Capcom confirmed that he's not coming back :(  "

Least hes got some confirmation. Whats my main-man Barrys excuse? :'(
#20 Posted by InfiniteGeass (2059 posts) -
@AjayRaz: And Bungie once said that Halo 3 would be their last Halo game. I won't believe it unless several Resident Evil games come out without him in it.
#21 Posted by zombie2011 (5054 posts) -
@FartyMcNarly said:
" I don't have ADD so constant change isn't needed and atmosphere is superior.  "
I feel the atmosphere in Resident Evil 5 is just as good. I feel the whole no hud on screen thing is overrated. The game i got sucked into most this year was Assassins Creed 2, and that game had a million icons on screed and shit flashes up on screen every 5 seconds.
#22 Posted by AjayRaz (12477 posts) -
@InfiniteGeass: I like your enthusiasm. maybe you're right! I don't want him to go :( 
#23 Posted by Yummylee (22587 posts) -

 

RE's new leading villian. >8D
#24 Posted by Creamypies (4091 posts) -
@InfiniteGeass: Maybe it's because I'm English. But to me... the accent sounded really off. I don't see why developers can't just hire English actors to play English parts. Presuming he was meant to sound English that is.
#25 Posted by SoylentGreen (259 posts) -
@AjayRaz said:
" @InfiniteGeass said:
" I thought it was fun trying to unlock all the upgrades for every gun. I also really love Wesker. He's such a great villian. "
yes. what really pissed me off though, was  
 
"


Then again, I'd only played small amounts of RE4 before RE5.
 
On topic: Dead Space has much better atmosphere than RE5, the guns feel better, and the bosses are just...better. I felt like I killed Cthulhu when I defeated the last boss in Dead Space, but Wesker just made me shrug.
#26 Posted by AjayRaz (12477 posts) -
@SoylentGreen: I mean, after how important Wesker was to the RE story, how much he has done in the RE series, see him going like that is incredibly underwhelming. It disappointed me as a huge RE fan. 
#27 Posted by Dynamo22 (70 posts) -

I'm a huge fan of RE5. But, Dead Space is much better than RE5 in every aspect. 

#28 Posted by Yummylee (22587 posts) -
@SoylentGreen:
Ayupp, plus u actually see his head just...dissapear lol Safe to say that Weskers dead. Or at least...this one, they'll probably bring forth one of the other ''Wesker Children'' or some stupid shit to give into popular demand.
#29 Posted by Wes899 (2128 posts) -

Wesker put his DNA into a ring, which Ada will clone.

#30 Posted by Dethfish (3699 posts) -

Dead Space was too scary for me, I barely got through the demo. I liked a RE5 a lot though.

#31 Posted by TheMustacheHero (6655 posts) -
@AjayRaz said:
" @SoylentGreen: I mean, after how important Wesker was to the RE story, how much he has done in the RE series, see him going like that is incredibly underwhelming. It disappointed me as a huge RE fan.  "
He will probably come back like he always does.
#32 Posted by AjayRaz (12477 posts) -
@TheMustacheHero said:
" @AjayRaz said:
" @SoylentGreen: I mean, after how important Wesker was to the RE story, how much he has done in the RE series, see him going like that is incredibly underwhelming. It disappointed me as a huge RE fan.  "
He will probably come back like he always does. "
I hope so, even though it would be really fucking stupid to have someone come back after being shot by two rockets in the face while drowning in lava in a volcano. 
#33 Posted by TheMustacheHero (6655 posts) -
@AjayRaz said:
" @TheMustacheHero said:
" @AjayRaz said:
" @SoylentGreen: I mean, after how important Wesker was to the RE story, how much he has done in the RE series, see him going like that is incredibly underwhelming. It disappointed me as a huge RE fan.  "
He will probably come back like he always does. "
I hope so, even though it would be really fucking stupid to have someone come back after being shot by two rockets in the face while drowning in lava in a volcano.  "
Well, Resident Evil is pretty stupid anyways. Zombies with guns and body armor? Really?
#34 Posted by zombie2011 (5054 posts) -
@Dynamo22 said:
" I'm a huge fan of RE5. But, Dead Space is much better than RE5 in every aspect.  "
Seeing you liked it so much, i'm gonna ask you.  
 
I stopped playing Dead Space after the first boss, the plant monster. Does the game get any better after that or is it just more of the same, because it feels like i've been doing the something in the same location for the entire game. Also is the story any good so far it's been pretty boring.
#35 Posted by Milkman (17345 posts) -

I love Resident Evil 5 but if you prefer RE 5 over Dead Space, then you don't like survival horror games.

#36 Posted by zombie2011 (5054 posts) -
@Milkman said:
" I love Resident Evil 5 but if you prefer RE 5 over Dead Space, then you don't like survival horror games. "
I think after i finish RE5, i'll finish Dead Space. Maybe after playing RE5 i'll have more fun with Dead Space.  
 
I just hope i don't run into any more of those regenerating monsters, those are scary as hell, and not so fun to fight.
#37 Posted by ArbitraryWater (12136 posts) -
@zombie2011 said:
" @Dynamo22 said:
" I'm a huge fan of RE5. But, Dead Space is much better than RE5 in every aspect.  "
Seeing you liked it so much, i'm gonna ask you.   I stopped playing Dead Space after the first boss, the plant monster. Does the game get any better after that or is it just more of the same, because it feels like i've been doing the something in the same location for the entire game. Also is the story any good so far it's been pretty boring. "
Yes and no. The middle is a bit of a drag but the last few chapters make up for it.
 
I know I am the minority when I say this, but I enjoyed Resident Evil 5 more than Dead Space. Both are really great games, but I found RE5 to be a much tighter experience all around in terms of pacing. Yeah, AI Sheva isn't too bright, but she's not the giant blemish that people enjoy exaggerating about when they shit on RE5.   As for Wesker though, yeah he was kind of a bummer. But really, Resident Evil doesn't have a story worth caring about on a more than superficial level. There are too many plotholes and inconsistencies for it to be considered "good".
@Milkman said:
" I love Resident Evil 5 but if you prefer RE 5 over Dead Space, then you don't like survival horror games. "
Calling Dead Space a survival horror game is a bit of a stretch. It's a third person shooter that has stuff jump out at you.
#38 Posted by HistoryInRust (6407 posts) -

Liked both games. I think you have to take Resident Evil at face value as an action franchise with horror elements now, otherwise the discussion quickly becomes one that slights it for its inability to keep any reasonable amount of tension.  
 
Dead Space was the more mature title. More exactly executed to the specifications of its hype or its targeted result. That is to say, Dead Space is a more precise, intelligent horror game. Resident Evil is kind of a bombastic action flick anymore. And that's what people are comparing. 

#39 Posted by AuthenticM (3806 posts) -

This game and Dead Space are absolutely not comparable. It's apples and oranges.

#40 Posted by JiuJitsuka85 (377 posts) -
@AjayRaz said:
" @InfiniteGeass said:
" I thought it was fun trying to unlock all the upgrades for every gun. I also really love Wesker. He's such a great villian. "
yes. what really pissed me off though, was  
 
"
[spoiler]
indeed. "oops I stepped into lava". Not very smart mister Wesker!
[/spoiler]
#41 Posted by Meowayne (6084 posts) -

  If you do you like Dead Space more than Resident Evil 5, why?

Because I value good writing and interactive storytelling about four billion times higher than hurr hurr durr explosions, graphics, and scantily clad women?
#42 Posted by demontium (4710 posts) -
@FartyMcNarly said:
" I don't have ADD so constant change isn't needed and atmosphere is superior.  "
Beat me to my response again.
#43 Edited by therabidfrog (349 posts) -

I have to say I didn't really care for Dead Space. I don't exactly enjoy putting myself completely on edge for 40 minutes at a time, and the last third or so of the game just became one immense gauntlet of monsters which is the one thing I seriously despise about Survival Horror games. They spend the majority of the game making you converse every bit of ammo, making every shot count as best as possible, and then they dump an army on you in the last leg.

#44 Posted by Nasar7 (2813 posts) -

The only thing I didn't like about RE5 was that last boss fight with Wesker. What a dumb way to end it.

#45 Posted by zombie2011 (5054 posts) -
@Meowayne said:
"

  If you do you like Dead Space more than Resident Evil 5, why?

Because I value good writing and interactive storytelling about four billion times higher than hurr hurr durr explosions , graphics, and scantily clad women? "
Scantily clad women? I don't remember seeing any in RE5, unless you're talking about the evil lady who showed some cleavage. 
 

#46 Posted by Alphiehyr (1083 posts) -
@zombie2011 said:

" So i'm more than half-way through this game 5-2 and it is awesome.    I intentionally skipped this game last year because of Dead Space. I played most of Dead Space and got really bored of it every level felt the same all the enemies looked alike the gameplay just got stale after a while. So after a break from the genre for a while i decided to pick up Resi 5 and man this game is so much better than Dead Space. The action is way more intense the setting is awesome and the graphics..oh man are they good. I haven't played Uncharted 2 for a while but the cutscenes in Resident Evil 5 are the best i've seen.  So the question. Most the guys on this forum love Dead Space, and i'm wondering if i'm missing something. Yeah the game controls better, but didn't you get bored after a while? I mean Resident Evil 5 has varied location and enemies while Dead Space didn't. If you do you like Dead Space more than Resident Evil 5, why?  "

"So the question. Most the guys on this forum love Dead Space, and i'm wondering if i'm missing something."
- You didn't really miss anything in Dead Space. You've just played to the point of it becoming repetitive.
 
"I mean Resident Evil 5 has varied location and enemies while Dead Space didn't."
- Even the most simple-minded individuals would realize that.

"If you do you like Dead Space more than Resident Evil 5, why?"
- Your question may be the most pertinent, you may or may not realize it is also rhetorical.

This edit will also create new pages on Giant Bomb for:

Beware, you are proposing to add brand new pages to the wiki along with your edits. Make sure this is what you intended. This will likely increase the time it takes for your changes to go live.

Comment and Save

Until you earn 1000 points all your submissions need to be vetted by other Giant Bomb users. This process takes no more than a few hours and we'll send you an email once approved.