Avatar image for sharkethic
#1 Posted by SharkEthic (1091 posts) -

So, I'm not gonna sit around watching a video of sitting around. Surfing the web while listening I tend to tune it out eventually. I imagine he chose the video format to easily limit the content to subscribers, but this ultimately results in me not watching/hearing it, despite the fact that it's a pretty interesting feature.

Am I alone in this? I'd love Jar Time in audio form for commutes and such.

Avatar image for sexytoad
#2 Posted by SexyToad (2939 posts) -

If I remember premium members can download videos. Right? Then couldn't you convert that to a mp3?

Avatar image for maajin
#3 Posted by Maajin (1171 posts) -

I like looking into his soul.

Avatar image for razielcuts
#4 Posted by RazielCuts (3269 posts) -

I posted this question before and I got the same response gave but that's kind of just hassle. I don't know, sometimes its good to see Jeff's expression and motions but yeah, it would be cool when they're an 1hr + to have an MP3 download to take on the go.

Avatar image for zzzleepy
#5 Posted by Zzzleepy (166 posts) -

I used to just download it and convert the video into mp3 and listen to it on my phone while I was on the move, not that hard to do.

Avatar image for questionable
#6 Posted by Questionable (670 posts) -

Video converting ourselves for a better user experience? What is this, 2008?

As a premium member that signed up pretty much exclusively for the jar videos (good job gerstmann) I find it a tad jarring that there still is no audio download option for these.

Avatar image for sharkethic
#7 Edited by SharkEthic (1091 posts) -

Like @RazielCuts and points out, downloading and converting the video, though easy to do, is kind of a hassle. So what I'm saying is, that it'd be a cool thing to not make paying members jump through those sorts of hoops.

Avatar image for questionable
#8 Posted by Questionable (670 posts) -

I wonder what the logic behind this is, the could just have given them podcast treatment. It's not like we have weekly video footage of 4 guys talking into microphones for 3 hours straight

Yes we CAN convert them ourselves but the real question is, should we have to?
In its current form the video feed adds little to the overall product other than making the Jar a thing.

Avatar image for bisonhero
#9 Posted by BisonHero (10501 posts) -

@SexyToad said:

If I remember premium members can download videos. Right? Then couldn't you convert that to a mp3?

I download it, but then whatever, I've already spent the bandwidth downloading the video version, so I don't see the point in converting it to audio-only. I put the video file on my phone, put that phone in my pocket, then put on headphones and listen to it. Sure, it's wasting battery playing a bunch of video I'm not watching, but whatever, my brightness isn't that high.

Avatar image for sharkethic
#10 Posted by SharkEthic (1091 posts) -

@Questionable said:

I wonder what the logic behind this is, the could just have given them podcast treatment. It's not like we have weekly video footage of 4 guys talking into microphones for 3 hours straight Yes we CAN convert them ourselves but the real question is, should we have to? In its current form the video feed adds little to the overall product other than making the Jar a thing.

Like I said in my original post, they already have the site-architecture in place to limit videos to subscribers, so I imagine that's the reasoning behind the chosen format.

Avatar image for ravenlight
#11 Posted by Ravenlight (8057 posts) -

I'll have to mess around with it later, but IIRC, it's relatively trivial to rip the audio out of the video with Audacity. I'd suggest that I or someone else could post a link to download just the audio, but I feel like that would devalue subscriber content.

@Questionable said:

I find it a tad jarring that there still is no audio download option for these.

Well done.

Avatar image for bocam
#12 Posted by Bocam (4099 posts) -

Jeff wants it only in video format

Avatar image for joey_ravn
#13 Posted by JoeyRavn (5219 posts) -

@Questionable said:

Video converting ourselves for a better user experience? What is this, 2008? As a premium member that signed up pretty much exclusively for the jar videos (good job gerstmann) I find it a tad jarring that there still is no audio download option for these.

@Questionable said:

I wonder what the logic behind this is, the could just have given them podcast treatment. It's not like we have weekly video footage of 4 guys talking into microphones for 3 hours straight Yes we CAN convert them ourselves but the real question is, should we have to? In its current form the video feed adds little to the overall product other than making the Jar a thing.

Podcasts are podcasts and Jar Times are videos. Nothing prevents you from ripping the audio into an MP3 file, but that's just not how Jar Time was conceived. If Jeff had wanted to do another podcast (Iike the Nintendownload Express), he would have done it.

Avatar image for sanj
#14 Posted by Sanj (3118 posts) -

Yeah I also usually leave it on in the background while surfing the web.