So I just beat episode 5, and I gotta say, bravo for making the ending as bleak and depressing as possible. Even the first season's ending with Lee's death didn't make me feel as shitty as this, because at least in the first season you ACCOMPLISHED something. Here it just feels like everything was so pointless. Also, I really liked that flashback to episode 3 of the first season, talking to Lee again was pretty rad.
Anyway my choices:
I protected the Baby - Seems like a pretty logical choice, and I'm not surprised to see this having a huge majority.
I tried to cover Luke instead of running to save him - I figured an extra 70~ pounds over on thin ice wouldn't do much to save him, so I covered him in hopes that he could get out on his own. When he fell through, I did everything in my fucking power to try saving him, even smashing through the ice and nearly dying myself. If you DO go over to him, I wonder if you can actually save him?
I didn't ask to leave with Mike - Wasn't too happy about this twist. I threatened to shoot him, and was kind of disappointed that I didn't even get the option to do so.
I shot Kenny - Perhaps the biggest choice I regret this entire episode (the other being not to go save Luke), when I learned that the baby died, I tried to reason with him, but I knew that he was extremely mentally unstable already, so I shot him to save Jane, figuring I could just travel with her, since she is a LOT more sane. And then you learn the baby is alive, with consequently led to...
I am alone with the baby - Fuck Jane. If she hadn't have done that, I wouldn't have had a reason to shoot Kenny! I told her she was nuts and that I refused to go with her, so now I'm all alone.
Talk about a depressing ending though, the conversations with Kenny this episode were all REALLY good, and the last one when he was dying I even got misty eyed over. Poor guy went through so much, and I betrayed him in the end thinking I was doing the right thing. I kind of want to replay it to see if I could have actually saved Luke, and to NOT kill Kenny in the end. Overall it was a pretty solid episode, definitely one of the best ones in the season.