My answer is "Yes, rarely". The point of having one is to have a quick, easy, physical reference. Often, I find that when I'm playing a game I don't want to get up and access my computer, or I'd rather not alt-tab out to read something (if that's even possible). I do find that online guides tend to be more thorough and of better quality, but a good book is great for the quick and dirty "For the love of all that is Holy, what the heck am I supposed to do?".
However, I rarely actually buy the guide. A walkthrough often defeats the point of the game in itself, especially if exploration or puzzle solving is a major component, since I usually just want a quick and dirty answer like you can look up online. I use guides more as a reference; an example of a guide I wish I could buy would be "What can I combine to make what in Monster Hunter", because even though the information is all in the game it's clunky to look up, and you can't always see where the product can then be used. "How to make weapons" was something I tended to reference often, but I disliked having to get out of game to go check it out.
The last one I actually got was a gift at Christmas, which was the guide for Spore: Galactic Adventures. I thought I wouldn't want or need it, but it had some handy stuff that I could look up both for the basic game, and for the new content. I was surprised by how useful it turned out to be, because I thought I wouldn't want it and never would have bought it for myself.
Log in to comment