211 Comments
Posted by Red

Poor Jeff doesn't know the joy of Yoshi.

Posted by DavidMerrick

Patrick, you are wonderful.

Posted by Pabba

Those be fighting words!

Edited by Sarumarine

I know lots of people take it deadly seriously, but I am enjoying this Klepek-Gerstmann blood feud over the validity of Yoshi's Island as a good game.

Posted by ILikePopCans

HAHAHAHAHA

nice Patrick

Edited by MeatsofEvil

Now we wait for Jeff's rebuttal

Posted by 2HeadedNinja

God ... Ryan would have HATED this ^^

Online
Posted by Y2Ken

Oh Patrick. You joker, you. :p

Still doesn't quite top those upcoming Game of the Year notifications, though.

Posted by ShaggE

Tell 'em, Patrick! Help make Giant Bomb a pro-Yoshi's Island website!

Posted by RecSpec

Damn Scoops.

Edited by rmanthorp

Shots are seemly fired Jeff. Return fire?

EDIT: also nothing about this looks any good - FUCK Yoshi!

Moderator
Posted by chiablo

Nice job Patrick...

Edited by PimblyCharles
Edited by Scarlet_Rogue

Graphically this game just looks ugly.

Posted by MarkWahlberg

I've always found Yoshi and Kirby's eating their enemies and then shitting them out to be mildly disturbing.

Posted by Grievus

Did you see Shy Guy's face when Yoshi grabbed him by the dick and ate him whole?

No, no, that's literally what just happened.

Posted by patrickklepek

Graphically this game just looks ugly.

SHHHHHHH. Quiet! (You're right.)

Staff
Posted by ajamafalous

Man, Nintendo's totally lost it as far as naming games now, huh?

Posted by AssInAss

@chiablo said:

Nice job Patrick...

Amazing.

Posted by ghostyTrickster

I LOVE Yoshi's Island and the style in this one is.... poor. It looks like a mix of the Yoshi's Island style and the Yoshi's Story style and it doesn't work...

If the gameplay is there though, I'll check it out for sure.

Edited by planetary

Oh, god. I had forgotten about the 2DS.

Posted by aurahack

I really like the end where they just left the Youtube link boxes there anyways.

Edited by Tennmuerti

Oh you rascal you >.>

Edited by Shaka999

I'm so glad I got a 3DS now.

Posted by Tireyo

May look bad, but it probably won't be!

Edited by Fistfulofmetal

For being the best Mario game, Nintendo sure likes dragging the Yoshi's Island franchise through the mud.

This just looks super rough.

Edited by ShuaReborn

Time to get some popcorn. This should be good. :D

Posted by Dan_CiTi

Yoshi's Island is a game about speed and precision, I hope this game doesn't lose that.

Posted by blacklab

Ooooh, that was evil!

Posted by cloudymusic
Posted by KatyGaGa

Shots fired

Posted by Nentisys

DAMN BRO

Posted by MachoFantastico

Kinda with Jeff on this, the art style looks terrible.

Edited by LikeaSsur

Shots fired so hard.

Posted by Tyrax

Oh no, Patrick is going to be fired

Posted by Nictel

Oh the tears if Jeff actually ends up liking this!

Edited by Nightriff

That title got me to click here. Patrick this isn't IGN with Click Bait titles, ugh.

Posted by MisterMouse

Hahaha I love that this "beef" is continuing. I would love for a patrick and jeff quick look of this game.

Posted by jimmyfenix

#Teamjeff #Yoshiislandsucks

Posted by AlwaysBeClothing

Wah wahhhhhhhhhhhhhhh

Posted by Zamir

Posted by millionthlayla

I never played the original YI, but I played the DS version. I really liked the art style. After watching this, I have a question: what the heck happened?

Posted by Sup

Posted by DorkyMohr

The thing I like about the SNES Yoshi's Island is that each level introduces you to a new concept that expands on the platforming or egg throwing or other basic functions. They're pretty tightly designed and don't overstay their welcome. This was absent from the following games in the series, hope that's not the case here.

Posted by Terranova

there should be a bet of some kind if Jeff looses he should be made to do a Yoshi's Island endurance run and if Patrick looses he has to become a Yoshi's Island hater.

Posted by mrfluke

Edited by Redhotchilimist

Prrrffff, really happy about this description

Posted by SlashDance

Hey look, another completely original Nintendo product!

Edited by SovietofBears

The SNES version is prettier than this monstrosity.