Austin, I'm really quite surprised to see Elite on your list. Maybe I've just not been paying attention. Suffice to say my eyes widened quite a bit to see you include it among your personal best of the year.
I find it really hard to tell people why I like E: D so much. Taken in the round I completely understand why others are confounded by this game. The modular and ongoing construction of the game has made for, at times, quite a disjointed experience. In general the game can be actively unfriendly to people experiencing it for the first time. Still, I've spent more time playing this game than any other this year and there are plenty of 'moments' during play that still bring a huge smile to my face.
Maybe the biggest stumbling block is people thinking they are going to be playing a space based RPG, or action adventure game. That's just not what E: D is at a pretty fundamental level. Progression can feel rather soulless with you either farming credits or engaging with the PowerPlay faction warfare system which can make it hard to feel like you are having any substantial impact on the galaxy as a lone gun. The mission system also has 'issues'. It's getting better (and I'm sure will continue to do so over the coming year), but lets be honest, this is no Witcher in space pants.
What I will say is that all of E: D's 'bits' are hung on a pretty solid core - the flight model is really (like, really) good and even after all this time it is still incredibly satisfying to slide your ship around in free space, alternating between flight assist on and off and enjoying running circles around your prey. This is a game where better pilots will always win out over lesser but better armed opponents. It's a game that really does reward skill and your investment in learning the flight systems quirks and eccentricities.
I guess that last paragraph sums up my feelings - this is a game that doesn't necessarily do the best job of inviting you into it's world, but it does reward those who persevere. That ethos makes for a game that will not be for a lot of people, but for those for whom it does gel there is nothing else like it.
Log in to comment