CivIV:Colinization vs regular CivIV

#1 Posted by MrOldboy (868 posts) -

Well, steams got them CivIV and CivIII on sale, $10 for CivIV complete. But I think I only want one Civ game, either regular CivIV ($5) or colinization($7.50)
Can anyone specify what makes the engine different or the gameplay? I know one came out years after the other so I expect improvements in colinization.
I might just get the complete pack, $10. But I hate buying stuff on steam I never play, i.e. the Sniper Elite sale, why the fuck did I buy that?

#2 Posted by Azrail (404 posts) -

if u get one get civ 4 
it the game everyone loves and the most recent 
some do prefer civ 3 but i perfer civ 4

#3 Edited by MrOldboy (868 posts) -
I know, I was asking the difference between civIV and civIV: colinization.
I have civI3 somewhere in my closet.
#4 Posted by EvilDingo (589 posts) -

I've got both, and I prefer Civ 4. 
I actually don't know what it is about the new colonization that turns me of it, since I've played quite a lot of the original. 
However I do love Civ4 with all it's expansions.

#5 Edited by Donos (1193 posts) -

Colonization is a completely different and (in my opinion) far inferior game. Basically, you have to build several mini-cities is Civ fashion, and build trade routes and caravans and such between them.  You start on the east coast of North America, and NA makes up the entire game map (I think). After that, you have to constantly balance your own expansion against the natives who already live there (they don't want you to take their land). From there, you build up an army and become independant from Europe, which will send a giant angry feet at you. Survive, and you win. 
Basically, it's a smaller, more linear version of Civ 4, which are two aspects I really, really don't like. Now, if the option is just Civ 4 or the full package, I'd say the package is still worth it. Warlords makes some good gameplay additions, and Beyond the Sword has more/better music. Fortunately, you can toggle off any of the other changes you don't like (everything else in Beyond the Sword).

#6 Posted by Keenblaze (470 posts) -

I'd suggest getting the pack, really, since you'll probably be so addicted that you'll regret not getting the extra content when it was crazy cheap. 
Still, if you must only get one of those two, get Civ IV. Civ Colinization is harder and not as fun. Plus, you save $2.50.

#7 Posted by MrOldboy (868 posts) -

Ok, I guess the consensus is reg civIV. I'd get the pack, but I dont think I will ever play the expansions or colonization. I am a very amateur PC gamer, so I dont even know if I will ever play civIV. I played it a few months ago, but since lost the disc I got from my friend. I only remember it looking kinda bad on my 1080p tv, but I'll give it another go I guess.

This edit will also create new pages on Giant Bomb for:

Beware, you are proposing to add brand new pages to the wiki along with your edits. Make sure this is what you intended. This will likely increase the time it takes for your changes to go live.

Comment and Save

Until you earn 1000 points all your submissions need to be vetted by other Giant Bomb users. This process takes no more than a few hours and we'll send you an email once approved.