I just finished episode 1, and Duck is worst. His voice is like nails on a chalk board, and he's entirely useless (not to mention a huge liability).
However, whenever I go back over the situation in my head, I always make the same decision. I could never save a young, fully grown adult over a young boy, despite the fact that the former has already proven himself to be friendly and useful, and the latter equates roughly to 100 lb. bag of shit that talks.
The interesting thing is, I would never have bothered mentioning it, except that this is the only decision that I was 100% positive about in the entire episode. Deciding to give Irene the gun was one of the most difficult decisions I've had to make in a video game, and I still can't decide whether choosing Carley over Doug was the right choice.
How has everyone else's experience been? Are you finding yourself second guessing all of your choices? Or are you positive that every decision you made was the best possible decision given the circumstances?