@humanity: I know you're trying to be snarky but sex has always been a large part of vampire lore.
@milkman said:
@brodehouse: Not saying that. But in this specific case, I don't understand how you can criticize a person for saying "this made me feel uncomfortable." Everyone's different and to say this person must have a "fucked up mentality" for having a different reaction to something than you did isn't criticism. It's an attack. She's not saying the people who made the game are sexists or bad people. Hell, she says "I applaud Cox and his team for their desire to take on challenging material." By all means when games journalists write things like "this art was drawn by a 13 year old" or stuff like, give 'em hell. But this is not one of those cases.
Nobody is criticizing her for feeling uncomfortable, nobody has even commented on it. People are criticizing her for claiming that the encounter trivializes sexual assault, that the encounter is intended to evoke sexual assault, that the game is intending us to find sympathy with rapists. She even attempts to portray the use of the female character as a prop to further Dracula's character development (and she is, so is the male character who dies moments before) as being inherently "problematic". There are numerous issues people have with her reasons for being uncomfortable, they are not arguing against her right to have emotions. You are revising the nature of situation in order for her to be victimized by it.
The "I applaud Cox and his team for their desire to take on challenging material". For one, I'd like any evidence whatsoever that this is "challenging material". It's a vignette where the villain protagonist vampire does exactly what vampires are known for. This is not the first game or story to have a morally flexible vampire in the protagonist role. Secondly, I find it completely ridiculous to say that you applaud something while you expressly call it terrible and attempt to turn public opinion against it. "I applaud the people who stand by the Constitution, but not having school prayer is victimizing religious children".
Well, to address your second point about this being "challenging material", there are numerous quotes in the article from the developer that make it clear that they're trying to push the envelope with the scene. It says that when she told him that it made her uncomfortable, he said "that's exactly what we wanted." It's pretty obvious that they want it be shocking.
As for the rest of your post, I direct you to my last post. Like I said, I don't think the idea of the game trying to evoke sexual assault is as absurd as you're making it out to be. It's all a matter of perspective. And speaking of perspective, as far as her point on evoking sympathy for Dracula, whether it's their intention or not, there's going to be people who play that scene and don't think "oh, this poor family." They're going to think "oh, this is badass!" Is that necessarily the developer's fault? Maybe? I don't know. It's hard to say outside of the context of the rest of the game.
And for the record, I am not arguing for the scene to be removed or even that the scene is bad. Or even that sexual assault should be some sort of off-limits thing in video game storytelling. I'm just saying I can see where she's coming from.
Log in to comment