I recently made a blog post about my opinions of the Zelda franchise, and how I just barely completed Skyward Sword, meaning I've beaten every Zelda game. I didn't like it. I liked where it was going at the beginning with the characters, and some of the puzzles and things were moderately clever, but the game was kind of a mess.
This is all in response to an article that more or less sums up my entire opinion of Skyward Sword. The game isn't awful, but I didn't enjoy it. Here's the article: