MMOs and how change can wreak havoc

Posted by infestedandy (266 posts) -

 

 Dragons and fire. Classic combo.
If you asked me if a game could be changed for the better by altering its core, I’d say certainly. If you said the game was already out, I’d point and laugh. Titles like Star Wars Galaxies and Gears of War 2 are prime examples of forced adjustments and indecision before and well after they shipped. Once a game is being played by the people, modifying the central experience can be detrimental to the longevity of any title, no matter how popular it is. Cataclysm isn’t doing this.
 

Star Wars Galaxies went wrong by changing mid-drift to try and reclaim much of the user base that abandoned it. Skills changed, Jedi status was easily attainable, and it basically ignored its faithful users. Gears of War 2 was broken out of the box and relied on constant patching to fix and the unfix changes to the multiplayer. After six patches, the experience still wasn’t up to par and the result was a very different game than the one that shipped during the holiday season. Blizzard is certainly guilty of altering talents and other small quirks incessantly, but with Cataclysm it looks as though they’re breathing new life into the game instead of vice-versa. 

I’ve been out of the World of Warcraft loop for some time now. Actually, having left after Wrath of the Lich King hit I never really missed my adventures in Azeroth. I only say this because when it came to playing, my morbid interest was fixated only on playing excessive amounts of time and nothing else. But having looked at recent screenshots, talent and skill changes, as well as observing the facelift of the old world, I’m excited again. 
 

 Capital cities like Stormwind here have changed and, oh yeah, you can fly in the old world.

One of the craziest things that immediately garnered my attention was the complete revamping of the talent system. Now instead of going here, there, and everywhere you can only proceed down a single path until much later in the game. Some would argue that this ruins customization, but for me this shows the attention Blizzard has paid to making their already streamlined experience even better. As a warrior, I hated picking up five point talents and other little things like Two-Handed Specialization. Talents like that were just unexciting, passive numbers instead of something more dynamic. Granted, it is a numbers game but there’s no comparison when discussing present talents and ones of the very near future. 

 Reenactment of the multiplayer on launch day.


Even better was seeing the old world, my favorite part of the game, getting a facelift. Having played the game so much, I could never endure the leveling process again. But now that the scenery is new and the quests altered, I want to explore this familiar yet oh so different land one more time. Why is this though? The game is still the same quest and gear grind it always was. It’s just been refined into a shinier quest and gear grind and maybe that’s why I find it intriguing.

Accessibility means something but paying attention to your core means a bit more. Blizzard may tinker around with things here and there, but their changes have yet to utterly reconstruct the way World of Warcraft is played. That’s why the core of this game will never change, and probably why it still is the most popular MMO to date.
 
Enjoyed the article? Follow me on Twitter!

#1 Posted by infestedandy (266 posts) -

 

 Dragons and fire. Classic combo.
If you asked me if a game could be changed for the better by altering its core, I’d say certainly. If you said the game was already out, I’d point and laugh. Titles like Star Wars Galaxies and Gears of War 2 are prime examples of forced adjustments and indecision before and well after they shipped. Once a game is being played by the people, modifying the central experience can be detrimental to the longevity of any title, no matter how popular it is. Cataclysm isn’t doing this.
 

Star Wars Galaxies went wrong by changing mid-drift to try and reclaim much of the user base that abandoned it. Skills changed, Jedi status was easily attainable, and it basically ignored its faithful users. Gears of War 2 was broken out of the box and relied on constant patching to fix and the unfix changes to the multiplayer. After six patches, the experience still wasn’t up to par and the result was a very different game than the one that shipped during the holiday season. Blizzard is certainly guilty of altering talents and other small quirks incessantly, but with Cataclysm it looks as though they’re breathing new life into the game instead of vice-versa. 

I’ve been out of the World of Warcraft loop for some time now. Actually, having left after Wrath of the Lich King hit I never really missed my adventures in Azeroth. I only say this because when it came to playing, my morbid interest was fixated only on playing excessive amounts of time and nothing else. But having looked at recent screenshots, talent and skill changes, as well as observing the facelift of the old world, I’m excited again. 
 

 Capital cities like Stormwind here have changed and, oh yeah, you can fly in the old world.

One of the craziest things that immediately garnered my attention was the complete revamping of the talent system. Now instead of going here, there, and everywhere you can only proceed down a single path until much later in the game. Some would argue that this ruins customization, but for me this shows the attention Blizzard has paid to making their already streamlined experience even better. As a warrior, I hated picking up five point talents and other little things like Two-Handed Specialization. Talents like that were just unexciting, passive numbers instead of something more dynamic. Granted, it is a numbers game but there’s no comparison when discussing present talents and ones of the very near future. 

 Reenactment of the multiplayer on launch day.


Even better was seeing the old world, my favorite part of the game, getting a facelift. Having played the game so much, I could never endure the leveling process again. But now that the scenery is new and the quests altered, I want to explore this familiar yet oh so different land one more time. Why is this though? The game is still the same quest and gear grind it always was. It’s just been refined into a shinier quest and gear grind and maybe that’s why I find it intriguing.

Accessibility means something but paying attention to your core means a bit more. Blizzard may tinker around with things here and there, but their changes have yet to utterly reconstruct the way World of Warcraft is played. That’s why the core of this game will never change, and probably why it still is the most popular MMO to date.
 
Enjoyed the article? Follow me on Twitter!

#2 Posted by ConfuciusOne (46 posts) -

I recently resubbed and have been pushing my main towards the loremaster achievement.  I used to play a lot, well that may be an understatement.  Let's just say I have several years of playtime spread across a few different characters.  Anyway, I've been so far removed from all the leveling content in my constant search for better loot, that I've all but forgotten what it felt like when I took my first steps into Azeroth as a Night Elf warrior.  I started cleaning up quests in Ashenvale yesterday and it hit me like a truck.  I started remembering everything that WoW used to be, some for the bad, some for the better.  Some quests have been tweaked and I sure do miss world PvP, it's still kind of weird to see level 20's on riding mounts and such.  I'm having a really good time just doing that and not really being in a guild, raiding, running dungeons etc.  I'm sure the time will come but for now, I'm content just living in the past. 
 
Maybe it's the masochist in me, but I'm really considering leveling another toon from scratch just to see all the old content again.

#3 Posted by thehexeditor (1404 posts) -

"The more things change, the more they stay the same." -Snake Plissken
  After obsessing over the changes they are making to the game, I find that this quote summarizes my opinion on Cataclysm these days.

#4 Posted by JCTango (1360 posts) -

SWG remains the best example of what NOT to do to an MMO.

This edit will also create new pages on Giant Bomb for:

Beware, you are proposing to add brand new pages to the wiki along with your edits. Make sure this is what you intended. This will likely increase the time it takes for your changes to go live.

Comment and Save

Until you earn 1000 points all your submissions need to be vetted by other Giant Bomb users. This process takes no more than a few hours and we'll send you an email once approved.