What's your favorite ice cream flavor.

I like the original Call of Duty because it was original.

There's a reason 4 spawned the new wave of modern shooters. It's fucking incredible.

Uno, cause of nostalgia and because I prefer WW2 settings to present day conflict settings.

the next one

@Slaker117said:

There's a reason 4 spawned the new wave of modern shooters. It's fucking incredible.

This.

I'd have to go with 4. 2 coming in at a very close second.

The one with Price in it.

COD 1 on PC. 

2 was great as well. Had a lot of fun with that game. But 4 was a watershed. For better or worse, it chanced to face of gaming.
 
It's weird, I am tiring of the CoD cycle myself, but just thinking about it makes me want to go back and play the original Modern Warfare. So many good memories with that game.

wait, seriously? ok, then 4 for me.

Call of Duty 2 and 4 are pretty close for me, but I would have to go with 2. 

im prob the only one to say this but call of duty 3
it was my first fps other than goldeneye and halo so I loved the campaign and multiplayer

Call of Duty 4.

I can't quote because of GB's setup, but I agree, COD2 and 4.

I have to say 4 was my favorite of the ones I've played. Take this as you will, though, because I am not familiar with the first, second, or third. Also, I really only judge them by their single player experiences.

Call of Duty 4 easily, I sank way to many hours in to that.  All the later games just can't seem to hold my attention.

Call of Duty 4 was, and is still absolutely god damn incredible. it'll probably always be my favorite. 

Without doubt, my favourite would be the one where you shoot people.

Call of Duty: United Offensive.

Without doubt, my favourite would be the one where you shoot people.

4, closely followed by the original

Gotta be 4.

Without doubt, my favourite would be the one where you shoot people.

CoD 4:MW was my favorite single player, really good story and pacing. MW2 was my favorite multiplayer CoD game.

Modern Warfare 2, it made amazing improvements on 4 and was overall a more polished game with better balance in multiplayer and more exciting story

Having thought about it some more, I would rank them as such: 
 
2 
4 
BLOPS 
1  
MW2
Finest Hour 
3

Original and 4 because those are the ones that made huge leaps forward for the series/genre.

im prob the only one to say this but call of duty 3 it was my first fps other than goldeneye and halo so I loved the campaign and multiplayer

Call of Duty 2 hands down. That game took away my summer. I have so many good memories with that game. Call of Duty 4 is close behind, i put a lot of time in that game as well.

@kermoosh said:

im prob the only one to say this but call of duty 3 it was my first fps other than goldeneye and halo so I loved the campaign and multiplayer

I liked COD3 a lot, for the little bit of time Treyarch had to put it out I think they did a great job. With that said I still have to go with COD4 as my favorite.

The one with the 4.

@Curval said:

@kermoosh said:

im prob the only one to say this but call of duty 3 it was my first fps other than goldeneye and halo so I loved the campaign and multiplayer

I liked COD3 a lot, for the little bit of time Treyarch had to put it out I think they did a great job. With that said I still have to go with COD4 as my favorite.

but cod 3 invented the option of throwing back a grenade, they revolutionized the series, to a certain extent

Call of Duty 4.  It was truly revolutionary to shooters at the time in my opinion.  I played the campaign over and over and over and over (I'd say probably 75 or 100 hours at the very least) when my Xbox's Ethernet port broke somehow, and played days and days of the multiplayer when I got it fixed.

either 4 or black ops. 4 was the first call of duty game that i played because it use to be a ww2 shooter journalist were complaining about too many ww2 shooters. i never got one.

cod1 and 4 for me

I like CoD 4 for it's single player.  MW 2 for it's multiplayer.  CoD 3, because I beat it, in a single day (and not even that).  2 was alright also, for being just another WW2 thing.

CoD 4 was the first multiplayer experience where I didn't suck. And that campaign, pretty epic.
 
The original CoDs were shit compared to the BIA series in terms of gameplay and authenticity.

CoD 4 in my opinion is easily the best out of all of them. I'm ashamed of how many hours I spent playing that game. Also, the All Ghillied Up mission is one of the best FPS missions ever.

call of duty 4. I enjoyed the previous cod's but eventually the ww2 setting wore thin. i remember cod4's modern setting was exactly what i had been craving at the time. the variety of weapons/gear were awesome, and the perk system felt like a breath of fresh air. i played very little of mw2 and i havent touched black ops, but i do feel like the series peaked at cod4. it felt like a solid, standard modern fps whereas the following games appeared to be a clusterfuck of random wacky features.

2, I think I preferred its multiplayer to 4's, but its very close.

The one with the guns.

cod4 if i had to pick.  everything after that kinda went down hill. 
 
cod 2 close second.

@kermoosh said:

@Curval said:

@kermoosh said:

im prob the only one to say this but call of duty 3 it was my first fps other than goldeneye and halo so I loved the campaign and multiplayer

I liked COD3 a lot, for the little bit of time Treyarch had to put it out I think they did a great job. With that said I still have to go with COD4 as my favorite.

but cod 3 invented the option of throwing back a grenade, they revolutionized the series, to a certain extent

Yes it did and I do think people just don't realize Treyarch has added some stuff to the series.

Call of Duty 4 was, and is still absolutely god damn incredible. it'll probably always be my favorite. 

The first one. It's what really got me into online shooters, not to mention making maps. I miss those days.

There's a reason 4 spawned the new wave of modern shooters. It's fucking incredible.