226 Comments
Posted by L1B3RATION

Nice

Posted by Blubba

Woo!

Posted by Torvec

bam, there it is

Posted by Vashyron

Whoo

Posted by GBH

the

vin man

Posted by LiK

ITALIAN STALLION!

Edited by Zurv

Did you finish deus ex (doesn't look like it on steam). my guess would have made it in your top 5!

Even if it didn't make your list. You should go back and play it.

Edited by buemba

Oh man, the Dark Souls bit was the best!

Posted by amir90

cool!

Posted by ThatFrood

Once again: Vinny is the fucking best.

Posted by Guided_By_Tigers

Wow another Saints Row: The Third GOTY.

Posted by nickux

Vinny, guys. Am I right?

Posted by Animasta

Looks like Saints Row is giant bomb's game of the year; it's already top on 3 lists.

Posted by Knives

I don't really get the Saints Row love on Giant Bomb. Not my thing.

Posted by Vorbis

Great to see Space Marine, Witcher 2 and Dark Souls make the same list.

Posted by phrosnite

I guessed correctly! Saint's Row: The Third FUCK YEAH! Also Space MArine! I love you Vinny.

Posted by fishmicmuffin

Vinny's Dark Souls reaction was hilarious.

Posted by BigSocrates

Once again a great conceit for the list, and yeah, Saints Row 3 looks like GOTY barring a huge upset. And unless I missed it this is the second list with no Skyrim at all. The variety on these lists is awesome too. So many great games released this year, lots of people are ready for new consoles but right now we are in that golden era where developers have mastered the machines and dozens of fully polished, realized, games are coming out. I kind of don't want to go back to lean launch title times.

Posted by Simplexity

Man I would have never thought he'd put Zelda at 1. That's crazy.

Posted by Seraphim84

No Skyrim at all? He must not've touched it yet. Here comes Vinny's 2011 game of 2012.

Saints Row may be topping everyone's list, but it's gonna be a brutal fight between that and Skyrim.

Posted by DeF

lots of things I didn't expect.

cool list and ...yea, that hair ... :D

Posted by Raios

I've really had no interest in saints row up to this point, it all just seemed too stupid. Based on these lists though I guess I will have to give it a shot.

Posted by Mutley

I have no idea how Saints Row: The Third is on three people's number 1 spot.

Its a good game, but I just do not get why these guys love it so much.

Posted by Mathey

Vindog RageQuit his Top Ten!

Posted by Flappy

Another Saints Row the Third GOTY? I can dig it!

Posted by Vegetable_Side_Dish

Space Marine, Dark Souls, Witcher 2?  
Love you!

Posted by Seedofpower

God yes, an Eisenhorn game would be awesome.

Posted by Zurv
Posted by Crono

I think Vinny has the most original top 10 of the bunch so far. Minus Saints Row of course.

Posted by Atlas

Alright, forget it. I'm done with GBs GOTY stuff. It's not just this video, but this is the last straw. I turned off the video as soon as I saw Saints Row: The Third at #1.

I'm being a bitch, a whiny little bitch, I know I am, but I'm out. Call me in 2012, Giant Bomb. It's been a great ride in 2011, and here's to more Whiskey Media goodness for years to come, but my taste in games is just too different to yours, and it's making me too angry seeing you guys overlook what made 2011 a special year in games for me.

Flame me all you like, because frankly, I deserve it.

Posted by OriginalGman

No Skyrim, all Saint's Row? That's why I love ya, Vinny. Now just give Skyward Sword another chance.

Posted by Bistromath

Vinny is my favorite Bombsmen.

Posted by TripMasterMunky

@Knives said:

I don't really get the Saints Row love on Giant Bomb. Not my thing.

That's how I feel about Bastion.

Posted by Scratch

Hmmm...the personal top ten lists so far seem to indicate that Saints Row might end up being GOTY.

Posted by Mystyr_E

@TripMasterMunky: ditto on Bastion. Haven't played Saints Row yet

Posted by RE_Player1
@Atlas

Alright, forget it. I'm done with GBs GOTY stuff. It's not just this video, but this is the last straw. I turned off the video as soon as I saw Saints Row: The Third at #1.

I'm being a bitch, a whiny little bitch, I know I am, but I'm out. Call me in 2012, Giant Bomb. It's been a great ride in 2011, and here's to more Whiskey Media goodness for years to come, but my taste in games is just too different to yours, and it's making me too angry seeing you guys overlook what made 2011 a special year in games for me.

Flame me all you like, because frankly, I deserve it.

This is the most ridiculous comment I've seen throughout this GOTY offerings. I pray you are joking because it sounds pathetic you need people to pick the games you liked in order to get satisfaction.
Posted by Daiphyer

THIS IS THE BEST! THIS IS THE BEST!

I AM MARKING OUT SO BAD RIGHT NOW!

Posted by Phatmac

VINNY!

Posted by Twinblade34

I'm not really on the same boat with giantbomb on Saint's Row.. its not that good IMO.

Posted by Troncek

@Twinblade34 said:

I'm not really on the same boat with giantbomb on Saint's Row.. its not that good IMO.

I am. Such a fun game from gamers for gamers.

Posted by Edmundus

Nice picks. Giving Witcher 2 and Dark Souls some love!

Posted by AngelN7

Awesome! Thanks Vinny for picking Saint's Row The Third , no im only missing the popcorns because Draaama is assured can't wait!, also SR3 it's friggin awesome I don't know what the big deal is.

Posted by MindOST

I feel that the running joke of "You should play Saints Row" has gotten into the heads of these guys a little too much.

The game's good, but they lean too heavy on the "Woah guys, you're a toilet, look how cah-razy this is!!111!!!1!"

Posted by TheSouthernDandy
@MindOST said:

I feel that the running joke of "You should play Saints Row" has gotten into the heads of these guys a little too much.

The game's good, but they lean too heavy on the "Woah guys, you're a toilet, look how cah-razy this is!!111!!!1!"

Or they just..ya know..like the game a lot. That's probably what it is.
 
Great list Vinny. I love you for giving Space Marine some love.
Posted by OneManX

@Mutley said:

I have no idea how Saints Row: The Third is on three people's number 1 spot.

Its a good game, but I just do not get why these guys love it so much.

I think it's because it's a really good game and everything seems to work, and it's just so much different from everything else around it.

Personally, I thought it was gonna be Skyrim-palooza, so i'm pleasantly surprised to see Saints Row 3 get some well-deserved love, for finally stepping out of GTA's shadow and creating a voice of its own.

Posted by KamasamaK

Lack of Dead Space 2 on the list is a surprise since the first was Vinny's 2008 GotY.

Posted by CptPanda29

So Vinny is Italian yeah?

Posted by Just_an_other_muffin

It makes sense why Saint Row is so high up on their lists. If you look at what these guys do for things like the live-streams and the Happy Hours it matches the kind of stupid fun that Saints Row the Third is.

Posted by GenesisZ

Holy fuck Vinny i know how you feel about that part in Dark Souls...LMAO at your mini dark souls rage.

Posted by Herocide

SPESS MEHRINES, TODAE THE ENUMEE IS AHT AHR DOHR