vidiot's Ryu ga Gotoku 3 (PlayStation 3) review

Even with cuts, Kazuma will still crush your face.

Where the hell do I begin? 
 
To talk about Yakuza 3, one has to immediately begin divulging on the sad history of this series: Specifically how it's been handled outside of it's native Japan. Even if you have a little to no interest in the game, you probably have read the stories of a little company called Sega, and it's confusing relationship with little game franchise it owns called Yakuza.
 

         
Yakuza, or Ryū ga Gotoku (“Like a Dragon”) as it's known in Japan has almost become an event. Since the series debut in 2005 a new entry in the series has been released roughly once a year. While we are just getting Yakuza 3 now, Yakuza 4, I kid you not, was just released a few weeks ago. It's currently number one in the charts over there, it was coupled by a massive ad campaign. If you include the side-story prequel that takes place in feudal Japan, the franchise has had five very successful entries. Only three have been released outside of Japan as of writing.

 
To understand Yakuza's massive success in Japan, compared to it's almost grass-roots word of mouth fan base over here, we really do have to examine and define what the franchise really is. We also have to accept the fact that it will never probably be as rabidly successful as it is in it's native country. 
 
We also have to accept that that's not a bad thing.

(Notice: The following is a bit of a rant. If you want to get to the meat of this review skim down, although I find the circumstances of what has happened to this series important to the actual game. There's a bunch of opinion that follows here. (*Activates Flameshield*)
 

 

The first time I read about the Yakuza franchise in a gaming publication, the description read that it was considered to be “The Japanese GTA”.

This statement is, and has always been, ludicrously false.

To proclaim such a statement, is similar to proclaim that Metroid Prime is like Quake, because of their similar first-person perspectives.

  • Yakuza has a mini-map.
  • Yakuza has an open-world hub, where you might wander and deviate from the main story.
  • Yakuza's storyline is dark and deals with crime syndicates.

Having a mini-map doesn't equate your game to GTA. Stop doing that.

To consider that these three concepts are married to the opinion that, “it's like GTA”, has always alluded me. The only situation I have barely come to accept: Would be if you were in a hurry, and needed to describe the game to the uninitiated non-gamer. Why would anyone describe the Yakuza series comparable to GTA is beyond me. Even the name: “GTA: GRAND THEFT AUTO” implies that vehicles of some-sort will be utilized, and in this case stolen. Yakuza has no such comparable mechanics or design. Such comparisons are false.
 
Instead you will wander around fantastic recreations of Tokyo and Okinawa. You will occasionally stop and fight in a random battles. You will complete side-stories and equip weapons and armor. You will gain experience, sometimes grinding at certain spots (both enemy encounters and side-stories.) before continuing through the main story.
 
Yakuza 3 is a goddamn JRPG.
 
When I use the word “goddamn”, I do not mean to imply distaste. Instead, consider this a new proclamation. One imbued with both the obvious, and a hint of exhausted annoyance. 
 
What's even more confounding is that remnants of the development team worked on the Shenmue franchise, and one could easily argue that the Yakuza series is a spiritual successor to Shenmue.
 
Did you describe Shenmue, as a “Japanese GTA” game to the uninitiated?
 

 Kazuma is unfazed from the madness.

When the franchise was first released overseas, the marketing campaign that went along with it reflected the false “Japanese GTA” concept. The localization followed in similar style, with the original Japanese audio track being removed and a universally panned English dub. In retrospect, the dub was not terrible when compared to other endeavors, but it was out of place. The story of Yakuza is not presented in the same style of something akin to anime, but more akin to a foreign film. To watch these characters talk with strange English inflections, with an awkwardly curse laden script to boot didn't help the endeavor.
 
 
It bombed.
Gamers interested in playing a Japanese GTA were put off by reviews that stated it was a brawler, and the niche fan-base that could have been exploited for profit ignored the endeavor because of the single language track. Couple the release of big-budget PS2 GTA games: Yakuza was dead on arrival.
 
The second entry would be released in Japan in December of 2006. It would see a western release in September of 2008. The Playstation 3 had been released two years prior.
 
It bombed.
Most people had no idea Sega had actually released Yakuza 2. If the release of the first Yakuza was a exercise at over-the-top ill advised promotion, the second Yakuza was an exercise at pretending the game that they released didn't exist.
 
It's not very surprising that for the last year Sega has denied that Yakuza 3 was ever going to be released in the west. Excuses seemed like the only official response, until a few months ago when it was announced that Yakuza 3 would finally get a western release. 
 
Finally, the series could get the attention it deserved.

...Although, not before a quarter of the game had been cut for apparent “cultural differences”. Oh, and it would be released on the same day as Final Fantasy XIII...

The confusion and circumstance regarding the context of Yakuza 3 almost rivals the actual game itself. It's not until you actually start playing Yakuza 3, when you realize the obvious room for success. The game plays to both fans of JRPG's and adventure games, at the same time it's subject matter is quite unorthodox for the style of game.

Yakuza 3 feels fresh. While it most certainly has it's rough spots, and could use some polish: It's overall design is solid, and the entire experience is more entertaining than most games of the same genre hitting the market. At a time in which critics have been complaining about stagnation regarding games made in Japan: There's a lot to like about Yakuza 3.
 
Yakuza 3's story once again revolves around that of Kazuma Kiryu, protagonist of the previous two games. Kazuma has left his life of crime and has opened an orphanage in Okinawa. Just as he thinks he has left his complicated past behind, the ex-Yakuza is brought back into the fold when he becomes pressured to leave the land his orphanage is on to make room for a military base an a resort. Both the Japanese government and the Yakuza both locally, and from his old clan in Tokyo become embattled in the situation. Everything quickly turns to conspiracy, when certain individuals directly involved with the land deal are shot mysteriously. It's up to Kazuma to head back to Tokyo and make everything right: specifically by beating the crap out of those who deserve it, while looking awesome with his iconic white suit. Kazuma is such a fun character, and it's awesome to see this super tough guy get caught up in these very life-threatening circumstances, and then be taking care of kids and despising life lessons the next. Or, taking photos of a old woman on a bike, not realizing she's doing a flip because she's so enamored with a poster and blogging on your phone about it so you can learn a new fighting move. The story-line hit all the right notes. It's melodramatic, depressing, and beyond silly when it want's too.
 
For those looking for a good story, look no further as Yakuza 3 is quite rewarding.



 Yakuza 3 at it's heart is an action-RPG. Kazuma wanders the streets of both Okinawa and the fictional district of Kamurocho in Tokyo. There is a main quest that Kazuma can embark on is highlighted on the map with side-missions that can be embarked on in a non-linear fashion. As discussed earlier, this is the beginning and end with the GTA comparisons. Yakuza 3's main story is a contained affair, and the location and the time of day are uncontrolled. In other words: If there is a sub-mission that you must do in Okinawa that's at night and you are in Tokyo because of the story: You're out of luck for the time being. For those concerned about not being able to see all the content your first time through, don't worry. A comprehensive “Premium Adventure Mode” is available after beating the game.

 
As Kazuma wanders from one story point to the other, he will have to fight off bands of street thugs, uninformed yakuza members, the homeless, clowns, and I assume half of Tokyo in random battles. When Kazuma initiates combat, the stark realism of the rest of the experience is thrown out of the window and the game becomes a full-blown brawler.

 Yakuza 3's combat is simple laughably brutal, and fun.

Combat in Yakuza 3 is a laughably entertaining affair. The combat for the most part is simple, and you will be relying on the age-old weak-strong punch combo for most enemies. Relying on this strategy helps, but what will keep you alive in the latter fights will be a combination of button mashing and contextual use of “Heat Actions”, derived by a “Heat gauge” that slowly fills as you give and take damage.

To put it simple: These Heat Actions are gloriously violent. It's one thing to crush someone with a sofa. It's another to crush someone with a sofa, then jump ontop of the sofa and have your feet go through the sofa. Other games might entice you with gore, Yakuza is more interested in replicating something akin to Jackass meets martial-arts. It's brilliant.

Throw in quick-time events, weapons both ranged and close, and people glowing in flames akin to something out of Dragon Ball, Yakuza 3's combat is tons of fun. It's mindless when it needs to be, surprisingly technical when it wants to be. For those who are interested in some of the latter optional tougher fights, get ready for something that's more than a button masher.
 
There are rough edges to the combat. Kazuma has trouble locking on to enemies, a problem that has been with the series since it's inception. The change from exploring locations at an almost simulator style sense of quality, to something so....for lack of a better word...gamey ....might turn off people.
 
Kazuma levels up and gains new abilities like all RPG's. Armor and weapons can be bought, and the gave has a full-blown crafting system that while is a bit convoluted is understandable.


If your bored with running into street thugs and playing the single player campaign, you have side-missions, and if you get bored with that , you have an almost ludicrous amount of mini-games to sink your teeth into. Side-missions for the most part involve the same “go here and beat up these guys ” mentality, but the context for the over 100 missions you can undertake is strikingly different from the next. For the completionist, get ready to run around a lot. There are way-points you can warp to, but you'll rarely use them considering that the locations size don't justify using them. Some of the missions are a bit too convoluted for their own good too.

 
Where some games would be happy having something, “like golf ”, for a mini-game, Yakuza 3 asks why cant a fully functional nine course golf game can't be added into the mix? A good percentage of Yakuza 3's mini-games while probably couldn't standalone, come dangerously close. To even consider such a feat is impressive in it's own right. Mini-games used to be a staple of the JRPG genre and to see them diminish overtime has been quite distressing to me. Yakuza 3's unrestrained acceptance of mini-games was incredibly shocking to me. Other games would kill to have the even half the amount of mini-games Yakuza 3 has.


At this point I would like to talk about the cut content.

If you have personally chosen not to purchase Yakuza 3 because of the cut content: I don't blame you.

 Some of the cuts are ridiculous and more importantly: confusing.

I was initially quite upset when I heard what was cut. The official statement from Sega stated “cultural differences ” for the reasoning of the cuts. This excuse is either half-true, or completely false. Yakuza 3's localization, and how it regards the cut-content gives the impression of something rushed out to store shelves versus something meticulously planned. A good example is the hostess mini-game.

Yakuza 3 has a fully functional hostess bar that you can manage, like Yakuza 2. For some reason of another, the mini-game has been stripped entirely from Yakuza 3.

Or has it?

Each of the girls in the hostess club still exist, and you can take them out on dates. You can even accomplish their final mission you receive after you romance them in the mini-game....But you don't romance them because there is no mini-game.... But this won't stop other individuals asking you about the hostess club, you apparently run (OR DON'T?!)

If this all sounds sloppy, then you get the right impression. Yakuza 3 might have cuts, but the remnants of what was removed still exists. The end result can be a very jarring experience for completionists trying to see everything the game has to offer. Mahjong was cut from the game, put that doesn't stop you from entering Mahjong parlors. The NPC that let's you play Mahjong stands behind the counter, silent.

 The subtitles are great, but is this an example of being faithful or a rushed job?

You can only take the “cultural differences” excuse so far. Another cut mini-game was a Japanese history test you could take called AnswerXAnswer. One could easily argue that new questions could have been made up, similar to how Persona 4 handled classroom questions. One could argue Mahjong might be too complicated to the uninitiated, although there are ways around that hurdle. The entire game is subtitled, the translation is also quite faithful. The “cultural differences” excuse starts to become even more weary when you realize that even the Japanese text for boss fights and street fights, haven't been touched. Everything relies exclusively on subtitles which is either the result of a localization team trying to be as faithful as possible, (Which is counter to the “cultural differences” line.) or the result of a localization team given a paltry budget. I choose to believe that the answer to this madness is somewhere in the middle.

Even though the game feels like someone took a knife to it, Yakuza 3 still has a multitude of features that puts other games at the $60 price point to shame. It should be noted that the main story-line has no cuts what-so-ever.

 

While most of Yakuza 3 follows a “clunky but fun” methodology, one aspect that's probably the most all-over-the-place is Yakuza 3's presentation. Yakuza 3's story-line is presented like a Japanese film, with tons of great voiced dialog. For some reason though, the quality of the presentation haphazard, one moment playing a phenomenally rendered cut-scene, the next moment delivering lines of dialog with just text. It looks, and feels antiquated as characters will speak lines and then talk only through dialog boxes. It makes sense probably not having voiced dialog with sub-mission's, but to have something important in the plot transpire only to go from voice, to text, to voice again is jarring.
 
Audio is practically non-existent, with an ambient soundtrack changing to rock music whenever an encounter is initiated. Soundtrack is nothing to write home about.

 The attention to detail is simply amazing. It feels like a populated environment.

The visuals have similar problems. While the main cast is beautifully modeled and look phenomenally realistic, the environment suffers a bit from used art assets from previous games (The series has had yearly releases for a reason, the reusing of locations is one of them). You won't be complaining though, while a murky texture here and there might attract the critical eye the locations are dense with detail and make up for their limitations by feeling like real locations. The area's might not be as large as a city, but Yakuza 3 makes up for the small size by packing these locations with a dizzying array of details. You will be impressed when you realize, that aside from the reoccurring burger shop a vast majority of the restaurant's and bars you can visit are individually their own.

Trophies are well done in Yakuza 3, but there is one major blemish and that comes from a trophy called “mini-game master”. A poor

 Want platinum? You better love billiards.

trophy or an achievement, are the ones that work counter to the experience and subsequently and have a questionable reason to be there. Mini-game Master accomplishes both by asking you to gain high-scores and beat expert players in all mini-games. It quite broken, with advanced players practically cheating and certain high-score's dazzlingly difficult. It requires no skill but excessive grinding. For those thinking of getting a Platinum, get ready to work for it.
 
Yakuza 3 is a bunch of fun. It's an action RPG with equal style and substance. The amount of things you can do off the beaten path is a breathe of fresh air. It's criminal infused story-line is equal parts gripping as silly, especially when the real enemy is revealed.
 
Yakuza 3 might be clunky, but even with brazen cuts it's able to stand on it's own and deliver a phenomenal experience, especially for those who want something new but familiar. 4/5.


One last complaint but it's still annoys me how this series is being handled so poorly, especially given this game's quality. I look forward to a day where I can review a Yakuza game without being subjected to strange and often times bewildering decisions, by the people who release the game over-seas. As of writing it's good to see that Yakuza 3 has sold more copies that Yakuza 1 and 2 combined, but that's not saying much. Hopefully this will instill confidence in Sega to attempt a release of Yakuza 4. There's a popular opinion online that if Yakuza 3 sells, Sega will graciously consider releasing Yakuza 4. Let's hope this popular opinion can be fulfilled, so we can move on and let this mentality be used for other non-game specific situations.

 
Like blackmail. 
 
 

(Notice: For reasons that I cannot understand the formatting for this review is all over the place. It's quite annoying to spend a bunch of time making this look perfect in edit mode just to see it show up as garbage. None of the headers showed up for reasons that are beyond me no matter how much tinkering I do. I made banners for each section, but I literally threw them together just now. Apologies for their quality. I would like to thank JL for walking me through my battles with html.)


16 Comments
Posted by Hockeymask27

Very well written review. Good job.

Posted by ahoodedfigure

A bit chaotic but rich in exactly the kind of detail I wanted from a review of this game.

Posted by vidiot
@ahoodedfigure: I couldn't get away with what's happening with the series it had to be included. I actually tried with my first version. Pile on strange formatting that had to be edited more times I could count and you get this. Next time I'll pick a game that's not knee deep in problems outside from the game itself. :P
Thanks.  
 
@Hockeymask27:
Thanks. I glad you enjoyed it.
Posted by vidiot

This is the part where I write something witty about having this review featured on the front page. 
 
I don't have anything. I'm kinda shocked and humbled, thanks to those who liked my review. This is the greatest gaming site and community, period.

Posted by wolf_blitzer85

Congrats on making the front page dude!  Managed to get my hands on the first game and I'm really really enjoying it. Hopefully I can find a copy of the second one for less than 80 dollars. Unfortunately now I have another good reason to buy a ps3. 

Posted by GmanHull

Great review, very detailed - you obviously really know your stuff when it comes to this series.  I do have a question though, as someone who hasnt played the first two games will I be able to pick up the story?

Posted by Ghostiet

People like vidiot or Pepsiman intimidate me - whenever I want to write something, I stop even thinking about it, because they release a new review or blog post and I don't even want to look at my piece of shit writing.

Good job, sir. Made me a buyer.

Posted by vidiot
@GmanHull: Absolutely. The only thing that I can think of that would be disorienting, is the beginning that jumps very subtly into a playable flashback for the first hour or so. If your not paying attention you might miss the fact you are playing a flashback, and subsequently become very confused :P
 
The beginning has returning characters from the first two games lamenting over things that had previously transpired, and then their gone for the most part. Yakuza 3 is most certainly it's own contained story.
 
Even better, there's an option on the main menu that let's you play recaps of the first two games and you can view these same movies at any time at your safe-houses. There's also a character relationship chart that you can access in the menu, that tracks the who and what certain individuals are and their motivations. Personally, I think other larger franchises that have become bloated in regards to their story, could actually learn from this.
 
@Ghostiet: Thanks duder. DON'T BE INTIMIDATED! :P
Posted by Ghostiet
@vidiot: THE CAPS ISN'T HELPING! >:(
Posted by Getz

Sorry dood, don't have to read all that...

Online
Posted by vidiot
@Getz: Awesome, thanks.
Posted by Getz
@vidiot said:
" @Getz: Awesome, thanks. "
Hey, it should be a legitimate concern of a writer that his piece is too long to engage a reader. Therefore, since brevity is the soul of wit, I will be brief. Your review is long. Long call I it, for to define true longevity, not in time but in size, what is't but to be nothing else but long? 
 
That's not to say it's BAD, after all I didn't read it. 
Online
Edited by vidiot
@Getz: Thanks for the context. Yes, I know it's long.
I felt strongly that the situation surrounding the game's release was too important to ignore, and it was something that I battled with myself (whether or not to include it.) prior to posting it. I'm happy I kept it.
Posted by Getz
@vidiot: Keep on keepin' on
Online
Posted by Artigkar

Great review! Hmm, I wonder if this game has been released in europe?

Posted by Dudacles

Fantastic review. It's a fresh approach, and I like it. Recommended.

Other reviews for Ryu ga Gotoku 3 (PlayStation 3)

    A great, underlooked game. 0

    Yakuza 3 is one of those games that if you haven't played it yet, you either never will or you'll inevitably stumble across it years from now, see it and think "I remember hearing that game was pretty cool," buy it, take it home and wonder why the hell you didn't play it sooner.   The History Lesson That Wasn't CutThe series is known as Ryu Ga Gotoku(roughly Like A Dragon) in its home country of Japan where it is outrageously popular and already on its fourth installment, known for bringing to l...

    12 out of 12 found this review helpful.

This edit will also create new pages on Giant Bomb for:

Beware, you are proposing to add brand new pages to the wiki along with your edits. Make sure this is what you intended. This will likely increase the time it takes for your changes to go live.

Comment and Save

Until you earn 1000 points all your submissions need to be vetted by other Giant Bomb users. This process takes no more than a few hours and we'll send you an email once approved.