Netflix Witcher series 1st Trailer

Avatar image for avantegardener
#1 Edited by avantegardener (2381 posts) -

Ouuuff, this is a swing and a miss for me. Acting seems a bit too slocky and production overly manicured in parts, and unfortunately I just can't 'believe' Henry Cavill in the role. Maybe it'll be ok?

Avatar image for liquiddragon
#2 Edited by liquiddragon (3526 posts) -

It was hard to tell for me. Idk, it could be fine.

I really don't care if adaptations are faithful to the source material. I'd be happy if this finds it's own identity. It's a different medium, a different creative team. The goal should be to make something good, that's it.

Avatar image for omgfather
#3 Posted by OMGFather (1061 posts) -

I wasn't that into it before but I really dig this.

Avatar image for luchalma
#4 Posted by Luchalma (548 posts) -

The Witcher 3 is my favorite game of all time, but I've only read a couple of the books. So I can't claim to be some kind of Witcher authority. But this seemed good to me. The Nilfgaardian armor still looks a bit meh but whatever.

Avatar image for liquiddragon
#5 Posted by liquiddragon (3526 posts) -
Loading Video...

Avatar image for boozak
#6 Edited by BoOzak (2645 posts) -

I'm getting some "In the Name of the King: A Dungeon Siege Tale" vibes from this which isnt great. I dont think Cavill looks bad in the role though, certainly much better than those pre-production shots or whatever they were.

Ultimately though I feel like this will be shrugged off as a Game of Thrones clone by most people, which is sad for the books and the games. I dont feel bad for Andrzej Sapkowski though, who is clearly just in it for the paychecks at this point and has been for awhile.

Avatar image for zeik
#7 Edited by Zeik (5221 posts) -

Looks good to me, even if Cavill still looks kind of miscast. But not so much I can't enjoy it.

Who knows about the final product, but I'll definitely watch it to find out.

Avatar image for conmulligan
#8 Posted by conmulligan (1946 posts) -

Some of the CGI looks unfinished, but overall this is promising.

Avatar image for efesell
#9 Posted by Efesell (4563 posts) -

It looks... fine.

Cavill will never sit quite right but it'll be alright.

Avatar image for junkerman
#10 Posted by Junkerman (536 posts) -

Not drawing inspiration from the music used in the games feels like a huge mistake. Thems some good soundtracks.

Avatar image for theflamingo352
#11 Posted by TheFlamingo352 (377 posts) -

Looks better than other stuff they've shown, but I'm not too excited.

I'm more shocked that this thing is being positioned as Netflix's Game of Thrones. Like, this trailer is going after that GoT vibe *hard*. Might be the most expensive thing Netflix develops this year.

Avatar image for killem_dafoe
#12 Posted by KillEm_Dafoe (2655 posts) -

I don't have any outstanding issues with this at all. I really dig what the trailer shows.

Avatar image for farleyslundgren
#13 Posted by FarleysLundgren (204 posts) -

Doesn’t look very intriguing but that might be the trailers fault for making it look generic. I’ll give it a shot when it comes out.

Avatar image for bobobones
#14 Edited by BoboBones (284 posts) -

I’m incredibly in love with the trilogy of games, but this is giving me (Netflix) Marco Polo vibes. I dropped that hard. Hope I’m wrong.

Avatar image for cerberus3dog
#15 Posted by Cerberus3Dog (1029 posts) -

More optimistic than I've been. Excited to give it a shot.

Avatar image for finaldasa
#16 Posted by FinalDasa (3231 posts) -

Since it takes after the books, I'm really curious what the narrative structure will be. A lot of the books (ok well the one that I read) jump around a ton. Be really neat to ditch the typical structure and go for something different.

Moderator
Avatar image for shiftygism
#17 Posted by Shiftygism (1060 posts) -

Cavill's the only draw for me, hope it's good, he needs something to get that DCEU stench off him, and M:I - Fallout wasn't enough.

Avatar image for farleyslundgren
#18 Posted by FarleysLundgren (204 posts) -

I watched the trailer again and I’m liking it more actually. I had kind of a knee jerk reaction the first time but it doesn’t look that bad tbh.

Avatar image for bladeofcreation
#19 Posted by BladeOfCreation (1405 posts) -

@boozak: I don't want to defend the guy because he comes across as a huge jerk in that interview he did with Waypoint a couple years ago, but I don't think it's fair to say Sapkowski is in it for the money.

This looks decent. I'm not a fan of Cavill, but everything else looks fine. There's a brief second in the trailer where he's swinging a chain, which is callback to the opening cinematic of the first game, which is itself a nearly play-by-play visual telling of how that fight goes down in the book.

Avatar image for captain_insano
#20 Posted by Captain_Insano (3531 posts) -

I’m incredibly in love with the trilogy of games, but his is giving me (Netflix) Marco Polo vibes. I dropped that hard. Hope I’m wrong.

Season 1 of Marco Polo was pretty alright. Season 2 may have been one of the worst things I have ever seen. So who knows.

Avatar image for brackstone
#21 Posted by Brackstone (938 posts) -

It looks fine? A step above the other fantasy shows sans GoT, but not GoT level on the production front. Some of it looks a little Sy-Fy quality, but other bits look quite good.

We'll see how the acting holds up. I haven't seen enough of Henry Cavill to be convinced one way or the other, but the rest of the cast is a little concerning. It's not that they're bad actors, they could all be fantastic, but generally a show like this will try to cast a few more well established actors as a draw to round out the supporting cast, and it could be a sign that the budget for the show isn't really there, or they're blowing a lot of it on Henry Cavill. Could be fine, but combined with some of the more dodgy looking parts I'm not completely convinced.

Avatar image for waterlord0
#22 Posted by WaterLord0 (69 posts) -

I was really into the trailer. Tho I have a limitless hunger for anything Witcher related.

Avatar image for christoffer
#23 Posted by Christoffer (2377 posts) -

Looks watchable and I will probably give it a try when it comes out. Yeah, It looks a bit cheaper than GoT but that doesn't have to be a huge problem. If they make me care about the characters and the story I would accept Star Trek: ToS quality.

Avatar image for frodobaggins
#24 Posted by FrodoBaggins (2098 posts) -

Yep, I'll be watching this.

Avatar image for efesell
#25 Posted by Efesell (4563 posts) -

@bladeofcreation: I feel like every interview I've seen with the author has come off either like that or otherwise super bitter about how popular the games were over the novels.

I love the world he's given but dude seems like a real shit.

Avatar image for mezmero
#26 Posted by mezmero (3784 posts) -

I'm quite skeptical honestly. Here's the thing with me, and I say this as a fan of the games so book readers can feel free to correct me on this (though try not to dogpile on me). I've been under the impression that the books don't have anywhere near the sense of humor the games do, which is one of my favorite parts about them. Obviously they have the intrigue and world building that fans love in spades but I never got the sense that the books are exactly chock full of knee-slapping hilarity. Again though, I could be completely off base with that assumption. The production values looks fine though in regards to Netflix produced stuff lately I've been far more put off by shoddy directing than by anything technical or talent related.

Avatar image for humanity
#27 Posted by Humanity (18933 posts) -

@mezmero: the books have about as much humor as the games but it stems largely from secondary characters and much less from Geralt although he does have his moments. What the books don’t have as much as the games is ironically the whole monster hunting thing. The first novel sort of sets up a “main quest” for him and at that point they just follow that plot line through without many detours. Overall the novels have much less action. Plenty of scenes of kings speaking of borders and trade, of birthright, of internal politics. This is probably why the trailer shows so little if Geralt because he actually doesn’t play that big a role in the big scheme at play.

If the show is going to follow the books closely then people will be in for a rather deflating surprise as Geralt is even more grumpy and bullheaded to a fault.

Avatar image for mezmero
#28 Edited by mezmero (3784 posts) -

@humanity: Appreciate the info. You'll forgive me for assuming the worst when it comes to the humor given how salty the author has come across in various quotes. It does in fact dishearten me to hear the Geralt doesn't sound as witty as he is in the games though that's to be expected given that he's not doing commentary on the absurd monster encounters and contracts that get peppered through side quests.

Avatar image for humanity
#29 Posted by Humanity (18933 posts) -

@mezmero: I mean I do think he is witty. He has this salt about him that can be funny when he's speaking to other characters and he is just not going to tolerate anyones shit. That said I do think the games setup a lot more humorous situations and he seems a little less gruff.

Avatar image for bladeofcreation
#30 Posted by BladeOfCreation (1405 posts) -

@efesell: I think on the one hand there SHOULD be some recourse for him getting paid some extra money based on how unexpectedly and wildly successful the game series was.

On the other hand, his weird assertion that the games would make people like the books less or make the books less popular is, of course, utter nonsense. The last book was only translated into English a couple years ago. It's undeniable that the games made people interested in the books.

Avatar image for flatblack
#31 Posted by flatblack (139 posts) -

I'll hold judgement until I can watch a full episode, but this trailer makes it look like a cw show

Avatar image for dudeglove
#32 Posted by dudeglove (13778 posts) -

The biggest draw of Witcher games was how damn well dressed everyone is. The costumes look dogshit frankly.

Avatar image for dryker
#33 Posted by Dryker (1124 posts) -

It looks a little drab. The costumes could definitely use some flare. The costume designer for the Tudors (another Cavill show) would improve things. But, of course, these expectations come from the games not the books.

Avatar image for oursin_360
#34 Posted by OurSin_360 (6197 posts) -

Looks amazing. I'm glad i stopped scouring the internet for opinions half the time these days i see people hating stuff and have no clue why lol. This looks good and i'm excited to see it.

Avatar image for zomgfruitbunnies
#35 Posted by Zomgfruitbunnies (1291 posts) -

Looks fine, honestly. Just somewhat concerned about how they're going to handle the timeline considering the trailer shows story bits from the Slaughter of Cintra to the origins of Yennefer. That's a substantial amount of time there. Also, which Geralt they're going to go for, because book Geralt is super fucking dry and a lot of the story works out the way it does due to him being like that.

Avatar image for therealturk
#36 Posted by TheRealTurk (576 posts) -

I think it looks fine for the most part. I've never been a fan of his acting, but Cavill at least looks the part, and a lot of the production design seems pretty good. Glad to see that there look to be some practical effects for some of the creatures as opposed to being a total CGI fest.

My only concerns are with Ciri and Yennifer. I'm glad that they are going back in the timeline to portray Yennifer pre-magicked beauty, but the actress feels like she lacks a certain . . . intensity? inherent in the character. The book version of Yennifer was pretty hard edged, bordering on sociopathic in spots, and I'm not sure I'm getting that here.

Ditto with Ciri. They've aged the character up, and I'll withhold judgment until I actually see where they're going with the plot, but she feels too waifish right now, enough that I can't really see them bridging the gap from that to where she ultimately ends up.

I dunno. Maybe I was just expecting a complete dumpster fire and what they're showing actually looks at least competent?

Avatar image for frytup
#37 Posted by frytup (1344 posts) -

Need to see more of Cavill actually acting, but I've always thought the English voice actor for the game series was awful, so my bar is not very high. Anything better than a bad Clint Eastwood impression will be an improvement.

As for the actual story... it's a world of magical monsters and a dude who kills them. The staying power of the series will hinge on how good the writers are at making an inherently silly and fantastical setting interesting.

Avatar image for nutter
#38 Posted by nutter (2284 posts) -

Love Witcher. Not sure about that trailer. Storytelling and acting are king, though, so I’ll give it a shot.

It feels weird that Geralt is more buff than fucking Superman, but hey, good on ya Henry Cavill, you goddamned brick shithouse!

Avatar image for glots
#39 Posted by glots (4380 posts) -

Looks ok. No expectations set personally, since I haven’t read the books and only played (some of) Witcher 3.

Avatar image for barrock
#40 Posted by Barrock (4154 posts) -

I really enjoyed the trailer, but people who actually saw the footage said it looks significantly cheaper than how the trailer indicates.

Avatar image for newhaap
#41 Posted by newhaap (511 posts) -

@liquiddragon: In case you wanted a better video of that panel, I found one - https://youtu.be/cLZms_s8SEc

Avatar image for fasterblaster
#42 Posted by fasterblaster (16 posts) -

Seems like a desperate attempt to get their own "game of thrones" style show. Not a fan of the casting choices.

Avatar image for sloppydetective
#43 Posted by SloppyDetective (1618 posts) -

@mezmero: I think he's much more likable in the books and has a more rounded personality in them. But I thought that Witcher 3 (the only game I've played of the series) made Geralt more of a cliched video game protagonist for the worse. I really did not start liking Geralt until Ciri re-entered the picture in Witcher 3.