After painstakingly researching this game, I think it started out pretty well, bringing Clint on board, getting a few Hollywood voice actors and what not.
But around the point that they practically announced it as a sandbox game is when things started to look dismal.
That and the fact that you always had to wait about a year to hear anything from it...

I had some hope for it when it was announced, but i kinda lost interest.

I haven't looked into it, but if it was set up the way I envision LA Noir to be like (don't know much about that game either :P), then I think it could have been...okay...

It depends on how they do it. If they make it a first person shooter where you can only use your revolver, but the ammo amount is never shown so you have to count your shots and determine whether you fired 5 shots or 6, then yes, I'd be very psyched.

...holy shit, that would have been pretty fucking sweet.

It could have been awesome.  I just found out it was canceled.  Sad day.

Hard call. There's the generational gap to consider. How many people  watched and enjoyed Dirty Harry movies? How many of the same people also enjoy video games?   I'm not saying it's impossible,  but the odds are stacked against such a game making money off the mainstream audience.

Personally,  I'm all for it.... but I fit the description above..

they need to get this game finished man. i would love to play a dirty harry game. it was a franchise destined for video games. 

it's a movie game, so no...

"it's a movie game, so no...

unless it's made by Rockstar(Warriors), then no.

"

sadly never played that one(didn't have xbox)

Oh man, I remember this. And that Indiana Jones whip physics game.

You totally don't have to worry because there is a Dirty Harry game that's already out!

I'd never heard of that in my life before...

" TurboMan said:

"it's a movie game, so no...

unless it's made by Rockstar(Warriors), then no.

"

umm...okay. 

there are some game movies that are good. escape from butcher bay

"

" I'd never heard of that in my life before... "