59 Comments
  • 59 results
  • 1
  • 2
Posted by ComradeCrash

cool

Posted by almeida

nice

Posted by maa4208

I want this so bad. Sooooo bad.

Posted by Mesoian

Bloody Fingers ahoy

Posted by skrutop

Dear god.

Posted by JakeTaylor

Enough of this BS. GIVE ME POWERGIG.

Posted by Swick

Interesting, I think I'm in.

Posted by ApolloBob

Rigolopolopolopolous!
 
And the ubiquitous Drake.

Posted by Jayross

Power gi... Oh..

Posted by 234r2we232

Solos!
 
Holy fuck. Want.

Posted by Burrobean

Yes, please!

Posted by heatDrive88

Good grief, I'm going to be broke by Christmas thanks to this and god knows what else is on the games horizon for the rest of this year.
Posted by JJWeatherman
@skrutop said:
" Dear god. "
This pretty much sums it up.  :)
Posted by AURON570

so basically you can pay more to get pro guitar and play in pro mode, or you could just stick with your regular ass guitar and play regular ass rock band? sound familiar?

Posted by CookieMonster

 ROCK IT REA-oh wait... 
 
Anyways, how in the holy fuck are you supposed to read off the numbers for some of those solos? I really hope they put in a no fail mode for the real guitar part of the game.    

Posted by Tordah

As cool as this seems, I don't like the way they display the information with the same "scrolling down" style as the regular plastic instruments. This is pretty much a vertical way of showing tabulature, as opposed to the standard horizontal tabulature (that "scrolls" right to left as regular sheet music does) that can be found anywhere and everywhere.
  
I understand why they chose to do it this way, since that's what everyone has come to expect from these games, but it's NOT an efficient way of showing the fret information you need to know. I'm no expert on licensing issues and such, but if that's what kept them from using the superior horizontal tabulature then I guess I can forgive them. Granted, if they had gone that route they would've had to do drastical changes to the overall technical and visual presentation of the game.

Posted by HarrySound

Finally a why to ern achievements with my 16 year experience on guitar...bring it on! |m|

Posted by Rasgueado

I really want them to explain clearly why my synth-guitar won't work. It already has a divided midi pickup attached to the body, so it should be able to work the same way as this does.

Posted by Mikewrestler5

This looks cool, I guess. I do play guitar, so I'm not sure why I'd really want this.

Posted by mrcraggle

On the pro guitars do you always have to strum for it to register or can you fret tap?

Posted by Lumley

As a guitar player this looks so fucking awesome.. 
but it's so bloody expensive :(

Posted by CowboyBebopper

Day one. Can't wait to hate myself for this.

Posted by Zaapp1

I can't read that fast...

Edited by MattyT
@CookieMonster: @CookieMonster said:

"  ROCK IT REA-oh wait... 
 
Anyways, how in the holy fuck are you supposed to read off the numbers for some of those solos? I really hope they put in a no fail mode for the real guitar part of the game.     "

 A. You're expected to be able to play PRO (Hard & Expert, especially) based upon rote rehearsal and muscle memory, like traditional learning of a guitar. The real key once you're at that level is the chord names that appear to the left of the highway.
 
B. No Fail is a modifier that can be enabled at anytime via the overshell.
Posted by jonnyboy

That looks confusing as shit, why not just have a scrolling  horizontal tablature? That vertical setup is unnecessarily complicated.

Edited by garyoldman

yup I agree. I got a drum kit. I play it almost every day, and have been for 2 years now

Posted by langdon_alger

sweet jeebus that looks complicated.  wish i had the time to learn it.  maybe just pro drums for me, then.

Posted by MattyT
@Tordah said:
" As cool as this seems, I don't like the way they display the information with the same "scrolling down" style as the regular plastic instruments. This is pretty much a vertical way of showing tabulature, as opposed to the standard horizontal tabulature (that "scrolls" right to left as regular sheet music does) that can be found anywhere and everywhere.
  
I understand why they chose to do it this way, since that's what everyone has come to expect from these games, but it's NOT an efficient way of showing the fret information you need to know. I'm no expert on licensing issues and such, but if that's what kept them from using the superior horizontal tabulature then I guess I can forgive them. Granted, if they had gone that route they would've had to do drastical changes to the overall technical and visual presentation of the game. "

Harmonix has stated that they have explored multiple ways of displaying the tabulature, and that this was the most effective way from what they worked with. Also, the highway would be more constricted horizontally than vertically in the multiplayer setting. Plus, from a personal standpoint, it'd really eff me up to be drumming, and see one track scrolling horizontally in the midst of the other three vertical note tracks. 
 
I believe that in order  to display any horizontal tabulature effectively, you'd have to essentially add another vocal-type track. Furthermore, do you place the horizontal guitar track at the top or the bottom of the screen? Really, it becomes a big mess.
Posted by riffingt0n

Yeah I don't think you're going to be sight reading the Crazy Train solo in that setup.  But then I'm not sure you really could anyway.  I'm not that bothered about their notation since you'll only be using it as a reminder.
 
Again, if only they let you plug in a real guitar and fuck their left-hand positional technology.  Not buying another entry level guitar to play with a video game, and I may not buy the game at all as a result.  I love pro mode, but buying RB3 without being able to utilize it with their instruments seems like a tease.
 
I guess if you don't have a guitar and want to learn this sounds like a good deal, but otherwise it seems like a huge waste of money to play on (in many cases) an inferior guitar to whatever else you're already playing on.
 And if you want to play a real guitar along with Rock Band songs you can already do that, as long as you don't care that you're not being scored on it...

Posted by MattyT
@langdon_alger: It sure is complicated, almost just like if you were learning real guitar...OH WAIT, YOU ARE LEARNING REAL GUITAR.
Posted by siln

Love me some Rock Band, but every day closer to release it looks less like a game and more like work.  With all the effort that has clearly gone into this, is there going to be anything fun for us groups of dorks who play on medium or hard, either solo or in groups of 2-3?

Posted by MattyT
@siln: Yes, basic gameplay will still be there, along with the standard DLC releases each week. I mean, they're only coming out with 12 songs by The Doors as DLC at launch, with packs by Bon Jovi and Billy Joel forthcoming.  I play solo 98% of the time, myself, and look to improve my own scores.
 
Bottom line, all of the PRO stuff you're hearing about is ON TOP OF all of the Basic Gameplay offerings from Rock Band 2, instrument-wise.
Posted by MaFoLu

ROCK IT REAL?
Oh, Rock for real, okay.
Anyway, I really want that pro guitar now.

Posted by Tordah
@MattyT said:
" @Tordah said:
" As cool as this seems, I don't like the way they display the information with the same "scrolling down" style as the regular plastic instruments. This is pretty much a vertical way of showing tabulature, as opposed to the standard horizontal tabulature (that "scrolls" right to left as regular sheet music does) that can be found anywhere and everywhere.
  
I understand why they chose to do it this way, since that's what everyone has come to expect from these games, but it's NOT an efficient way of showing the fret information you need to know. I'm no expert on licensing issues and such, but if that's what kept them from using the superior horizontal tabulature then I guess I can forgive them. Granted, if they had gone that route they would've had to do drastical changes to the overall technical and visual presentation of the game. "
Harmonix has stated that they have explored multiple ways of displaying the tabulature, and that this was the most effective way from what they worked with. Also, the highway would be more constricted horizontally than vertically in the multiplayer setting. Plus, from a personal standpoint, it'd really eff me up to be drumming, and see one track scrolling horizontally in the midst of the other three vertical note tracks.   
 
I believe that in order  to display any horizontal tabulature effectively, you'd have to essentially add another vocal-type track. Furthermore, do you place the horizontal guitar track at the top or the bottom of the screen? Really, it becomes a big mess. "
Yeah, it could potentially become a big mess. I agree. But what about 3 horizontal lines (guitar, bass & vocals) and a vertical one on the right (or left) for the drums? I think that could work well, and it wouldn't be nearly as constricted as this. I think it's safe to say in 2010 that the majority of people own a widescreen tv.
 
The thing that bugs me the most about this system is that it's essentially impossible to read those parts with fast solo notes quick enough with the narrow and compressed vertical view. If those notes were displayed in the traditional horizontal form and came scrolling from right to left (much like they do in programs like Guitar Pro), then a somewhat good guitarist would be able to play it on his first try, even being totally unfamiliar with the song.
Posted by BenderUnit22

This shit looks scary as hell.

Posted by Curufinwe

Why did they pick that Filter song?  There's so many better ones.

Posted by MrKlorox
@Curufinwe said:
" Why did they pick that Filter song?  There's so many better ones. "
Cause it's the one that everybody knows, thanks to MTV in the 90's.
Posted by Shadowsquire
@Rasgueado: Your guitar may have midi, but how are they going to know what frets you're pressing?
Posted by nazer858

now I can rock for real?

Posted by toots

will buy
 
..oh wait i'm broke from my real guitar :(

Posted by TwoOneFive

that thing is freaky dude THE FUTUREEEEEEE

Posted by Distrato

Can't wait to buy the stringed guitar. Hate and like that its coming out later. I really wanted to play it on Tuesday but my wallet is crying right now anyway. 

Posted by HerbieBug
@Tordah said:
" As cool as this seems, I don't like the way they display the information with the same "scrolling down" style as the regular plastic instruments. This is pretty much a vertical way of showing tabulature, as opposed to the standard horizontal tabulature (that "scrolls" right to left as regular sheet music does) that can be found anywhere and everywhere.
  
I understand why they chose to do it this way, since that's what everyone has come to expect from these games, but it's NOT an efficient way of showing the fret information you need to know. I'm no expert on licensing issues and such, but if that's what kept them from using the superior horizontal tabulature then I guess I can forgive them. Granted, if they had gone that route they would've had to do drastical changes to the overall technical and visual presentation of the game. "
Yep.  You're pretty much looking at just memorizing the song ahead of time and playing along with the way it is now.  No way I could sightread like this.  It'd be nice if they implemented a horizontal version setup along the same lines as Guitarpro-style animated tab.
 
As a musician, I'm not at all insterested in the casual Rock Band games but this thing has me intrigued.  Not keen on the button guitar though, that just looks awkward.  For the midi Squire, I'm curious how the game will handle things like tapping and bends.  Will there be any notation for that stuff, or?  I noticed in the Crazy Train solo in this video, the tapping section is transcribed for 100% left hand fingerings, which is inaccurate to how that part is properly played. 
Posted by gunningyoudown

is the numbers the frets?  
 
I love the power glove its so bad 
 
wait.... 
 
i love the pro guitar its so bad

Posted by Tr4gic_H3r0

I think I may finally be able to learn to play guitar.

Edited by efbiaye

Price goddamn it! Price! :> 
 
PS. One of the achivements in Pro mode should be to replace a broken string during a concert ;p

Posted by Shirogane

I wonder how many people break the strings on the Squier within a week of purchase....
Posted by RVonE

Now this would be cool if that Fender was actually released with the game instead of next year.
Posted by Phished0ne

Still no glimpse of Llama......grrrrr
Posted by christ0phe

This looks difficult to read at high speeds compared to tablature. 

  • 59 results
  • 1
  • 2