@Laivasse: Point taken.
Though the AadP posits that popular opinion can and does change widely, wildly and differs regionally and culturally, semantically my argument still holds water (you should have seen this sentence before I re-wrote it).
You may believe that product A has such and such flaws, but if I believe any flaws it does have are transcended by its otherwise appealing aspects (in fact, I may be unable to perceive A's negative qualities at all), then I am not wrong and I haven't 'over-rated' A.
Extrapolating that idea, if the general consensus is that A is a quality product, based on the same reasoning ('conformity' struggles to apply here, given we are talking about a structured analysis of the qualitative aspects of A) the dissenting voices cannot claim that the masses have incorrectly 'over-rated' A.
Saying that, I concede that opinion is fickle. Gone With The Wind was once a beloved classic and is now widely regarded as bloated and racist.
I stand by my point, though. I'm stubborn and hate to be told that my (often unreasonable) decision to enjoy something is wrong because this person says so.
Specifically? I agree with neither your combat nor UI points. The action itself may boil down to rhythmic button presses, but everything on the periphery is absorbing. Oils, potions, signs - if you want more from the action, it is there to be pored over. Similarly, given that there is much information to be relayed, the UI is surprisingly intelligible.
The learning curve leaves much to be desired, though, and the narrative suffers a little here and there for juggling too many plot-points (I'll also say that the branching path divergence offers very little in the way of worth upon replay - the game's mechanics come away at the seems a little there). Besides that, the option to play the introduction out of sync is bewildering (which also gives rise to learning-curve issues).
@sixpin said:
@GetEveryone: Just wanted to say that I enjoyed the articulate nature of your post. The writing was well crafted and your point salient.
Also, Witcher 2 is pretty great and I need to finish the play through I started.
Thanks, man. I know it's just a message board, but I enjoy writing and try to convey that in my posts.
Also, you should. It's great.
Log in to comment