dankempster's Sonic the Hedgehog 4: Episode 1 (Xbox 360 Games Store) review

A Flawed Return To Form For The Blue Blur

Even the promotional material oozes nostalgia
In a lot of ways, Sonic the Hedgehog 4: Episode 1 reminds me of Mirror's Edge. Not the most obvious comparison to draw, you might think, but after a couple of hours playing the latest iteration in the Sonic franchise, the similarities were strikingly clear to me. Both games seem to offer the promise of free-flowing, momentum-driven platforming - the latter through acrobatic parkour, and the former through sheer sense of speed. Both games deliver on this promise a lot of the time, and when they do, I find them to be thoroughly enjoyable experiences. Unfortunately, both games also feature some questionable design choices that only serve to break up this flow and hurt the game. In the case of Mirror's Edge, it's those missions which prominently feature combat. With Sonic 4, it's awkward level design and a disappointing amount of recycled content that hold it back.
 
 Seeing this screenshot has reminded me that I haven't left Sonic idle yet. Must do that ASAP!
My history with Sonic the Hedgehog is a long and turbulent one. Alex Kidd in Miracle World aside, the Master System version of Sonic the Hedgehog 2 is one of the first games I ever remember playing. From there, my relationship with Sega's mascot took the next logical step - the Mega Drive. Some of my fondest childhood memories involve sitting in my parents' bedroom after school, playing the first three Sonic the Hedgehog games. Even now, those titles pretty much define a pure gaming experience for me, and I frequently return to them when I'm looking for something that I can just get lost in for half an hour. When my family made the jump from the Mega Drive to the PlayStation, Sonic and I parted ways for a good number of years. I missed the days of the Dreamcast, completely bypassing Sonic's move into the third dimension. It wasn't until Sega took the Blue Blur multi-platform with 2004's Sonic Heroes that we were reunited, and the reunion was not a happy one. Since then I've sworn off Sonic games, and witnessing the once-great figurehead of gaming's downward spiral from the comfortable distance of video game forums has been a very sobering experience.
 
So assuming we're ignoring the Sonic Mega Collection and Sega Mega Drive Ultimate Collection compilations, it's been six years since I last purchased a Sonic game. Now, in 2010, the tenacious blue rodent has once more managed to spin-dash his way into my wallet. The reason? Simple - the promise of a Sonic game that's returning to the series' two-dimensional, speed-focused roots. The promise of a title in the same vein as the old Mega Drive games was something that sounded both too good to be true and too good to pass up. So, on the day of the game's release, I bought some Microsoft Points and spent them on this downloadable title. After a few days' worth of blasting through the game's four zones, I feel like I'm ready to pass judgement on Sonic 4. That judgement is, effectively, "It's good, but it could have been something better".
 
 Considering this is billed as classic Sonic, shouldn't they be calling this guy Robotnik?
Let's start with the game's plus points, shall we? First up, there's the visual presentation, which I honestly can't fault. The game looks great throughout - each of the four zones on offer has its own distinct theme and feel. Enemies are all returning culprits from previous Sonic games, but in a lot of ways that's nice. I for one loved seeing the familiar forms of various nasties rendered in 3D. I don't think people out there who dislike Sonic's redesign will warm to the game's visual style, but I personally found it to be both faithful to the franchise and appropriately updated for a modern audience. The gameplay itself is tried-and-true 2D Sonic - a simple case of powering through a series of multi-pathed levels as quickly as possible, collecting rings and wiping out any of Dr. Eggman's robots that stand in your way. It's functional, it's fast, and most importantly, it's fun. Part of this is down to the incorporation of a Homing Attack, a new move that enables Sonic to lock onto items mid-jump and power through the air towards them. This simple addition brings an additional dimension to all aspects of the gameplay, making jumping sections faster and more fluid, and making enemies easier to dispatch. Its overall effect is one of streamlining the whole experience, and anything that makes the game look, feel and play faster and smoother is a welcome addition in my book.
 
Each themed zone is made up of three acts, followed by a boss battle against Eggman himself, so the format is definitely going to make those of us who grew up on Sonic feel comfortable. That being said, Sonic 4 also takes some big steps towards modernising the traditional set-up, making it feel more suited to the contemporary market. The biggest of these steps is an incorporation of a level hub, something that didn't feature in the Mega Drive games. This level hub has huge implications for the way the game is played - rather than simply powering through the whole game in one sitting, as you had to in Sonic 2, it's now possible to jump in and out at will. It's also possible to hand-pick any of the game's twelve acts to play individually. This makes it very easy to leap back into a previous level to earn some extra lives if a particular boss is causing you grief, or to go for that all-important level high score. While I was playing the XBLM version, I should also imagine this feature is a big plus in the iPhone version of the game, making it much easier to simply pick-up-and-play an act or two. It may not sound like a big deal, but it definitely felt like one to me. Throw in the now-standard widgets like Achievements and online leaderboards, and what you have is a Sonic game that feels true to the series' origins, but also relevant in the twenty-first century.
 
 I JUST WANT TO GO FAST DAMMIT!!!
Put all this together, and you've surely got the makings of a perfect 2D return for Sonic, yes? Well, not quite. You see, there's one crucial element I haven't spoken about yet - level design. To say that Sonic 4's level design is inconsistent is an understatement - it jumps from one end of the spectrum to the other with schizophrenic frequency.  This is where I feel my comparison to Mirror's Edge is justified. When the level design is geared towards maintaining momentum, and you're bouncing from springs and running through loop-the-loops at top speed, Sonic 4 really shines. Unfortunately, there are moments where the level designers deliberately interrupt that momentum by throwing in some form of awkwardly-controlled platforming puzzle, and this really tarnished my experience. To be fair, this happened to a certain degree in all the Mega Drive Sonic games too, but never as frequently as it seems to in Sonic 4. I appreciate that Sonic Team needed to find a way of providing that sensation of speed without developing a game that effectively plays itself, but I definitely think there was a better balance to be found.
 
Sonic 4 would probably be worth getting excited about if inconsistent level design was its only flaw, but unfortunately it's not. I took issue with a couple of other points while playing the game, the first of which was its musical score. Previous Sonic games have boasted incredibly catchy, funky soundtracks, and several tracks from the first three games are now seared into my synapses as a consequence. Sonic 4 clearly tries to emulate this, but fails horribly. The funny thing is, I honestly can't put my finger on the reason why. Maybe it's because everything sounds a bit too "clean" and "polished"? I don't know. All I know is, the music does nothing but grate, and I certainly won't be walking around humming any of Sonic 4's soundtrack to myself. Another, much more serious issue the game has is its overwhelming tendency to recycle content from previous Sonic games. As I mentioned before, this includes the enemies, but it's not limited to them. Each zone feels like a mish-mash of the memorable zones from older Sonic games - Splash Hill Zone is effectively Green Hill Zone in all but name; Casino Street Zone acts as the obligatory Vegas-inspired zone; Lost Labyrinth is a cut-and-paste of the original Sonic's Labyrinth Zone, complete with the same "endless waterfall" sequence; and the Mad Gear Zone lifts heavily from Sonic 2's Metropolis Zone. This rehashing extends to the bosses, too - every single Eggman fight in the game is lifted straight out of a previous Sonic game. You're getting very little content for your 1200 Microsoft Points as it is, so to find out that a significant portion of it is second-hand is pretty disheartening, to say the least.
 
in some ways, Sonic the Hedgehog 4: Episode One is a startling success. I certainly wasn't expecting it to deliver in all the ways that it does - it's definitely the fastest Sonic game I've ever played, with the sensation of speed far overtaking (no pun intended) the Mega Drive games. Its slick presentation, fun gameplay and updated feature set offer more than I'd expected to get from this downloadable title. Unfortunately, the questionable level design, appalling soundtrack and distinct lack of original content really do hold the package back, preventing it from fulfilling its true potential and reducing it to the status of being simply "another Sonic game". When you consider that you can buy all three Mega Drive Sonic titles on Xbox LIVE Marketplace for the same price as Sonic 4, you really have to question whether or not it's worth its asking price. Supposedly there are still two more episodic packs for Sonic 4 on their way. When they do eventually arrive, I'm hoping to see some better level design and more original content. Will it happen? I guess only time will tell.
2 Comments
Posted by SuperfluousMoniker

This is a great review, and I fully agree. A lot of people are crapping on this game, saying it has bad physics or Sonic runs too slow, which just leads me to believe that they haven't really played it or that they tried it, sucked at it, and decided it was the game's fault. The gameplay is good, and a lot of the levels are good, but the amount of recycled material and some poor levels keep it from being more than a three star game. But it's a pretty strong three stars, if only for Splash Hill Zone.

Posted by WatanabeKazuma

There were two things that got down about this game and that was the music and the bosses. 
 
The recycled bosses were pretty lazy considering they are labelling this as a true sequel, I appreciate added attacks but that wasn't enough considering.
 
If there was one aspect of the original Genesis games that I wish were recycled it would have been the music, most of it missed the mark for me, especially the boss theme which is horrible.

Other reviews for Sonic the Hedgehog 4: Episode 1 (Xbox 360 Games Store)

    A Fan's Perspective. 0

    It’s easy to get caught up in the zeitgeist surrounding Sonic the Hedgehog 4: Episode 1. For close to a decade now, there has been a dedicated segment of the gaming community who has pounded their fists in demand for a game that plays just like the early-90′s Sega Genesis classics. By all means, Sonic the Hedgehog 4 should have been the game everybody has waited so long for. Excitement was replaced by embarrassment, however, as many discovered the game was less “sequel to Sonic 3” and had ...

    8 out of 10 found this review helpful.

This edit will also create new pages on Giant Bomb for:

Beware, you are proposing to add brand new pages to the wiki along with your edits. Make sure this is what you intended. This will likely increase the time it takes for your changes to go live.

Comment and Save

Until you earn 1000 points all your submissions need to be vetted by other Giant Bomb users. This process takes no more than a few hours and we'll send you an email once approved.