Giant Bomb Review

191 Comments

Gears of War 3 Review

5
  • X360

Gears of War 3 is a fantastic follow-up that answers important questions about the nature of the Gears universe while backing it all up with an even bigger, better multiplayer suite.

Some enemies will now burst out of the ground in a completely radical-looking way.

Closure has become something of a rarity in today's video games. Blame it on whatever you want, from the business need to keep popular franchises running until we're all in the grave, to an increasing focus on multiplayer games, but these days it feels like most games set up at least as many questions as they do answers. That's part of what I like about Gears of War 3. It answers questions. It leaves things in a dramatically different place than they were at the start of the game. If this were to be the final game in the Gears franchise, it'd be a satisfying place to leave things... not that I believe for a minute that we'll never see a Gears of War 4 or Gears of War: The New Class or something along those lines. But instead of immediately making you wonder about the next game in the line, Gears 3 seems like it's built to last, with both a surprisingly touching story and a set of multiplayer additions that attempts to address the issues that plagued the previous game.

Gears of War 3 is about damaged goods. While it's expected to see Dominic Santiago's continuing mental breakdown after the loss of his wife in Gears 2, almost every character you can think of is feeling the effects of this longterm war, and the story spends just enough time focusing on the ways that some of the different characters are unravelling to make the game feel like it's about more than just hiding behind boxes and shooting monsters in the face. The game opens with Marcus dreaming about his father, and, as you might expect after the ending of Gears 2, much of this game deals with the revelation that Adam Fenix might not have died all those years ago. But the people in and around Delta Squad aren't the only things breaking down. With the COG effectively disbanded, there's no government left to back up these soldiers, forcing them to scavenge and trade with other survivors in order to continue the fight against two enemies: the battered-but-definitely-not-beaten Locust and the wild, infected Lambent creatures, which in the two years since the conclusion of Gears 2 have continued to mutate into something that now only occasionally resembles their original "irradiated Locust" look. The human forces appear scrappy and divided in Gears of War 3, and it's exciting to watch their campaign unfold.

You can play through the five acts of the Gears campaign in a few different ways. The online co-op option allows up to four players to play simultaneously, and there's a new arcade mode that turns on score tracking, giving you points for kills, assists, and so on. As you earn points, a points multiplier meter fills, giving you an opportunity for higher scores, but if anyone on the team goes down, that meter quickly begins to drain, giving you a real incentive to keep everyone alive. You can also enable mutators that alter the game a bit. Some make it more difficult and give you extra experience points, like one that requires you to active reload every single time. Others make it easier and reduce the XP you'll earn, like one that gives you infinite ammo. Others are just there for kicks, like one that adds a laugh track to the game. They all sound interesting, but you'll have to play for tons and tons of time if you want to unlock them all, which is pretty unfortunate.

The good news is that you can spend that tons of time in just about any mode. That includes the game's versus multiplayer, which offers the same sorts of game types found in Gears 2, so if you want to capture and hold points there's King of the Hill, or you can always go for more straight-up modes, like Team Deathmatch. TDM works with a respawn counter, giving each five-person team 15 respawns to start with. This helps make every death count and keeps matches moving. The game also seems to be attempting to give new players a fighting chance with a new "casual" option that jumps you right into a TDM match. But if you reach a specific skill threshold, this option is locked out, forcing you to go up against the regular Gears players in the standard setting.

Beast mode lets you play as different Locust classes as you chow down on humans.

This is the part where dudes roll up behind you every 15 seconds and blow you into chunks with a shotgun blast unless you are too busy rolling up behind them with a shotgun of your own. Great. OK, perhaps that's oversimplifying things a bit, but my point is that Gears 3's multiplayer gameplay hasn't changed dramatically, so those same players who were absolutely raw at Gears of War 2 will pick right up where they left off. Ideally you'll get matched up with players who are at or around your skill level, but my early experiences with the game ended up reminding me that while I think the competitive multiplayer in Gears is well-designed and exciting, playing it against people who play a lot of it is frustrating in an "I guess I'll just turn this off now" way, not a "Gee, I'm going to strive to get better so this stops happening" sort of way. I will grant you that this is more of a personal issue and not an actual problem with the game itself, and for those of you in a similar situation, there's always Horde mode.

The wave-based survival mode that first popularized the style returns with some solid enhancements in Gears of War 3. Horde mode is still all about five guys working together to take down tons of AI enemies on the game's multiplayer maps. But now it almost has a tower defense sort of feel. You'll earn money for kills, and between rounds you can spend that cash on barriers that slow the enemy's progress, turrets that you can operate manually, decoys that distract your foes, and so on. Every tenth wave pits your crew against a random boss battle--you might end up facing two berzerkers, or maybe an effing brumak will show up and ruin your day. Picking up weapons or refilling your ammo also costs money, which means that the new Horde mode is a mix of the old Horde mode, some sort of tower defense-like structural accoutrements, and the Zombies mode from Treyarch's Call of Duty games. While I'm not a huge fan of those inspirations, they come together really well and make an already solid Gears 2 mode even better.

There's also a new mode called Beast that, in some ways, acts as an inverted Horde mode. It's another five-player co-op mode, but now you're playing as the Locust and attempting to kill humans that have holed up behind barricades and other obstacles in the game's multiplayer maps. It's also class-based, requiring you to spend the money you get for each round to spawn as different Horde species. Tickers are the best at bashing through the barbed-wire fences and other obstacles that slow down your team, so it's best to select them up front to expose the humans before moving in with bloodmounts, boomers, serapedes, and other heavy Locust artillery. The catch is that all of this starts with a 60-second timer, requiring you and your team to move extremely quickly if you want to complete a round, though not quite as quickly as that might sound. Everything you attack adds a second or two to your timer. It's a fast, frantic mode that feels nicely different from anything else on the disc. It's a pretty cool change of pace.

All of this online action will, theoretically, work better than it did in Gears of War 2. After numerous complaints about host advantages and other online shenanigans, the game's matches have moved onto dedicated servers. This is a behind-the-scenes change, for the most part. You won't see a server browser or anything like that, and the only place where you get options about which weapons you want to allow in a game or which map you want to play on is when you're setting up a private game. You can also play against bots in those private games, if you like, but only in the versus multiplayer. Bots can't play Horde or Beast with you. Bots can, technically, also appear in public quick match games, but I suspect that once the game is widely available, you probably won't see a lot of non-human players in those matches.

The Lambent creatures blow up real good.

Visually, Gears of War 3 is a step up from the previous game. The campaign takes you across a lot of different locations, and you'll see some great weather effects and lighting along the way. You'll also see plenty of great explosions, and some of the best bangs come out of the Lambent creatures, which pop in a really satisfying way when you take them down. That said, the game's cutscenes often suffer from frame rate issues, as they have in the past. The game also has 3D support, but I found the 3D mode to be sort of a blurry, murky mess. Even with the brightness cranked up, it was difficult to see enemies in some cases, and on-screen text is chunkier and a lot harder to read. Your mileage may vary, I guess, but my official advice is to leave the 3D mode alone. It's not worth it.

Gears of War 3 manages to leave a question or two unanswered, but those holes aren't big enough to drive a sequel through. When the next Gears of War comes along--and lets not be naive about these things, we'll almost certainly see another Gears of War game someday--it'll probably have to be a fairly dramatic shift, from a story perspective. The members of Delta Squad have finally found some closure, and, for all of the derisive things the world lobs at Gears' totally-broed-out motif, the story even manages to be touching on multiple occasions. It's a joy to play, and the game's expanded set of multiplayer options will give you plenty of things to keep you busy for a good, long time. Oh, and Ice-T's pretty great in it, too.

Jeff Gerstmann on Google+
191 Comments
  • 191 results
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
Edited by Nicholas

Thank you, Jeff. After watching the "Ask Me Anything" and hearing you talk about the dire straits that humanity is in at the beginning of Gears of War 3 I was sold.

P.S. I already have this quest.

Edited by notdrew

yay

edit: LOL Dammit. THIS IS THE SECOND TIME THAT THIS HAS HAPPEN TO ME. Being second twice should be a quest dammit!

Edited by evilrazer

Haha. Anyway, I already have this quest.

Posted by DerekDanahy

Hell yeah 5 stars!

Posted by Hoffafiles

Partay all night

Posted by MadLaughter

Definitely playing this. Thanks Jeff! (Time to read >_>)

Posted by BeanoFritz

Dammit

Posted by MariachiMacabre

@Nicholas said:

ygrwdtetrt

@thatguy said:

asda

Pathetic.

Hot damn I'm excited for this game!

Edited by Marz

as Marcus would say...  "NIIIIIICE!"
  

Posted by ReyGitano

Damn. Well, no way of holding out on my friends now... College life has made me so damn broke.

Posted by Hot_Karl

I'm glad that we got a pretty nice assessment of Ice-T's performance in this review as well.

Posted by Xymox

There's no way in hell gears 3 could get 5 stars. Did it? It did. Holy crap. Video review coming soon?

Posted by Shaggydoo

Yea mang

Posted by Warihay

Just confirming what I already figured. Can't wait for Tuesday!

Posted by Animasta

@EuanDewar said:

Going to read this review anyway because it's staff content and it would be a shame not to but I am getting this game irrespective of anything in this review.

are you dissappointed it only got 5 stars? :P

this is totally not my kind of game at all, and I really don't get how people find it fun, but it's probably a good version of said game type? I got nothin.

Posted by cassus

So.. Gameplay still just holding the trigger down and then timing the reload, then?

Posted by evilrazer

@cassus: But now you can cry occasionally, if you want.

Posted by EuanDewar

Just read it.

This sounds literally perfect for my needs.

Posted by rmanthorp

"Oh, and Ice-T's pretty great in it, too."

YES. As expected Gears3, I am so excited!

Moderator Online
Edited by LiquidSwords

LET THE HATE BEGIN!!!!!

Ugh! It's midnight and have work tomorrow. Of course I'm going to watch this right now!

Posted by niamahai

i am now saddened that my epic edition won't arrive till NEXT saturday

Posted by Diablochicken14

I'm sold on this now, can't wait to get back into Gears again.

Posted by Red

Meh. I've never liked the Gears of War franchise. Too gray, enemies soak up too many bullets, too macho, and characters control poorly. I'll take Uncharted's cover-based shooting over GeoW any day.

Still, good review, and considering it's the biggest game dropping for another month, I may rent it and give the series another try.

Posted by rjayb89

Whoa, whoa there, Marcus! There's a fucking chainsaw on your fucking gun, watch where you put your hands, man.

Edited by NathHaw

I think that Gears of War was a pinnacle of the 360. It was a seminal game.

Posted by onan

5 stars! I'm shocked. ;D

Can't wait for this to come in the mail

Posted by Nayson

Five stars? Why so low Jeff? Why so low?!?

Posted by Catarrhal

@Red: Totally agree, but I'm obligated to play this because of Ice-T.

Posted by mewarmo990

It's good to hear the series is still going strong. I don't own a 360 but I thought the PC port of GoW was a job well done. Too bad there won't be any more since it's pretty clear by now that Games For Windows (for which GoW PC was a flagship title) was a failed initiative.

Posted by Stahlbrand

Glad to hear it came out well. All that time to polish, it would be a shame if it didn't.

I guess I should pre-order? I normally wouldn't, but when I went to get Dead Island a week after release I found it completely sold out... Which is a personal first for a non-instrument based game.

Posted by Curious_George

@Red said:

Meh. I've never liked the Gears of War franchise. Too gray, enemies soak up too many bullets, too macho, and characters control poorly. I'll take Uncharted's cover-based shooting over GeoW any day.

Still, good review, and considering it's the biggest game dropping for another month, I may rent it and give the series another try.

I rented the first and second and they were a fine diversion, but I don't see why the series receives so much attention. My Xbox is now busted so I won't be playing this one, but I kind of don't feel like I'll be missing much. I'd take an Uncharted any day as well (if only for the less drab scenery).

Posted by TheKing

Yeah, woo! Bring it on sucker - this' my kind of shit.

Posted by Sparky_Buzzsaw

Of all the games I can't play due to my visual limitations, the Gears series is the most lamentable as it looks spectacular and fun. I'm hoping to see this one in action, but I doubt I'll ever be picking it up myself.

Moderator
Posted by bkbroiler

Welp, time to place that order at Amazon.

Posted by itsjoncharles

I agree about the multiplayer - it's very competitive. In every other FPS scene I've entered, I have initially sucked but have then got a lot better to perhaps even good. Gears 3 was the first time this did not happen. I continued to suck despite practice and this puts me off, because I will only be playing the campaign as well as Horde and Beast mode. Therefore I have to ask myself whether this is worth a purchase at the moment, especially with Battlefield 3 and the Halo: Reach Title Update around the corner.

Posted by l4wd0g

Great read. Thanks for the review.

Posted by SoftCoreDave

Neat!

Posted by ectoplasma

Oh no. You broke the streak of never ending 4* reviews!

Posted by TaliciaDragonsong

Awesome, I've heard nothing but good things so far.
This will last me long hopefully!

Posted by SuperfluousMoniker

I've never been a huge Gears fan, mostly because I don't like the multiplayer, but if this has a better single player campaign than Gears 2 (which was fucking terrible IMHO) it'll be at least a rent for me.

Posted by lockload

Seem like such a feature rich game, amazing value compared to many games

Posted by mastrbiggy

Good review Jeff.

Posted by wickedsc3

I've loved all the gears games, already had this pre-ordered but good too see it got a great review. Can't wait for Tuesday, this is such a great franchise.

Posted by CassyFU

damn one of few things leaving me wanting 360...

Posted by Swoxx

Awww yeaaah, let's wrap this bitch up

Posted by WiqidBritt

I'll probably play this mostly on normal, I've always felt that the enemies take way too many bullets to make playing the game 'tactically' feel right.

Posted by Brackynews

"Scramble 'em 'till they're dry!!!"

\m/ >_< \m/

Posted by ChernobylCow

Sounds neat. All these early reviews have got me excited for a game I was other wise ignoring. My girlfriend and I beat GoW2's campaign in splitscreen (using different difficulties was very nice) and I played horde for a while but that game has been shelved for a long time.

Unfortunately, Jeff's review is a little bit by the numbers without much of his personality showing through. Having a comment about Ice-T at the end is about it. Hopefully if we see a video review we'll see "Jeff's side" but if you read snippets of this review alongside a video it would sound like one of his old Gamespot write-ups. Oh, well. He's probably exhausted from slugging through this game so fast.

Posted by Mijati

Looking forward to this greatly. As a "top" gears 2 player (Was ranked top 250 when I stopped playing) am definitely going to be putting in a lot of time into this. On top of that I've loved the story thus far and can't wait to see how it ends so will be playing through that at least twice (I do my first run on Hardcore then the second on Insane, maybe co-op) like I have done the previous too games.

Posted by bones360uk

Jeff just made my day!

  • 191 results
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4