@Murdouken: This thread is relevant to my interests since I just got my first 360 earlier in the month. I'm primarily a PC gamer myself. I bought mine almost exclusively so I could play Dark Souls and Skate 3, but now I've been reminded that I can finally play RDR. I'll have to get on that. Oh also Rock Band. I have never owned any instrument peripheral game.
I just ordered my first Xbox 360.
The weirdest reintroduction to console games you could choose is Deadly Premonition. The controls will probably feel nonsensical to you; however, when you're done with it, you will be able to play any game for the console AND you'll have had a good time.
EDIT: Ooh, and nobody mentioned Trials HD. That game is sweet.
Fable2 & Shadow Complex are both pretty good. Other good ones that I can think of but you might have played them on pc, Battlefield series (bad company or just battlefield3), bayonetta, bioshock, banjo kazooie nuts & bolts, mass effect 1 & 2, saints row3, deadly premonition, mortal kombat, fear2, 50 cent blood on the sand, amped3, dead space 1 & 2, left4dead 1 & 2, singularity, marvel ultimate alliance, fallout new vegas, just cause2, crysis2. GLHB & if looking for people on the site on XBox Live feel free to add me (fox01313).
This edit will also create new pages on Giant Bomb for:Beware, you are proposing to add brand new pages to the wiki along with your edits. Make sure this is what you intended. This will likely increase the time it takes for your changes to go live.