Did SW:TOR Make You Find the Lack of VOs in Other MMOs Disturbing?

#1 Posted by Seppli (10251 posts) -


#2 Edited by Seppli (10251 posts) -

Whilst waiting on Blizzard to sort out the back-end for their Diablo 3 log-in servers, I got lured into the TERA Beta. Hey - it's happening at the same time. Better than staring at a log-in screen stubbornly refusing me entry. I kinda dug the core combat mechanics. Could have a lot of potential. I was instantly put off by the 'silent' NPCs though. I think Bioware poisoned the well for lower-production value MMOs forever. VOs or bust for me. Even if I don't actively listen to every quest in detail, marinating in its noise and information is much preferred over reading a questtext or not knowing at all what's going on.

Haven't played WoW since playing SW:TOR. Wonder if it'd negatively impact my perception of it aswell.

#3 Posted by The_Laughing_Man (13629 posts) -

Not all the voice acting was good. And some of it was the same actor. I mean ya its fully voiced..but some of its kinda crappy. Or the voice doesnt fit. 

#4 Posted by adoggz (2064 posts) -

Verily. First thong I noticed when I tried sto recently.

#5 Posted by ToxicFruit (1717 posts) -

Yes but i skip all the quest text in other mmo's anyway

#6 Posted by wemibelec90 (1629 posts) -

Not really. I've played more MMO's where it's just text so that still seems normal to me. I also started to get really annoyed with Old Republic and having to wait for the quest givers to get through their spiel before I could go and do it, so that might have had a negative effect on my opinion.

#7 Posted by adoggz (2064 posts) -
@adoggz
Verily. First thong I noticed when I tried sto recently.
Uh... no thong is exactally what I meant I was not trying to type thing and mistapped on this damn phone and its not like I'm using the moble site and can't edit my posts or anything.
#8 Edited by Jrinswand (1704 posts) -

I only played during a free weekend, but I actually couldn't stand the voice acting in SWTOR. When I play MMOs, I want to grind and kill stuff. I'd much rather have quest text, not so that I can read it but so that I can skim it and get straight to the killing stuff.

#9 Posted by spiceninja (3056 posts) -

It's made playing WoW a lot less interesting. But that could just be consequence of playing it for 700 hours.

#10 Posted by rkk667 (26 posts) -

It may not be voice acting alone. For me it is more that I get to interact with the quest NPCs and see my own characters reactions rather than just reading one piece of text. This can help give context to what you are doing also. Every now and then I actually laugh with the story - even if I don't get into the emotions of it I can understand motivations. The other nice thing about the quests in SW:TOR is how they lead into each other and form legitimate chains nearly every time.

#11 Posted by celegorm_menegroth (63 posts) -

As well done as SWTOR's voice acting was ( in parts ... it wasn't all fantastic, and some of it, and it's deployment, was absolutely horrid ) ... I think it all comes down to presentation and style.

What made SWTOR's voice acting work was that you were seeing some cut-scenes for major plot points in the quest chain. It was interesting to hear that done in a quality way.

However, the downside to that approach is that it's really off-putting to go through some sequences a second time. I got a serious impression of "I've heard this dialog ... and I have no interest to hear it again." Would I like to see how the Imperial Agent story-line plays out if I did things differently? Sure. Am I ever going to find out? Nope. Not interested.

There are other ways to do things, and as long as the game does it in an equally quality way, I'd be fine with it regardless of voice-overs. I can think of ways to do it without voice-overs that I would be interested to see if it'd actually work and be memorable. I'd prefer designers build their games with some originality ...

On a related note ... the stark contrast between the high quality voice acting and animations of the characters during dialog cut-scenes has always made Bioware's approach to how to deal with your "camp/castle/house/ship" an even more stark and offputting contrast than the bad or repetitive dialog sequences. I've seen my favorite companions/characters through the lens provided, and they have some personality. They move around and have an opinion. And then ... they do their best impression of a cardboard standee.

This imitation of decoration was actually sorta "plausible" in a world that was devoid of life. But, now you've given parts of the game life? The lack of life in other parts only seems more poignant.

#12 Posted by TaliciaDragonsong (8698 posts) -

Not really.
 
I'd like to see more voiced quests/events in MMO's however, like how WoW started to use it in Cataclysm but there needs to be more story focus in the future if they want to keep the gamer's attention.
I love reading through all the quest windows in Lotro or WoW, but I'm in the minority there.
 
Personally I can do without VO, but I think people will want it more and more eventually.

#13 Posted by WinterSnowblind (7615 posts) -

I think the voice acting was well done and did help the feeling that it was a big budget RPG and not just a typical MMO.

But it gets grating, it wasn't long before I put on subtitles so I could just read it myself and get through it faster. Having VO for the story stuff would have been enough.

#14 Posted by Marz (5648 posts) -

somewhat, while playing Tera Open Beta.... while there are a few cutscenes, most of it is just quest fodder i didn't bother reading... when i probably would have gave it a listen while playing SWTOr even if it's a mediocre quest.

Online
#15 Edited by Ares42 (2623 posts) -

I would actually say it was quite opposite for me. I needed to "prepare" myself for all the cutscenes in Swtor. If I had just played some random MMO and it started doing cutscenes like that I would probably just start skipping, as I (like almost everyone else) don't play MMOs for story. It's just not what makes the genre interesting. I gave Swtor a real chance at convincing me I was wrong (by not skipping a single cutscene on my first character), but it didn't succeed. I can confidently say I much rather prefer MMOs where I can just skip through whatever exposition there is, without feeling lost.

Online

This edit will also create new pages on Giant Bomb for:

Beware, you are proposing to add brand new pages to the wiki along with your edits. Make sure this is what you intended. This will likely increase the time it takes for your changes to go live.

Comment and Save

Until you earn 1000 points all your submissions need to be vetted by other Giant Bomb users. This process takes no more than a few hours and we'll send you an email once approved.