I picked Tetris Effect as GOTY because it seems to have the best general consensus among the GB crew. Then again I was totally off last year when I thought Super Mario Odyssey was a shoe-in for GOTY.
I think Artifact could be a sleeper. I can see Ben and Brad really getting into this game. I didn't include it into my list because I think Celeste, Astrobot and Hitman 2 will garner more positive vibes.
RDR2 is going to be a disappointment considering what Jeff and Dan had to say about the game in recent podcasts. I still included RDR2 in my list considering how much Alex and Abby like the game.
Even though I think COD Black Ops 4 is going to be Jeff's GOTY, I don't see anyone else adding it to their lists so I omitted it.