what may that game be, mine would be bully by far, most fun i have ever had

GTA San Andreas. Haven't played RDR yet though.

San Andreas.

Vice City

Toss up between Bully and The Warriors.

Really liked San Andreas.  Bully is a close second since it's setting was so uniquely awesome.

Bully for me.

tough one either bully or red dead

they are all so much fun

Red Dead Redemption and Bully

Bully

Max Payne 1 and 2. Red Dead is quickly becoming an all-time favourite though.

"Toss up between Bully and The Warriors. "

definitely bully.

Grand Theft Auto IV.

" Toss up between Bully and The Warriors. "

I haven't played Bully or gotten more then 3 hours into GTA4. With that said easily RDR. Seems a lot of people really like Bully though so I might have to gamefly it.

Red Dead Redemption. I was expecting more of that in this thread.

Max Payne 2
 
Haven't played much of GTA IV but the little I have played has been very fun.

Does Lemmings count?

Grand Theft Auto IV or Max Payne (1 or 2).

1

To hard to choose

" Red Dead Redemption. I was expecting more of that in this thread. "

I really liked Bully. I even S-Ranked it :P But I'd have to say RDR is a bit better.

" @inkeiren said:

" Red Dead Redemption. I was expecting more of that in this thread. "

bully has one of the best settings i've ever seen in a game. RDR is a western "

Never played Bully but so far it's Red Dead Redemption.

Max Payne 1 and 2 for sure.
 
tho Bully would not be that far behind.

" @Laketown said:

" @inkeiren said:

" Red Dead Redemption. I was expecting more of that in this thread. "

bully has one of the best settings i've ever seen in a game. RDR is a western "

How much of RDR have you played? Not being confrontational, just wondering.  The setting is the thing I liked least about RDR. I do not like westerns. It really had to be a game that is great in every other aspect to win me over. I prefer the settings of all other Rockstar games. Every single one. I like RDR because of the gameplay, graphics, soundtrack, voice acting, and characters. "

Having not got my hands on Red Dead Redemption yet, for me it's a toss-up between Canis Canem Edit (Bully) and Grand Theft Auto IV. Both absolutely fantastic video games

Red Dead Redemption.  Before that it was GTA3 and Manhunt.  Never really liked any other Rockstar games.  Vice City was fun for the bikes, and not much else.

Vice City and the Bully

GTA (1) was fairly awesome in its day. I wasted a good chunk of my life playing that game. However, I believe Vice City takes it. 

Vice City

Red Dead Redemption. That's the only one I've beaten.

Max Payne series, Red Dead Redemption, GTA 3 onwards.

My fondest memories are of Vice City, loved the whole 80s thing. But in truth all rockstar games that I have played have delivered. 
 
Also are we counting Max Payne 1 and 2? Seeing as they weren't actually developed by Rockstar, only published.

GTA IV

GTA 3, but then again its the only that I played till the end. And Bully. But from what I've seen of RDR it will probably be my fave.
 
Do the Max Paynes even count? Remedy made them

So far, definitely San Andreas.

I'm pretty sure it'll be RDR once i've played it, though.

Top five: 
1: Red Dead Redemption 
2: Bully 
3: Vice City 
4: GTAIV 
5: San Andreas

RDR

GTA: Vice City.

GTA3.
 
Red Dead Redemption may have over taken it but it's still too new and fresh - I'll see how I feel about it in a year or so.

RDR for sure.

Smugglers Run

Grand Theft Auto: Vice City: 
Great soundtrack and a lot cool interesting characters + a ton of references to tv shows and movies makes this an awesome game experience. 
 
A close second whould have to be Bully or Canis Canem Edit as we call it here in Europe.