@oatz said:
@Narx said:
Quantity is not a factor of quality.
Where was this ever even implied?
I didn't finish DA2 because it was shit, but Dragon Age Origins had a good length for me.
I just stated my opinion on the subject. I never said that this was implied. I just don't think that quantity is a factor. I payed 60$ for God of War 3 and finished it in under 10 hours and thought it was a blast and do not regret it one bit. Payed 60$ for Batman Arkham City and was done under 15 hours and i don't regret it. Would both theses games be better if the were twice as long? I don't believe necessarily so.
@phish09 said:
@Narx said:
Quantity is not a factor of quality.
True, but it is a factor of value. I think Limbo is one of the best games of 2010, but would I pay $60 for a 2 hour game? Probably not. Not because the quality of the product isn't high enough, but it just isn't a very sound value proposition. I'm not saying that 30-40 hours is a bad value proposition either, especially considering there is a lot of replayability in DA2 if you're into the game that much, but you can't act like the length of a game should not be considered when making a purchasing decision.
Of course that extreme is not a sound business call. We could possibly believe that there's a mental barrier somewhere which is set up differently for everyone. An 8-10 hours game for me for 60$ is worth it if I have fun all the way, others might not think so.@EmuLeader said:
@will_leisure said:
I'd rather have a great 20-hour game compared to a decent 40+ hour game with a lot of filler. With school and a full-time job, I don't have all the time in the world, so a game's length isn't a factor for me anymore.
I agree. As long as the content is great throughout, and its not just 10 hours (like a long FPS), length isn't really a worry. I do enjoy them being long, though. This is mainly due to the quality of the stories of BioWare games. They suck me into the universe and make me care about what happens. Longer games can mean getting to delve into the universe more, with more plot development opportunities. Again, as long as its great quality content throughout.
I think you hit the barrel there for me. I am a great fan of RPGs, I am in the middle of a playtrough of Persona 3 myself and quite glad that the game last this long because every time I play it I enjoy it, I don't want it to end. I for one did not enjoy the Deep Roads in Dragon age: Origins. Having to spend 2 hours less in them would be great and in my opinion might have made a more coherent experience.
In the end, I think what matters is fun per hour ratio. And that will differ for every single person for every single game.
Log in to comment