Discuss theories on Rich Gallup's eyebrow here. I think it's actually two eyebrows really close together.

It was burned I bet.

He said himself "its a puberty thing"

Meh... genetics.

Damn, Rich gets his own forum section? Who do I have to kill to get my own? That DaWhiteAsian guy?

He got the scar while eating pineapple!

I can believe that. Pineapples are pretty spikey, and you have to have it pretty close to your face to eat it.

You know i never noticed it that much before until i rewatched some old footage of him on youtube, maybe he got smacked in the face by a controller. You know when you play with someone who moves the controller around as they move their character ingame?

Well, the truth of this whole eyebrow thing -- He rescued kittens from a burning building, with the use of only his eyebrow, a clothing hanger and some bubblegum.

Ok, so the actual truth is that it had something to do with genetics during puberty. I don't remember what it was called, but it made his hair turn white in that spot. So no, it's not a scar.

He explained this on his final On the spot.

I know for a fact he's talked about it, and I'm pretty sure he blamed it on puberty...

he also said some nicknames they gave him because of it. Can't remember them..

I never noticed till yesterday when I was looking through closeup images. They never went in that close on gamespot live. 

Never noticed till now

I heard he got it when he was a roadie for the Stones in the good 'ole days.

He was attempting to catch lightning to impress a girl.  He failed.

He was punched in the face by a ghost and was terribly frightened.

The truth is that when he was in puberty his body thought he had a mole on his eyebrow, (which he didn't) and bleached it out

CleverLoginName has it right (by the way, clever log in name.... C WAT I DID THUR?!?!?!)

Battle wound.

Read the page lulz.

He has a scar on his left eyebrow. The scar developed during puberty when, as Gallup explains, his body thought a mole had developed and tried to bleach it out. However there was no mole, leaving a bleached patch of skin. The more widely accepted version is that a ghost went through him and left a mark.