Does anyone not think this game is the greatest game of all time?

#1 Posted by Shane394 (138 posts) -

Because I don't really like it that much. I'm not here to argue whether or not it is a good game, I just want to know if anyone else doesn't really like it that much, like me.

#2 Posted by natetodamax (19421 posts) -

Who said it was the greatest game of all time?

#3 Posted by Fallen189 (5346 posts) -

It's the best game of the millenium so far. It's perfect.

#4 Posted by Djeffers03 (2537 posts) -

Im sure a lot of people don't think it's the best game of all time.

#5 Posted by Shirogane (3595 posts) -

It makes my head go totally whacko with all the weird gravity and camera stuffs. So no, i don't think it's awesome. Unless i wanted to throw up constantly, then yes, it would be the greatest game of all time. 
That and i don't like 3D Mario platformers, mainly cause i suck at them. 2D Mario games are awesome though.
#6 Posted by Hockeymask27 (3687 posts) -

I think its alright. I'm more of a Super Mario World kind of guy. I did like Luigi Mansion though.

#7 Posted by LiquidPrince (16532 posts) -
@Fallen189 said:
" It's the best game of the millenium so far. It's perfect. "
I disagree...
#8 Posted by Animasta (14827 posts) -

it is the greatest game of all time
I haven't even played it and I know it so

#9 Posted by Godzilla_Sushi (1149 posts) -

I don't even know if it's the greatest game this year after Mass Effect 2!
It's pretty gosh darn great though...

#10 Posted by ToadRunner (279 posts) -

if i had never played a game in my life, then yes, it would be the greatest game i ever played.
if i had played any mario game ever, you realize its just a mappack for smg 1.
pretty good game, nothing special. it wont be remembered the way galaxy 1 was, or the way super mario 64 was.
its just a solid platformer, but its not even top 5 platformers of all time.

#11 Edited by rjayb89 (7806 posts) -
#12 Posted by Rio (604 posts) -

Ive played it, its a great game...... it is no where near the greatest game of all time.  At least not by my standards.

#13 Posted by JJWeatherman (14804 posts) -

Yo, it's pretty good.

#14 Posted by JustinHopewell (52 posts) -

It's great, but calling it the greatest game ever is a bit of a stretch. It's doing some clever things, and doing them well, but not really innovating. It's not sparking any new genres or reigniting any old ones. A few of the levels are fairly forgettable, and I would love to be able to skip the "story" text. Above all else, the game hasn't been out nearly long enough to step away from it for a while and really compare its worthiness to the history of gaming in order to make an informed opinion like that. 
All that said, its still a fantastic game.

#15 Posted by TooWalrus (13344 posts) -
#16 Posted by CrossTheAtlantic (1154 posts) -

It's kind of incredible that the only thing beating the first Mario Galaxy on the GameRankings list is this and OOT. 
Still haven't played this one yet, though. Probably won't until about July.

#17 Posted by Mikemcn (7566 posts) -
#18 Posted by Halopower67 (199 posts) -

Nintendo seems to do this more than anyone, just look at Zelda too

#19 Posted by Whisperkill (3045 posts) -

I still think the camera is fucking retarded. 

#20 Posted by Hitchenson (4708 posts) -
#21 Posted by FlamingHobo (4769 posts) -

There is no 'greatest' or 'perfect' game. Super Mario Galaxy is no exception to this rule.

#22 Posted by danyul (32 posts) -

I just beat the game last night after I picked it up friday, and I was a bit disappointed. This game is the second highest rated game of all time, right behind OOT (it was actually beating OOT for a bit) and yet I still think Super Mario 64 is a better game. The best level in Galaxy 2 is a remake of a Mario 64 level, but no owl =( 
It was a really great game, Im not gonna bash it and say it was horrible or anything. It was tons of fun, and definitely a 5 star game. But best game ever? I don't really think so. The camera can be really awful at times, I had a glitch where it got caught behind a building on the pinata stage, and wouldn't move, even though I was on the complete other side of the level. Other times its just minor things that really screw you over when you need to make accurate jumps, or when you're on circular planets and the camera shifts, the controls do too, and suddenly youll find yourself going the complete wrong direction out of nowhere. Also, spring mario is just goddamn terrible, I dont understand why they brought it back, although its only for 1 stage. But they rehashed a couple other things from galaxy 1, including that flying bug boss, and a couple other bosses.  
The other thing I didnt like was that you never really feel like youve learned a level. Galaxy pretty much holds your hand, and as long as your going to the next launch star, your going in the right direction (save for secret stars, where you usually have to find a hungry luma, and theyre usually directly on the path your on). When you pick different stars, different launch stars appear to take you to a different place. It becomes a task of not figuring out where to go, but just getting there. It kinda kills the exploration of mario 64, where the only clue you had was the title of the star name. In Sunshine they added cinematics showing where to go, and that kinda ruined a bit of the fun for me. They still do it in galaxy. It makes the game less of an adventure, and more of a basic platformer. But thats just my opinion on the structure of the game, and maybe many people like it being the way it is. 
Either way, I had lots of fun with Mario Galaxy 2, and you should definitely get it if you have a wii, its a great game overall.

#23 Edited by Willy105 (4915 posts) -

Well, the consensus is the best game of the generation, but to say greatest game of all time is a stretch.
Either way, to say it is a candidate must mean that the game is crazy good.
 @rjayb89 said:

Final Fantasy VII  "

#24 Posted by vinone (157 posts) -

I love this game, I'm in aw as I play it most of the time, my jaw will just drop at times, I love it soooooo much.

#25 Posted by yinstarrunner (1260 posts) -

It's a really solid Mario game with fantastic level design and variety.  It's very fun.

#26 Posted by spankingaddict (2840 posts) -

Its one of the best!

#27 Edited by owl_of_minerva (1485 posts) -

There's no need to determine whether it's the best game of all time, because there's no objective yardstick for influence or importance. It seems clear that Super Mario Galaxy probably delivers as the best game of its genre at present. If what it offers is not for you then there are other genres and games out there.

#28 Posted by Dalai (7798 posts) -

It's gonna be one of those games that will always make the top 100, but best game ever? That's bordering on crazy talk and I frickin' love Super Mario Galaxy 2.

#29 Posted by MikkaQ (10296 posts) -

This game is effing awesome, but far from being the best.

#30 Posted by Drewbs (2794 posts) -
#31 Posted by ISuperGamerI (1972 posts) -

I haven't played the game yet but I don't think there is one game that is better than every other game in the world.

#32 Posted by SuperfluousMoniker (2909 posts) -

Game of the year? Looking like a strong contender. Best of all time? Nope. I'd put the first Mario Galaxy higher than this one... It's pretty clear that they were running out of ideas by the end of the game. It really starts losing steam steam around world five, and the special world is comprised almost entirely of levels ripped straight out of the first Mario Galaxy. The first four worlds are effing amazing though.

#33 Posted by WickedFather (1694 posts) -

I'm loving it but Mario Sunshine was a helluva lot more coherent and challenging, it's actually got me dripping for a bit more sunshine.

#34 Posted by Skytylz (4072 posts) -
@Mikemcn said:
" @TooWalrus said:
" @rjayb89 said:
" Obviously the greatest game of all time is either Final Fantasy VII or Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time. "
The greatest game of all time is Bully. Duh. "
Kotor, Duh. "
Yah, KOTOR.  I'd consider Ocarina too though.
#35 Posted by Allprox (618 posts) -

This edit will also create new pages on Giant Bomb for:

Beware, you are proposing to add brand new pages to the wiki along with your edits. Make sure this is what you intended. This will likely increase the time it takes for your changes to go live.

Comment and Save

Until you earn 1000 points all your submissions need to be vetted by other Giant Bomb users. This process takes no more than a few hours and we'll send you an email once approved.