Star Wars Forum

Star Wars is a game franchise comprised of 107 games

Who shot first? Greedo or Han?

Topic started by Mikemcn on Aug. 13, 2009. Last post by Bucketdeth 3 months, 1 week ago.
Post by Mikemcn (1,667 posts)

Poll: Who shot first? Greedo or Han?

  • Han Solo
  • Greedo
  • They shot at the same time.
Post by RHCPfan24 (6,383 posts) See mini bio
1184 ACH / 24955 P

Loading...
I am just going to pick the straight answer and say "Han." Greedo was too busy worrying about his "time" with Jabba to shoot first.


Post by Fallen189 (1,489 posts) See mini bio
1289 ACH / 17649 P

Loading...

Online Now

It depends which version you watch.
 
It's Greedo however.


Post by HatKing (513 posts) See mini bio
1855 ACH / 34280 P

Loading...

Online Now


I remember one day on DVD is slowed that down to see who shot first really, and it was really close but somebody DID shoot first.  Thing is I can't remember who. :/


Post by WitchHunter_Z (487 posts) See mini bio
318 ACH / 2415 P

Loading...
In the original version Han shoots first, as that scene is a direct reference to the opening scene of The Good, The Bad and the Ugly. However, in later editions Lucas changed it so that Greedo shot first, to make Han seem like more of a 'hero', but it was done digitally and very poorly, in one edition Han's neck literally streches to the side, dodging the shot.


Post by ShaneDev (183 posts) See mini bio
745 ACH / 13795 P

Loading...
@WitchHunter_Z said:
" In the original version Han shoots first, as that scene is a direct reference to the opening scene of The Good, The Bad and the Ugly. However, in later editions Lucas changed it so that Greedo shot first, to make Han seem like more of a 'hero', but it was done digitally and very poorly, in one edition Han's neck literally streches to the side, dodging the shot. "
I always wondered what this argument was about and now i know 


Post by Lies (2,415 posts) See mini bio
790 ACH / 16075 P

Loading...
Han shot first.


Post by PeasForFees (1,646 posts) See mini bio
490 ACH / 7640 P

Loading...

Online Now

 Lucas says Greedo, But Han did Shoot first in the original Film


Post by Earthborn (30 posts) See mini bio
937 ACH / 19099 P

Loading...
Lucas shot first, and second, and third...


Post by LiquidPrince (6,898 posts) See mini bio
377 ACH / 4935 P

Loading...

Online Now

I'd say Greedo was intended to shoot first even if that wasn't the case in the original cut.


Post by The_A_Drain (3,216 posts) See mini bio
2301 ACH / 51325 P

Loading...
@WitchHunter_Z said:
"In the original version Han shoots first, as that scene is a direct reference to the opening scene of The Good, The Bad and the Ugly. However, in later editions Lucas changed it so that Greedo shot first, to make Han seem like more of a 'hero', but it was done digitally and very poorly, in one edition Han's neck literally streches to the side, dodging the shot. "

Wow that's screwed up lol. The version I have Greedo misses by like 10 miles the beam comes out of the gun at like a 30 degree angle and misses Han by miles. It's really silly. 
 
But yeah, officially, Lucus retconned it so that Greedo shot first. So Greedo did in fact shoot first.


Post by Bucketdeth (4,657 posts) See mini bio
427 ACH / 5145 P

Loading...

Online Now

  
  Skip to about 2:30.





Edgar
800 points

pyromaniac
126 points

dudacles
85 points

Lies
40 points

takua108
25 points


You are in Edit Mode. Make sure to save your work at the end!!
  • Submissions can take 24 hours to be moderated.
  • Please leave a comment to explain why you're making this change.
Save Changes Cancel