Giant Bomb Review

162 Comments

Borderlands 2 Review

4
  • X360
  • PS3
  • PC

Borderlands 2 gives you more Borderlands. No more, no less.

There are some solid explosions in Borderlands 2, but you might not want to look at all of them.

Borderlands 2 feels like someone sat down and built a checklist of the first game's issues--simplistic AI, PC interface issues, bad boss battles, the lack of a trade interface--and set out to fix them. By that standard, it's certainly a better game than the original, and it backs these additions up with smart online updates, an even more expansive random loot generator, and a revamped set of character classes that make every piece of gear and every skill point you spend feel like a tough trade-off between different types of character growth. It feels very iterative in spots, and it often feels like you can see the parts where Gearbox ripped out an old system and swapped it for a more robust and balanced replacement. It also maintains its strong sense of humor, but the various characters in play throughout Borderlands 2 can be a little hit-and-miss, leading to cases where I just wanted the game to shut up and let me get back to shooting stuff and opening chests.

Borderlands 2 is set five years after the events of the first game and features an all-new cast of playable characters, who are again cast as "vault hunters" en route to Pandora to make a fortune. The cast of the first game now exist as full-on characters in the world, complete with dialogue that helps flesh them out as actual people, rather than mostly silent player characters. Most of your missions will come from Roland and the gang, though since they were barely characters in the first game, I never really got attached to any of them. The original gang serves as leaders of a resistance movement that's attempting to fight against the Hyperion Corporation, led by a smarmy prick named Handsome Jack. It seems that Jack swooped in after the events of the first game, took credit for the vault hunters' actions, and is now attempting to mine the heck out of the planet because it's crawling in priceless alien ore that, naturally, is one of the keys to awakening some ancient alien power. You, as one of the new vault hunters that's been screwed over by Handsome Jack and left for dead, quickly team up with the old crew to do their bidding, seek revenge, and collect a whole lot of loot along the way.

Though the first Borderlands certainly had more than its fair share of loot variety, the sequel really blows this aspect of the game out by bringing more and flashier effects to weapons as well as shields, class mods, grenade types, and relics. You'll find large capacity shields that lower your health, or shields that give you a deep bonus to melee damage when they're depleted, or shields that reflect damage onto melee attackers with an elemental bonus. Grenades can have elemental effects as well, along with statistics such as fuse time, radius, and overall damage. But the grenades can still be bouncing betties, transfusion grenades that leech health from your targets, and other types that appeared in the first game. Class mods and relics spread out quite a bit, too, giving you items that give you more experience points for kills, larger magazine size for weapons, or even bonuses that only work when you're firing guns from a specific manufacturer.

Though some of the characters may seem similar, the skill trees are different enough to make them all feel unique.

Gun manufacturers are one of the ways that Borderlands 2 gives method to its madness, and each weapon manufacturer specializes in a different style of weapon. Hyperion guns, for example, gain accuracy when you hold the fire button down, so instead of getting wild and all over the place like you'd expect, you actually get deadlier in longer bursts. That's weird. Jakobs tends to deal in revolvers and other Western-themed guns that have your character fanning the hammer as he or she squeezes off rounds as quickly as you can pull the trigger on your controller. Maliwan deals in weapons with elemental effects. Bandit weapons all have misspelled names and tend to have larger magazine sizes than the others. You get the idea. On top of that, it's sort of easy to get a sense for a weapon's basic style by just looking at it. Assault rifles with huge, open-ended barrels probably fire tiny rockets instead of bullets, for example. It'd be nice if there was an easy way to see a weapon actually firing without going through the process of actually equipping it, but after a dozen or so hours, you start to get a sense for which weapons fit with your play style and which weapons are just vendor trash.

I don't know how you played the original Borderlands, but at some point, my Soldier character became practically unstoppable. With the ability to regenerate ammo and health, he became almost completely self-sufficient, and armed with the proper combat rifle, it was trivial to pick him back up if he ever managed to fall. Borderlands 2's skills feel a bit more balanced, making it more difficult to simultaneously spec in every direction. And the classes that appear analogous to classes from the first game aren't, so even if you think you know how the guy who tosses out a turret will play, the Commando feels very different from the Soldier. Even though you can easily respec your character at any time, I found myself agonizing over every skill decision because none of them were perfect fits for every situation. The loot, also, forces those decisions. Equipping a shield with a high capacity but also a penalty to your health might sound like a great idea... until you encounter a crew armed with shield-draining shock weapons. The only constant is that corrosive weapons, which chew through armored targets quite well, seem way more useful here than they were in the first game, because most of the villain's forces are armored robots.

Though questing in the direction of Handsome Jack is the entirety of the main line in Borderlands 2, there are plenty of side missions to find along the way. These are the missions that take you in wild different directions as you attempt to help find a new name for one of Pandora's creatures, help out a robot that wants to be human, or decide whether you want to return lewd photos of Moxxi to Marcus or back to Moxxi herself. In this case, the periphery of the experience is more interesting and fun than its core. The main quest pits you against Handsome Jack, who comes across as a one-note villain with very little to offer beyond a thick layer of smarm that gets old after the first few hours. I kept expecting some sort of meaningful progression for the villain, but the end result is a flat character that's more annoying than anything else. It was more of a "I wish I could disable this character's dialogue" feeling than a "boy, I can't wait to shut this jerk up with my guns" situation. In contrast, the rest of the game is lush with great little touches in its dialogue. Some of the best writing in the entire game, in fact, comes when you take a little too long to take action, be it holding for a moment before freeing Claptrap from the snow to waiting for the Guardian Angel to get impatient before you insert Quest Object A into Mission Advancement Slot B. These little gags are often worth waiting for, and even though they're usually only a couple of lines, they're some of the funniest moments in a game that, with a glaring exception or two, is generally pretty funny to begin with.

Zero's decoy ability makes him way more than just a simple sniper.

But the story and characters aren't everything. Playing with other people is what Borderlands does best, and that aspect of the game has grown up quite a bit. At any time you can pause your game and bring up a network menu to make your session publicly accessible, friends only, invite only, LAN, or totally offline. You can do this on the fly, without having to quit out or anything like that. It's really nice. Once players are in your game, you can open up the all-new trade interface to pass items around without having to drop them on the ground and expose yourself to potential thievery. In general, playing with other people is pretty much painless, even on PC, which now uses Steamworks across the board instead of that GameSpy nonsense. The PC version of the game is much friendlier overall, and the in-game menus for inventory are easily manipulated with a mouse. Playing the game with a mouse and keyboard feels just fine, but you can still play the PC version with a controller just as easily. Over on consoles, you'll still get a good sense of the game's terrific art, but the frame rates get quite dodgy when then action picks up and there's still scads of texture pop-in whenever you change zones. The PS3 version of the game, sort of like its predecessor, looks a little grimy and jaggy when compared to the 360 version, but it's certainly not a crippling issue.

I obsessed over the original Borderlands in spite of its flaws. Earning loot and exploring every little corner of the world became top priority for me when that game was released, and I kept up with its DLC add-ons, doing my best to ignore their decidedly uneven quality. Borderlands 2 is a better game in most of the ways that matter, but some of that is brought down by the familiarity of the experience. Perhaps some of that is on me and spending a couple hundred hours with the first game has rendered me resilient to some of the new game's charms, but as someone who went into Borderlands 2 with a sickness that I thought only more Borderlands could cure, I'm left feeling like I didn't receive a full dose this time around.

Jeff Gerstmann on Google+
162 Comments
  • 162 results
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
Posted by jasondesante

best part of this review is you only need to read "Borderlands 2 gives you more Borderlands. No more, no less." and you will understand everything about the game.

Posted by neoepoch

I tend to disagree. I think this game is probably the best sequel I've played in a long time. Everything is just so better that it is an absolute joy to play.

Posted by hollitz
Posted by dam4742

I can see a lot of Jeff's points, I just don't necessarily agree with all of them. Borderlands 2 is a much more focused, engaging and exciting affair from the first second. I'm playing it on PC and played Borderlands 1 for the third time through with Steam friends in the weeks leading up to the release. Borderlands 1 had a lot more downtime as you wandered around between settlements. The battles seemed a bit more spread out, particularly in the "rust" areas around the New Haven hub. The pacing slowly built in Borderlands and the lack of story and constant voice acting made the game a tension-building sensation rather than the non-stop action and voice-acting of Borderlands 2. I actually posted this on Anthony Burch's site too, but it bears repeating: I cannot think of a better writer than Burch to take the helm of Borderlands 2. (Okay, I can, but Joss Whedon is a little busy.) My only minor critique of Burch's writing is that his characters share a singular sense of humor - his. It may have been a little more fun with a bit more variety in the humor than the usual anything-goes, zaniest possible stuff we're used to from HAWP. But I love the game, the humor, the potential for more content and playable classes coming in October and the sheer volume of people I see logged into Steam playing it. All my friends finally seem to agree on a game being worth their time.

And as a side note - Giant Bomb's rating translates to an 80/100 on Metacritic, making it the lowest current critical score by 10 points. All the other critical scores are between 90 and 100 (most are 90). The only other ones I saw prior to peeking at Metacritic for curiosity had me in disbelief that it was going to be so universally acclaimed, and I found it strange that Giant Bomb (of all places) had the low score. I value and trust Giant Bomb and Jeff's opinion. Hopefully the Internet rage monsters won't come here to slam you, but stay and see all the great content that's here to see and share. I'll have to come back when I finish the campaign and write my own review. The ones I saw first were: IGN - 9/10, GameTrailers 9.2/10, Game Informer 9.75/10.

Posted by Dad_Is_A_Zombie

Jeff's review seems to be sort of what I figured. I picked up the original's GOTY Edition late in the game. Enjoyed and played the hell out of it. Probably going to do the same thing with this one. Summer '13 pickup for me in all likelyhood.

Posted by AbsolutHysteria

@Solh0und: Damn right, this shit is classic.

Posted by honkyjesus

@Dad_Is_A_Zombie: This is exactly what I am doing, though I rented it on Tuesday and returned it today.

Umm, the game itself seems a bit unfished. The technical side of things, especially pop in, are jarring.

Posted by echronorian

That's what you get for playing Axton. It's not that he sucks, he's just the least exciting class. I've played with Maya and the Gunzerker and I'm having the best time I've had in a shooter since I dunno when.

Posted by MetalMoog

I couldn't agree more with this review. I too spent hundreds of hours in Pandora and explored every nook and cranny of the original world and the zombie island. By the time the other expansions came out I had seen enough. Hoping that Borderlands 2 would be different enough and cure my desire for more quality experiences like I first had with the game I pre-ordered the second.

While the game is good I can't help shake the overwhelming sense of BINDER DUNDAT. It's essentially more of the same, tweaked and tuned from the first. It's no doubt that Borderlands 2 is a more polished game than the first, but at this point it's unique charms have been lost.

Posted by AnonymousBoy

I like this review except for the part about how much you dislike Handsome Jack. None of the characters in this game really progress or present any very interesting story, but the dialogue is all good. The writing and voice acting for Jack's character is just as witty and funny as the rest. So I don't know what your deal is against him.

Posted by steppenwolf

Golly, Mr. Gerstmann I think you're being a bit too harsh. I mean the voice acting is great, sure there are a few lines that aren't as good as the others but sheesh, there's SO many of them. It's pretty damned funny too, some of the jokes fall flat but again there are SO many jokes being tossed around all the time and most games can barely make me chuckle. I guess I never played the first one so this one feels fresh enough. I know there are some issues but hey, I'd at least finish up by saying: the good FAR out weigh the bad.

Posted by honkyjesus

@hollitz: Holy fuck. Is that the lead, cough, writer, for it? No wonder I hate that asshole besides not being funny and being around a chick who wants me to shoot my dick off.

Christ, the balls on that pretend nerd. I am going to shoot my own dick off.

Seriously, that is effed up.