I don't think they'd want to reminisce over the time they spent playing DP, that game was awful....  

I'd still like it to happen, but I won't get my hopes up. I don't imagine that they want to spend any more time talking or thinking about that game than they already have, haha. 

While I like the idea of such a podcast, I'm not sure it'd pan out too great - it's been too long since they played it (with an E3 chucked in there, just to further befuddle them) and a lot of the game was them becoming bored/frustrated by the various peccadilloes. I'm not sure I'd wanna slog through a whole podcast full of "and then what happened again?" and "ugh, that was the worst".
 
Don't get me wrong, I'm sure there would be great bits, but I'm just not entirely sure it'd make a great podcast on the whole. That said, I'm more than happy for a GBDPER podcast to appear in my iTunes and prove me wrong.

If they did a Twin Peaks "endurance run" and talked about both Deadly Premonition and Twin Peaks, I think it would be great. That being said, we watched them play it. Would a few of us getting together for a podcast be so bad?

I was thinking of this recently but it's been over for too long, I don't even think they remember it anymore.