Or BGGOTYGP 2015 for long short.
With GOTY over I was wondering how closely the Best Game list compares to the staff's personal list. I did this by applying the Formula 1 scoring system to the their list and ranking them accordingly.
There are a few exclusions from the point and I'll go over those before breaking down the list.
First, I left Matt Rorie's list off. Being only five games listed and not ranked made it hard to attempt to apply the same rules that all the other lists. Even if I took the list in order that they appear in his article the game on the bottom of his list would rank higher then the games at the bottom of the other Bomber's lists.
For Jeff I also excluded his #11, Bloodborne. Nothing against the game but with the F1 scoring system being applied on the top 10 finishers earn point and with Jeff's list the only one with 11 items it would unfairly weigh his list more then the others.
Destiny: The Taken King is excluded for being an expansion and not a stand alone video game.
So now the list
Position | Game | Points |
---|---|---|
1 | Metal Gear Solid V: The Phantom Pain | 116 |
2 | Super Mario Maker | 66 |
3 | Rocket League | 61 |
4 | Splatoon | 37 |
5 | Undertale | 28 |
6 | Axiom Verge | 27 |
T7 | Invisible, Inc. | 25 |
T7 | Keep Talking and Nobody Explodes | 25 |
T7 | Rise of the Tomb Raider | 25 |
T10 | Grow Home | 21 |
T10 | SOMA | 21 |
T10 | The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt | 21 |
T13 | Monster Hunter 4 Ultimate | 20 |
T13 | Ori and the Blind Forest | 20 |
T15 | Bloodborne | 18 |
T15 | Downwell | 18 |
T15 | Fallout 4 | 18 |
T15 | Kerbal Space Program | 18 |
T19 | Her Story | 17 |
T19 | Life is Strange | 17 |
T21 | Dying Light | 15 |
T21 | Galak-Z: The Dimensional | 15 |
T21 | SOMA | 15 |
T24 | Hacknet | 14 |
T24 | Until Dawn | 14 |
T26 | Contradiction: Spot the Liar! | 12 |
T26 | Nuclear Throne | 12 |
T28 | Lara Croft Go | 10 |
T28 | The Book of Unwritten Tales 2 | 10 |
T28 | Wheels of Aurelia | 10 |
T31 | Cities: Skyline | 8 |
T31 | Cradle | 8 |
T33 | Elite: Dangerous | 6 |
T34 | DiRT Rally | 4 |
T34 | Dragon Ball XenoVerse | 4 |
T34 | Mortal Kombat X | 4 |
T34 | Pac-Man 256 | 4 |
T38 | Assassin's Creed Syndicate | 2 |
T38 | Batman: Arkham Knight | 2 |
T38 | Cibele | 2 |
T38 | Puzzle & Dragons: Super Mario Bros. Edition | 2 |
42 | Ronin | 1 |
Log in to comment