So, a topic for people who've gone through the first chapter. I think it's in place.

As it's a game that had such enormous pressure to be of a same quality level as the previous games, has it succeeded so far?

My answer? Yes.
I love the graphics, voices, dialog, story and the humor as well as all the references. :)
I really enjoyed playing through this and laughed and grinned so much that it's unprecedented.
I've not done that since... since..  Curse of Monkey Island I think, it might even have surpassed that.

It was fantastic. I loved it. It was everything I hoped and expected from a new MI game. Now I'm impatiently waiting for the Secret of Monkey Island Special Edition, and the next episode of tales.

I loved the game as well.  From the opening lines to the final credits, this was a Monkey Island experience all the way through.  Another excellent game from Telltale.  I can't wait for the next episode. 

I feel like I got my money's worth, and then some! There is something really special about those Monkey Island games, I suppose it could be a spot of nostalgia...

I've been on vacation for one and a half week, so I haven't played it yet. But MAN I can't wait. Downloading from Steam now!

They did the franchise proud. I liked chapter 1 a lot. Can't wait for the next one :)

I thought it was great aswell, my only gripe is that is was sooo damn short. Im used to Telltales games lasting longer before the next chapter.