tornadocreator's World of Warcraft: Cataclysm (PC) review

  • Score:
  • tornadocreator wrote this review on .
  • 2 out of 4 Giant Bomb users found it helpful.

Is Cataclysm Catastrophic?


World Of Warcraft. It's a game that is already more popular than God and if you've stuck with it to get to level 80, you're unlikely to leave any time soon and this review is unlike to change anyones mind, but is Cataclysm a fantastic addition or an abysmal failure? That's honestly hard to judge and it depends on how you're approaching the game.

I like to keep my reviews short and to the point, to review for the every-man and give an impression of the game. After all, while an in depth analysis may serve a purpose, I'm sure you'd like to play the game for yourself without me describing the whole thing, unfortunately WoW is so massive, a short review is near impossible so I'm going to cut it down to three main areas:-

The Good:

1. First of all, balance. Every class is now balanced and plays beautifully with them all having distinct flavours and roles. It's no longer a matter of following the only talent build worth bothering with for your class any more. Now all the classes and all the trees have a decent range of abilities and fit in well. This does however mean that now Paladins aren't an immediate “I Win” button, which quite frankly is about bloody time.

2. If you where ever planning on starting an MMO but never got around to it, now is the time to start World Of Warcraft. The starting areas and quests for levels 1-40 have been completely revamped and they are very well written. They have a nice story element, they make sense, and they have quite seriously reduced the amount of pointless grinding needed. Levelling now, even solo, is very enjoyable.

3. Guilds now serve a much larger purpose and it fosters a sense of community. Whether you want a competitive PVP-Raid guild on a standard server or a theme based roleplayers guild on an RP server, it seems the guilds are much more capable of catering to the needs of the players now, and while this is more a community thing than anything else, the addition of the Goblins has greatly increased the non-combat based roleplaying on the Horde side for those who want to play merchants and artisans on the RP servers.

4. The style and scope of this game is beautiful. It's very well designed and awe inspiring to look at, and with the fullscreen window mode added in, it means those who prefer playing in windowed mode, to allow things to run in the background, can enjoy the graphics and designs at full resolution. The design changes to places like Orgrimmar and Thousand Needles are nicely implemented and thought out, but will take some people time to get used to.

The Bad:

1. With more balance came total railroading. It's now impossible to make a bad build on WoW. You're locked into your talents from the get go, cannot spread your points across multiple trees, have too few options to distinguish yourself with and as a result your Frost Mage will be like every other Frost Mage, and so will your Shadow Priest, Survival Hunter and Protection Paladin. Cookie cutter couldn't be more appropriate. The game even throws the correct equipment at your feet so you'll never need to worry about being poorly equipped for your level... it does however mean a simple computer program could play this game and get much the same result as a human being. Don't expect to think when playing this game any more. WoW was never intended to be a game that required a lot of strategy but at this point tic-tac-toe seems to require more thought.

2. What a profound waste of time. This is the exact feeling you'll get when you look back at the really rare loot and pile of emblems you worked your ass off for in Wrath. Why? Because ten minutes into Cataclysm the first green magic items you pick up will make all your rares and legendaries completely obsolete. Welcome back to mediocrity, those hundreds of hours in arenas and dungeons spent making your character competitive can be rendered entirely pointless by any level 81 character with a spare half-hour.

3. I hope you have a powerful computer. WoW has become a processor and graphics glutton, and if you're running with Vista expect to be crying should you ever find yourself in world PVP defending a major city on a PVP server. Unless you have at least 4GB of RAM, a 2.2GHz Processor and a GeForce 9 Series or better graphics card, expect lag, even on the lower graphics setting, unless you're on a low-population server. Considering this time last year WoW could run on 512MB of RAM with a 1.4GHz Processer and a GeForce 5 Series graphics card with only slight lag, this is a major oversight on the part of Blizzard who risk alienating everyone who hasn't invested in a proper gaming PC, you now officially need a more powerful PC for World Of Warcraft than you do for Oblivion or Fallout 3, and that's not a good thing.

The Conclusion:

So, is it worth it? It all depends, if you've never played WoW before, this is a great change, and you'll really enjoy levelling and going through the storylines. The game is popular for a reason and they have made the game much better for those starting out however if you're an old WoW player you're likely going to find this expansion restrictive and rather disappointing. Honestly, at this point my advice would be to give this a miss. If you're new to the game pick up the very cheap World Of Warcraft and the first expansion Burning Crusade and enjoy playing though to level 70, because the vast majority of the new content is patch content for the lower level areas anyway. The expansion specific stuff, is simply not worth the cash unless you're already invested in the Warcraft world, in which case the lack of customisation may drive you away. This expansion is a strange beast. The expansion itself is really disappointing, but it may well bring enough life back to the vanilla game to make that ironically worth looking at again.

Posted by Baziel

Bad part number 3 is just not true. I only have 2 gigs of ram  and an 8800 video card with vista ( 3.5 year old pc) and I can run everything on max settings just fine with no lag to speak of. I am also on a high population server.

Edited by TornadoCreator
Then you're lying. I play on both Argent Dawn EU and Ravenholdt EU, a high population RP and medium population RP-PVP server respectively and I get lag in major cities like Orgrimmar or Dalaran in Argent Dawn or if there's a big world PVP event on in Ravenholdt if I have the graphics even on high, forget ultra. I have an Intel Core 2 Duo T6600 2.2 GHz Processor, 4GB of RAM, NVIDIA GeForce G210M Graphics Card and Windows 7 with DirectX11. That's better than your computer in every way that matters and I play on medium graphics because if I use high I lag, not often, but enough that it matters. On top of that, an 8800 video card and 2GB of RAM is physically incapable of running WoW on the "ultra" setting, which is the setting above high, and what I assume you mean by "max". I wrote this review from experience, I'm hardly going to make shit up just for the hell of it now am I.
Edited by Baziel

Not  gonna argue with you or anything, but I'm not telling any lies. Maybe there's something wrong with your computer and you should get it checked out because I manage to run it fine with my pc that's less good.
edit: Just checked online. 8800 is better than  g210m so there you go I guess.

Posted by TornadoCreator
I re-read this review after someone gave it a thumbs up an noticed you'd responded again but for some reason I didn't respond. Perhaps I couldn't be arsed. Well, I'm responding now. First of all, I know there's nothing wrong with my computer, it can run Fallout 3, Civilization 4 and EVE Online all fine and I'm tech savvy enough to actually know when something goes wrong. 
Second point, you're graphics card isn't better. the Nvidia GeForce 8800 is a 384 MB RAM on 64-bit bus, the G210M however is 512 MB RAM also on a 64-bit bus but with twice the bandwidth and 4 times the clock speed, which is expected as the 8800 was a Nov 2006 released card, where as the G210M was a June 2009 released card... something tells me that in 3 yeard, graphics cards made by the same company probably improved somewhat.
Now, if you weren't trolling and just made a mistake, fine, but posting that you play WoW on "max" with a 5 year old graphics card on only 2 GB of RAM is called fucking lying and it screams a troll to me. I suggest you pick someone who doesn't know what they're talking about in future when you try to make them look like a fool otherwise you only end up pwning yourself.
Posted by Baziel

Not agreeing with you does not mean I am a troll.
Anyway, 8800 series cards go upto 768mb ram I believe. Mine however has 640mb and not 384mb like you claim. Guessing WoW needs more memory instead of gpu power or something, I dunno.
I don't really care what you think of me or say that I am lying even tho I am not tbh.
By now both cards are pretty shit so who cares? I can run wow on max settings and I'm happy with that, wether you believe me or not is of no importance to me. 
Have a nice day.

Edited by TornadoCreator
Yes, the later 8800 GT and GX onwards cards can go higher that 384 MB, but that's not the point, even with the best 8800 card avaliable you still can't run WoW on max settings. The point is unless you have 1GB of Graphics and at least 4GB RAM (I'd say you'd realistically need 6GB RAM on high population servers or you'd suffer lag), and at least a 2.6GHz Processor you cannot run WoW on "max". YOU ARE LYING! Even with the best 8800 series card, and no other programs running in the background it is IMPOSSIBLE to play WoW on max setting with only 2GB of RAM. This is a fact, not just me disagreeing with you. I'm not claiming a difference of opinion here, I'm pointing out that you are simply wrong and you know you're wrong, therefore you're a troll. 
So what now? You can either admit that you're wrong, stop commenting, or keep digging... either way, you're only making yourself look stupid if you carry this on. There isn't a single person who will read this and think, "Oh, the Baziel knows what he's talking about" because you're knowledge of computer hardware is clearly nothing more than what you can get off google/wikipedia in 5 mins. Now stop this pointless posturing. I don't even know why you bothered commenting in the first place when your first comment is so obviously a lie to every WoW player. We've all been at the mercy of lag, and if all it took was 2GB of RAM and an 8800 Graphics Card no-one would ever lag again. Think about it.
Posted by Baziel

So what now? Well, you believe what you want to believe and I'll just carry on not caring what that is. 
Good day to you sir.

Other reviews for World of Warcraft: Cataclysm (PC)

    A must play for anyone who loves rewarding teamplay. 0

        So yeah the third expansion from Blizzard Entertainment has hit the shelves a week back (December 7th) and it is more epic then I could imagine. This expansion brings back awesome team-play in both PvE and PvP and makes it more challenging, thus more enjoyable then ever before.   World of Warcraft: Cataclysm is the game I'm talking about of course. Being a big fan of the series I pre-ordered this baby on and was online in less then 1 hour after the launch time. The transitio...

    1 out of 2 found this review helpful.

This edit will also create new pages on Giant Bomb for:

Beware, you are proposing to add brand new pages to the wiki along with your edits. Make sure this is what you intended. This will likely increase the time it takes for your changes to go live.

Comment and Save

Until you earn 1000 points all your submissions need to be vetted by other Giant Bomb users. This process takes no more than a few hours and we'll send you an email once approved.