Avatar image for yukoei
#1 Posted by Yukoei (2141 posts) -
Avatar image for wellthatsb4d
#2 Posted by i69edUrGpa (596 posts) -

YOU'RE MAKING ME CHOOSE BETWEEN THOSE FANTASTIC TITLES!? I CAN'T EVEN CHOOSE WHICH ONE OF YOUR THREADS TO POST IN!!1!!!1!!! LOLOLOLOLOLOLOL

Avatar image for yukoei
#3 Posted by Yukoei (2141 posts) -
@i69edUrGpa said:
"YOU'RE MAKING ME CHOOSE BETWEEN THOSE FANTASTIC TITLES!? I CAN'T EVEN CHOOSE WHICH ONE OF YOUR THREADS TO POST IN!!1!!!1!!! LOLOLOLOLOLOLOL "

Lmao.
Avatar image for branthog
#4 Posted by Branthog (5777 posts) -

Are you asking for advice on which to buy if you can only buy one? If so, I'd say Mass Effect 2 if you are console-only and Dragon Age if you have a PC. Both are great, but if you can only get one, you probably are looking for the best value. Dragon Age has a broader potential for engaging re-playability than ME2 does (though it isn't shabby itself). Plus, Dragon Age on PC is somewhat cheaper than ME2 on console.
 
If you're making me choose for myself? Well, then I won't. I'll have both.

Avatar image for yukoei
#5 Posted by Yukoei (2141 posts) -
@Branthog said:
"Are you asking for advice on which to buy if you can only buy one? If so, I'd say Mass Effect 2 if you are console-only and Dragon Age if you have a PC. Both are great, but if you can only get one, you probably are looking for the best value. Dragon Age has a broader potential for engaging re-playability than ME2 does (though it isn't shabby itself). Plus, Dragon Age on PC is somewhat cheaper than ME2 on console.
 
If you're making me choose for myself? Well, then I won't. I'll have both. "

I was making YOU choose and you HAVE to choose or mutan ninja elfs will rape your furniture.
Avatar image for venatio
#6 Posted by Venatio (4724 posts) -

Which one did I like more? 
 
Easily Mass Effect, I love that game

Avatar image for skald
#7 Posted by Skald (4430 posts) -

Dragon Age.

Avatar image for shirogane
#8 Posted by Shirogane (3629 posts) -
@Yukoei said:
"@Branthog said:
"Are you asking for advice on which to buy if you can only buy one? If so, I'd say Mass Effect 2 if you are console-only and Dragon Age if you have a PC. Both are great, but if you can only get one, you probably are looking for the best value. Dragon Age has a broader potential for engaging re-playability than ME2 does (though it isn't shabby itself). Plus, Dragon Age on PC is somewhat cheaper than ME2 on console.
 
If you're making me choose for myself? Well, then I won't. I'll have both. "
I was making YOU choose and you HAVE to choose or mutan ninja elfs will rape your furniture. "

Hmm, mutant ninja elves sound kinda hawt... 
 
Dragon Age is waaaaay too long, and too hard. If not for that it'd be a pretty awesome game. But i like sci-fi over fantasy... 
It's too bad ME doesn't have lightsabers/equivalent.
Avatar image for xyzygy
#9 Edited by xyzygy (10595 posts) -

The Dragon Age story and setting is totally uninspired, and Iike how they do dialogue in Mass Effect. Plus, the presentation for Mass Effect is stellar. 
 
@Shirogane: I think that after doing KOTOR maybe Bioware would want to step away from the Lightsabers :P

Avatar image for deactivated-57b1d7d14d4a5
#10 Posted by deactivated-57b1d7d14d4a5 (2945 posts) -
@extremeradical said:
" Dragon Age. "
Avatar image for drrandle
#11 Posted by DrRandle (1376 posts) -

Mass Effect actually knows what it means to have a video game that is visually appealing, on top of a good story. The combat...well that's personal tastes, but I found Mass Effect's combat to be more satisfying and less convoluted. Also Mass Effect came up with some really nice conventions from a cinematic and narrative point of view that Dragon Age decided to ignore, making it feel much more archaic. 
 
All this being said I haven't played 2 yet, so for all I know the series divebombed, though I doubt that to be true.

Avatar image for thejollyrajah
#12 Posted by TheJollyRajah (1606 posts) -

Dragon Age is great.

Avatar image for sly_ry
#13 Posted by Sly_Ry (155 posts) -
@Shirogane said:
It's too bad ME doesn't have lightsabers/equivalent. "


How dare you.
Avatar image for mike
#14 Posted by Mike (17288 posts) -

Dave's commentary about Dragon Age totally scared me away from it. I just don't have the time to sink into a title like that right now...I'll get around to it eventually though.

Moderator
Avatar image for shirogane
#15 Posted by Shirogane (3629 posts) -
@Sly_Ry:
@xyzygy:

But but...lightsabers! 
 
Well, main i just want a proper melee weapon in ME, considering enemies have a tendency to just run all the way up to you and start shooting/whacking you around. Especially those damn krogan.
Avatar image for fallen189
#16 Posted by Fallen189 (5453 posts) -

Mass effect was trash. Pick the lesser of two evils.

Avatar image for witchhunter_z
#17 Posted by WitchHunter_Z (894 posts) -

I prefer Dragon Age, but I have a feeling that Mass Effect would be better if I played them on consoles.
 
I didn't enjoy Mass Effect at all my first playthrough, it took me a second to appreciate it but it still feels rather underwhelming. Dragon Age on the other hand sucked me in right from the start and was consistently excellent.

Avatar image for matfei90
#18 Posted by Matfei90 (1279 posts) -

Get both, but if you can't I'd definately say Mass Effect.

Avatar image for armaan8014
#19 Posted by armaan8014 (6114 posts) -
@Yukoei said:
" @Branthog said:
"Are you asking for advice on which to buy if you can only buy one? If so, I'd say Mass Effect 2 if you are console-only and Dragon Age if you have a PC. Both are great, but if you can only get one, you probably are looking for the best value. Dragon Age has a broader potential for engaging re-playability than ME2 does (though it isn't shabby itself). Plus, Dragon Age on PC is somewhat cheaper than ME2 on console.
 
If you're making me choose for myself? Well, then I won't. I'll have both. "
I was making YOU choose and you HAVE to choose or mutan ninja elfs will rape your furniture. "
Hehe.. nice..
And about the question, if you have got the time, go for DA:O.  But if it's instant gratification you want, ME2
Avatar image for jadeskye
#20 Posted by Jadeskye (4392 posts) -

The mass effect fiction is the better of the two imo. 
 
Origins is the better game. 
 
however, if you bring mass effect 2 into it... deffinately ME

Avatar image for toxicfruit
#21 Posted by ToxicFruit (1913 posts) -

This is like choosing between my 2 unborn children, or my dog and my bird :(  you sir are a monster!

Avatar image for penguindust
#22 Posted by PenguinDust (12994 posts) -

There is only one answer and that is BOTH.  But, if you mean which should you get first, then it depends on where you are running it.  If you are going to play on you PC and your PC has the recommended specs (not minimum), then I'd definitely say Dragon Age: Origins.  But, if your only option or preferred platform is the 360, then I would suggest Mass Effect 2.  If you have a completed save for Mass Effect 1, then get ME2 for wherever that save is stored.  Now, if you haven't played Mass Effect 1, then that is your first priority.  However, the DA:O on PC rule still trumps all I've said so far.  Simple, no?