Orson Card is a fucking bigot. He is an extremely flawed man with loathsome views and I despise him for hating homosexuals. So, I boycott his books (at least since Ender's game). However, that's not a very complicated matter in the case of a book, because about as much of the profit earned is going to card is going to him as is going to the publisher. In that case, he truly is earning the profit that he doesn't deserve, because even though he is a great sci-fi writer and his body of work and his personal beliefs are completely un-connected, I find it noble the idea that people would not purchase his books to prove a point to people. Like being a vegetarian and boycotting meat, boycotting proves to a person that you are standing up for what you beliefs but it doesn't mean anything because you can't stop, or even slow, somebody from producing something when their is at least somewhat of an audience out there for it, which is the case for both meat and Orson Scott Card's novels. They both still have an audience.
Analogy aside, a game is a completely different matter. The game is based in Orson Scoot Car's fiction (let me prove a point here) so I'll say he gets 5% of the profit from the game (a complete and utter guess). The point is, it's considerably less in the case of a game than his novel, and the game is a great one which has none of the bigoted views apparent in Orson Scott Card's personal life. I understand the principle of the matter in the case of both the game and a book, but what it comes down to is that a fundamental level it makes less sense with the game. The game has a loose connection to the man himself, and as flawed as he is, it can't let you stop from purchasing what appears to be the best downloadable game yet released on XBLA.
As much as I respect what people are trying to do, it's not like Card is gonna kill a homosexual for each 1000 dollars he earns. It's understandable that people wish him to not earn anything, which is why the books are boycotted by many. But in the case of a game connected to his fiction in the loosest sense, which he probably had next to none involvement in the game and which contains none of the views held by Orson himself, it doesn't make sense because it will not stop his personal views because no matter how much people bitch, it will benefit him very little, and it will detract from the profit for a bunch of great people (assumedly) who set out to make a great game and achieved in doing so.
It proves nothing because earning less profit doesn't matter to Card because all he did was probably give his signature to earn a little money, and he probably doesn't care for how much money he gets because he almost no stake in the project at all. It's not good for Chair, and they deserve better than a petty boycott against a loathsome man whose fiction just happens to be a part of their game.
Also, go check out Christian Nutt's article on Gamastra. Quite good. Has some good points and makes for a good perspective on the whole matter (he is gay himself).
Log in to comment