Gun to head wins

Edit:

Persona 3 MC. One word. Armageddon.

P1 MC because he wears an earring.

Makoto doesn't care.

I wish i was Japanese for once, so i could see the P3 Movie, hopefully we can get a dubbed version quick. From the looks of it there won't be any Robot Lady since it's only Part 1.

Also to get soiled school girl panties from vending machines.

Is this not what we all wish for? If not to sniff them but to wear them in our house looking at our self in the mirror?

Seeing how the Persona 3 MC is dead I'm going to give it to Persona 4 MC.

Stronger how? Charlie has a few feet up on the Bluekid.

Stronger how? Charlie has a few feet up on the Bluekid.

P3 dude has better hair and dresses nicer.

Given the fact that Charlie can summon his persona naturally, and P3MC has to use an evoker to force it out, I have to say Charlie wins.

Not only is this false according to Persona 4 Arena, but even if we were to ignore that game Makoto is able to summon his Persona in the real world while Yu isn't.

Yu has Teddie. Automatic victory.

Yu cross-dressed like a boss.

The P3 characters found a way to bring out personas, they explained it in P4A. If the P3 MC had

The reality is, both of them aren't much in the way of characters, but rather stand ins for the player.

He volunteered himself for it, though. It's not like he was defeated and forced into that position.

The personas you can make in P4G are waaaay more broken than anything in P3, so it'd have to go to Charlie.

Locking this down. We generally discourage these sorts of character battle threads because they're almost never produce meaningful conversation and often lead to people flaming/insulting each other for no reason.