As good as MGS4 was, it was overated. So you should take the 10 ratinh with a grain of salt. Never played the first Uncharted though, it's very tempting alright.

why are the reviews so early?

You finished it already? You rate it 10/10 then? Amd lolwtfbbq @ people complaining for scores over 8/10 >_>

" You finished it already? You rate it 10/10 then? "

holy shit don't complain about a 9.5 dude...
 
I kinda expected this game to get that high of a score from all the footage it looks great.

" why are the reviews so early? "

That is a ridiculously good review, good to know I won't be having to cancel my pre-order

IGN, I'm happy for you, and I'ma let you finish... 
 
...but PSM3 had the best Uncharted 2 review of ALL TIME!!!

IGN has some sort of a deal with Sony, I believe. They also reviewed Infamous and Killzone 2 pretty early.

" @Al3xand3r said:

" You finished it already? You rate it 10/10 then? "

He's a fanboy, one that cares about scores to tenth decimal. can't be satisfied with a 9.5, thats why giantbombs star system is awesome. "

Whoa whoa whoa, when is this game coming out again?

"The online is SUPER FUN!"    This guy knows what he's talking about!

" Whoa whoa whoa, when is this game coming out again? "

" @zombie2011 said:

" @Al3xand3r said:

" You finished it already? You rate it 10/10 then? "

He's a fanboy, one that cares about scores to tenth decimal. can't be satisfied with a 9.5, thats why giantbombs star system is awesome. "

I didn't mean it as a fanboy at all.I think you got it all wrong here Sir. But you wanna call me a fanboy... what ever douce. You see how easy it is to call people names.  "

How do you already know that Uncharted 2 is a masterpiece?  Please, I want to know.

The game looks excellent. 

"                                So they gave MGS4 a perfect 10 but 9.5 for this masterpiece.                       "

"

IGN has some sort of a deal with Sony, I believe. I also reviewed Infamous and Killzone 2 pretty early.

"

OK OK OK...soooo i got a little bit carried away here. my apologies to everyone. 

Waiting on gamerankings.

"what everdouce. You see how easy it is to call people names. "

God that train sequence looks like it'll be a blast to play. Hell, everything about this game looks like it'll be a blast.

" @buzz_killington said:

"

IGN has some sort of a deal with Sony, I believe. I also reviewed Infamous and Killzone 2 pretty early.

"

You are IGN? "

Wow, less than or around 10% difference from the average, which often is lower thanks to some pretty obvious hater reviews from lesser websites. What a joke indeed. Your opinion that is.

" @buzz_killington: If you are greg miller from ign considering you spelled actually amtually, I always wanted to say this. Everything is AAA according to you and not gamerankings. I take your site as a joke, for your over inflated ps3 and wii reviews. Resistance 2 was the worst game i've ever played and 87% on gamerankings, 94% on ign. Same with folklore and everything else you think is AAA quality like need for speed shift when it's down to 84%. Just wanted to say that here and now. "

" @Pie said:

" @buzz_killington said:

"

IGN has some sort of a deal with Sony, I believe. I also reviewed Infamous and Killzone 2 pretty early.

"

You are IGN? "

I am amtually Greg Miller from IGN.com. I am a senior editor for the Playstation 3 part of the site. I have reviewed many games, including Infamous and Killzone 2.  "

" IGN, I'm happy for you, and I'ma let you finish... 
 
...but PSM3 had the best Uncharted 2 review of ALL TIME!!! "

" @Pie said:

" @buzz_killington said:

"

IGN has some sort of a deal with Sony, I believe. I also reviewed Infamous and Killzone 2 pretty early.

"

You are IGN? "

I am amtually Greg Miller from IGN.com. I am a senior editor for the Playstation 3 part of the site. I have reviewed many games, including Infamous and Killzone 2.  "

Killzone 2 was reviewed by Jeff Haynes on IGN mind you, so, yah >_>

" @Pappasman said:

" why are the reviews so early? "

"

I'm still not completely sold because in my opinion IGN inflate exclusives scores.

I'm sold on the game, but because Uncharted 1 was great, not because of any reviews...

awesome, love it when reviews come out early.  9.5/10 from ign means that game is serious business.  good video review, and damn the visuals are insane.

Tomb Raider remade again??

Pretty damn early review, I still don't know if I'll buy it or one of the other AAA games coming out in October.

Guys just to clarify for those confused, I am NOT actually Greg Miller. That was just a joke.

" @buzz_killington: If you are greg miller from ign considering you spelled actually amtually, I always wanted to say this. Everything is AAA according to you and not gamerankings. I take your site as a joke, for your over inflated ps3 and wii reviews. Resistance 2 was the worst game i've ever played and 87% on gamerankings, 94% on ign. Same with folklore and everything else you think is AAA quality like need for speed shift when it's down to 84% on gamerankings. Uncharted wasn't even over 90% on gamerankings. Just wanted to say that here and now. "

I dont know.  The game always felt janky to me.  The control just didnt feel right, and when I played the multiplayer beta, it was just so unweildy.  TO each his own but for me, the MP didnt seem that fun and while I do think the game looks beautiful, something about the animation seems off.

I love the first game to bits and am finding the multiplayer demo brilliant as well. My excitement for this game could not get any bigger at this point in time.

I watched this review with someone and when we heard that it was 10 hours of single player she seemed really shocked and disappointed.  

I guess some people don’t get the whole, “quality over quantity,” thing.

Not me, this review just reinforces how excited I am for this game.

"  

I watched this review with someone and when we heard that it was 10 hours of single player she seemed really shocked and disappointed. 

" I'm sold on the game, but because Uncharted 1 was great, not because of any reviews... "