Got 1200 pts to spend for a game so ill get the 800 pts back from MS.
 
But I'm torn between Comic Jumper and Limbo. CJ's zany comical style seems right up my alley, and I loved the previous Twisted Pixel games. But Limbo has the eerie atmosphere and seems to be overall better reviewed (and it is made by a local company).
 
A dark horse in the race could be Puzzle Quest 2 - Loved the first one but I am on the fence on the new design.
 
What do you think?

limbo! actually i've never played comic jumper but I really enjoyed limbo

Puzzle Quest 2. Limbo and Comic Jumper are both disappointing.

It depends what you're looking for. If you want an artsy game with good atmosphere and some solid puzzles go with Limbo, if you want a game with a bunch of cool comic book art styles and a good story that's very funny, but don't mind some kinda crappy gameplay, go with Comic Jumper.

If you want a game with disappointing story get Limbo. 
 
if you want a game with disappointing gameplay get Comic Jumper.

" It depends what you're looking for. If you want an artsy game with good atmosphere and some solid puzzles go with Limbo, if you want a game with a bunch of cool comic book art styles and a good story that's very funny, but don't mind some kinda crappy gameplay, go with Comic Jumper. "

I have them both...  I am enjoying Comic Jumper MUCH more than I enjoyed Limbo. 
 
Although I am not a fan of puzzle games, so I have a feeling that has something to do with it.  :P

Limbo. It's simply more fun in my humble opinion. Comic Jumper is really funny though.

It depends on what you're in the mood for.  The two games couldn't be more different in tone.

I love the gameplay in Comic Jumper.

" If you want a game with disappointing story get Limbo.  if you want a game with disappointing gameplay get Comic Jumper. "

Game Room shopping spree!

I think comic jumper would be the most fun of the 2 but limbo is a better overall game.

I did enjoy Limbo a lot but after I finished it, I felt like the $15 price was a tad high for something was completely black in white, with no voice work or story. But it was a really awesome puzzle platform. 
 It was challenging but when you figured out the puzzle, you felt good about it. 

Comic Jumper is just the opposite. Gameplay just doesn't look appealing enough for me to buy it. Sure, I'll miss out on the humor that the GB guys really liked but I rather wait for the memes and good parts to hit Youtube. 

Limbo and it's not even close.

Comic Jumper looks insane.

Limbo.

Comic Jumper, without a doubt.

Haven't played Comic Jumper, but it looks pretty boring to me. Limbo was really amazing.

I enjoyed playing Limbo a lot more but I'm not sure if I'd say it's worth $15. Comic Jumper is hilarious and needs to be experienced, but I'm forcing myself through some of the game sections just to hear the dialogue and watch the cut scenes. If you can find a Let's Play of Comic Jumper I'd watch that and buy Limbo.

Neither

Costume Quest

" Limbo and it's not even close. "

limbo

" Neither "

I was really disappointed by Limbo. I haven't played comic jumper, but if you've been following the GB coverage than I think you know what you are getting into.
 
However, Costume Quest comes out on the 20th and I'm all lined up to get that. If it interests you, you may want to hold out.

Dude, I know this doesn't really answer your original question, but it would nevertheless result in you spending the requisite 1200pts. Wait till next week and get Super Meat Boy. Seriously, that game looks like its going to be phenomenal. And the early reviews suggest as much.

Limbo was awesome and totally worth the money. If you play it start to finish in one sitting it's extremely well paced.
 
I just bought Comic Jumper today. So far the characters have been really funny but the gameplay has been average at best.
 
Between the 2 I'd definitely get Limbo.