Persona 3 FES ending (Mild Spoilers)

#1 Edited by Jeust (10650 posts) -

What did you think of the good ending of the Journey? Did you like it? What was your interpretation of it? 
 
For me it just sucked, compared to the rest of the game. The main character is supposed to die, so what are those final three days (including graduation day)? A dream, or did he suffer from a degenerative disease that killed him after a month? No explanation is given for it.  
 
It feels so disconnected... Well, that's what we get for a philosophical ending. 

#2 Posted by ZenaxPure (2569 posts) -

I assume you mean the pre FES ending (I think?). I actually liked it for reasons I just almost spoiled while typing this as I have no idea if you have finished FES or not. 
 
FES answered any questions I had, the exact reason for the graduation day scene put a tear in my honestly.

#3 Edited by Jeust (10650 posts) -
@Zenaxzd said:

" I assume you mean the pre FES ending (I think?). I actually liked it for reasons I just almost spoiled while typing this as I have no idea if you have finished FES or not.  FES answered any questions I had, the exact reason for the graduation day scene put a tear in my honestly. "

I finished the Journey. Yep, pre-FES.  
 
It felt like it missed some explanation. i liked it, but it doesn't bode well rationaly. Does the Answer explain the ending better?
#4 Posted by EvilTwin (3324 posts) -
@Jeust: No, not really.  The Answer is unnecessary and tedious.  I would highly recommend forgetting it exists.  As far as the main game, it's been awhile since I played it.  What exactly are you not understanding?
#5 Edited by Jeust (10650 posts) -
@EvilTwin: Supposedly the main character dies and seals Nyx. But then you are transported to a time a month after, where you can visit and interact with the other characters as the main. And it all ends with him closing his eyes in the lap of Aegis, as his companions rush towards him. 
 
So he died right after Nyx or got a degenerative desease that killed him after a month? Or was it a dream?
#6 Posted by ZenaxPure (2569 posts) -
@Jeust: For me, The Answer answered all my questions and yes it does explain the graduation scene better. However, like the above poster says The Answer really sucks, all it contains is the dungeon crawling part of the game with a few cutscenes here and there. However, I found the last few hours of it to be amazing.
#7 Posted by ZenaxPure (2569 posts) -
@Jeust: They made a promise to meet together on graduation day if defeating Nyx did erase their memories. He used the last of his willpower to seal Nyx but kept enough "life/power/energy/whatever" to keep his promise to his friends, once they arrived he had depleted the rest of his energy and died. 
#8 Posted by Jeust (10650 posts) -
@Zenaxzd: Hum hum. That should have been in the Journey. Without it, it doesn't make much sense.
#9 Posted by AndrewB (7617 posts) -

The ending to The Journey was great. Obviously sad verging on depressing, and maybe a little confusing (it took me awhile to figure out exactly what just happened), but its pretty awesome. That and the general tone of the game are among the reasons I tend to like P3 over P4.
 
They kind of shat on that with The Answer, breaking the characters to contrive a little more gameplay. In the end, I just watched the highlights of it on Youtube, because even the gameplay was stupid difficult and repetitive beyond measure. I'd rather wrap my mind around some of the things that seem like missing plot points than to go through that.

#10 Posted by ZenaxPure (2569 posts) -
@Jeust said:
" @Zenaxzd: Hum hum. That should have been in the Journey. Without it, it doesn't make much sense. "
I believe they wanted it to be somewhat inferred. The Answer doesn't really explain that point exactly, I actually read around on various message boards/wikis to fully understand the entire thing.
#11 Posted by Deadmanforking (577 posts) -

I loved the ending of the journey, I thought it was a very fitting end to that game. And I have yet to play the answer yet.

Online
#12 Posted by FluxWaveZ (19342 posts) -
@AndrewB said:
" breaking the characters to contrive a little more gameplay "
Huh?  I think the only character that was acting strangely in The Answer was Mitsuru.  What she did didn't fit her character at all.
 
I don't remember the details too well, but I'm pretty sure they explained why no one remembered the main character in the ending of the Journey.  And it's also explained why the main character dies in the Answer.  The Answer does clear up some stuff that happened before, but like others have said, it's pretty tedious.  I managed to get through it anyways.  It also delves in some themes that are heavily explored in Persona 4 (The Shadow within oneself with Metis/Aigis).
 
What really surprised me was that the MC actually died in the end of the Journey.  I innocently thought he simply fell asleep on Aigis' lap before that...
#13 Edited by Jeust (10650 posts) -
@FluxWaveZ: Yep, but the game fails to show how and when he really died. Did he died when Nyx spoke of him for the last time, or did he died on Aegis lap?
#14 Posted by FluxWaveZ (19342 posts) -
@Jeust: He definitely died on Aigis' lap.  Wait, why would you think differently?  There was no dream sequence or anything...
#15 Edited by Jeust (10650 posts) -
@FluxWaveZ: Because Nyx tells of how the main character understood the meaning of life, and how aegis would one day too. The meaning of life means also death.  And with all the weird things coming around, like the main character floating to Nyx, seems pretty far fetched for him to come back. 
#16 Posted by ZenaxPure (2569 posts) -
@FluxWaveZ: Believe it or not one of my good friends couldn't figure out the MC was dead at the end of the Journey, confused me as well since I thought it was fairly obvious. Also the whole Mitsuru acting out of character thing in The Answer is explained by herself (which I am sure you may remember, I am just pointing it out).
#17 Edited by FluxWaveZ (19342 posts) -
@Jeust: It was explained by Ryoji that after the coming of Nyx, no one would remember what had happened before.  I mean, the whole city had woken up from their floating tombs when Nyx arrived and every person living on Port Island would have seen the battle.  And Nyx is not the one who said that finding the meaning to life = death, it was Igor in the Velvet Room before the final confrontation.  That's what made the MC realize what he had to do when his team was getting dominated by Nyx, and so he floated like the messiah he was into the heart of Nyx to face it's true form.  With the support of his maxed social links backing him up, it was believed he defeated Nyx itself.
 
Skip ahead and everyone has forgotten what happened, just like Ryoji foretold, except for the MC himself and Aigis.  
 
I'm going to spoil The Answer for you, but the MC died because his spirit was literally being pulled and damaged.  He didn't actually defeat Nyx, as it turned out, and therefore manifested his spirit into a statue to prevent it from ever returning to the world.  But humanity, forgetting what had happened, continued down the path of darkness (basically humans are ungrateful, liars, bitter and wish for death subconsciously) and it became so significant that a huge ass shadow monster was formed: Erebus.  Erebus was the one who broke the MC's spirit-manifested-into-a-statue apart, as humanity called out to it so strongly.
 
Furthermore, Aigis does discover the true meaning of life during The Answer, and she does "die".  But, as it turns out, she just becomes a "real girl", making the mechanical part of her die.
#18 Edited by Jeust (10650 posts) -
@FluxWaveZ: I love spoilers! That's a nice wrap-up. 
 
But Nyx also talks about the main character knowing the meaning of life.  
 
In the end it's a weak ending for a main game.
#19 Posted by FluxWaveZ (19342 posts) -
@Jeust: I actually liked the ending quite a bit.  Especially the whole climax of the final ascent through Tartarus, that was freaking awesome.
 
And on the Persona 3 / Persona 4 tangent, don't you guys think that Persona 3 FES' Blind Alley sounds like Persona 4's Signs of Love?
 
 
     
 

#20 Edited by ChrisTaran (1610 posts) -
@Jeust said:

" @Zenaxzd: Hum hum. That should have been in the Journey. Without it, it doesn't make much sense. "

That is in The Journey, and I had no problem at all following the ending of Persona 3 long before I ever touched The Answer.  I'm not sure how there was any confusion at the end. 
 
Your also one of the rare people I've ever seen have a negative reaction to  the end of P3.  It generally has a very positive reception by people.
#21 Edited by Jeust (10650 posts) -
@ChrisTaran: For me it didn't explain when he died, right after Nyx - as Nyx itself sugested when saying that "he had understood the meaning of life" - or a month later on graduation day, and if he died a month later, why that happened?  
 
He seemed fine the day before... :p 
 
It seems a intellectual ending where some parts - plot holes - are left to the imagination and comprehension of the player.   
 
Being that the ending of Persona 3, excluding the Answer, would leave a sour taste on my experience. After a great experience with awesome cutscenes and a involving story, having such a disconnected ending is disappointing. 
#22 Posted by SpiralStairs (1020 posts) -

I loved the ending. It's my favorite part of the game. After all the work and connecting with all your team members so much, it feels like the game's way of saying goodbye to it all. It may have been vague, but I couldn't have been more satisfied.

This edit will also create new pages on Giant Bomb for:

Beware, you are proposing to add brand new pages to the wiki along with your edits. Make sure this is what you intended. This will likely increase the time it takes for your changes to go live.

Comment and Save

Until you earn 1000 points all your submissions need to be vetted by other Giant Bomb users. This process takes no more than a few hours and we'll send you an email once approved.