rachelepithet's WWE All Stars (PlayStation 3) review

Retro meshed well with modern; pick up n' play done right.

Let's cross off the first and foremost bulletin point of any THQ wrestling game, hell, the  "THQ Wrestling Game Promise" if you will: All Stars has broken online gameplay. Must you know how they've done it this time? Certainly, you can connect to other human beings over the Internet, so it beats that Xbox WrestleMania title by a default. In this game, however, it's lagging network code, followed by unblock-able, irreversible combos that assure if you don't get the very first hit in an online match you've already lost.

It's as if either THQ or the WWE fails to throw enough money at their product for focus testing, polishing, quality assurance, you name it. No surprise that they shut down the division that produced this game. It's probably because they spent too much and did too much right by everything else about the game (besides the online) that they put THQ's other grappler "WWE '12" to shame.

While it can be repetitive, and you'll wish they made more retro promos than the spectacular Undertaker & Paul Bearer one, WWE All Stars is a knife through the air of the stagnant RAW franchise THQ has been churning out since 2004. Gone is the methodical pacing, as well as the overdose of moves, button configurations, mini games, and area of effect systems. All Stars is a return to form of the original SmackDown! PSX games, or the In Your House arcade game, maybe even WWF Attitude for the N64. Fast, simple, fun. Winning and losing sort of happens like a Mortal Kombat or Street Fighter game; it's all about timing. Strategy comes down to, "Am I gonna grapple now because he's expecting a strike?" This simple gameplay engine is nearly flawless, and is what separates this game from such garbage as Legends of Wrestling that delivered old school characters without a decent game to back 'em up.

WWE All Stars is a terrific budget game.  It sacrifices such malarkey as awkward, dialed in, voice over filled career modes, make-your-own finishing moves, choose your adventure story-lines, as well as the ability to fight in the arena crowd or parking lot. But this game spices things up by capturing the nostalgia of 80's and 90's wrestlers and making them fit in with contemporaries, all in a game that's easy to pick up and play but challenging enough where victories aren't guaranteed.

0 Comments

Other reviews for WWE All Stars (PlayStation 3)

    Would of been 5 stars if.... 0

    The Create a Wrestler mode was better.....this game is great for Nostalgic wrestling fans and fighting game lovers as well. The Create a Wrestler in Legends of Wrestle Mania was better, but thats because it was the same system used by the current SD vs RAW team, this game is made by former Midway and Acclaim wrestling game makers.  While this is good in move animation and cut scene animation, it blows for stiff action figure style wrestling....reminds me of when LJN, one of WWE's older action fi...

    2 out of 8 found this review helpful.

This edit will also create new pages on Giant Bomb for:

Beware, you are proposing to add brand new pages to the wiki along with your edits. Make sure this is what you intended. This will likely increase the time it takes for your changes to go live.

Comment and Save

Until you earn 1000 points all your submissions need to be vetted by other Giant Bomb users. This process takes no more than a few hours and we'll send you an email once approved.