Pick your favourite #10 game from past GOTYs
It's a hard choice between The Witcher 3 and Stardew Valley. But I'm going with Stardew Valley on this one.
Someone is gonna come in here and say something snarking indicating the opposite, so I'll just state for the record what the silent majority thinks of it.
Looking at that list, everything makes sense as 10th place. Split between games which might make it to the number one spot on some top-tens, but the GB guys just didn't play enough of or like quite as much as the general populace and games which were extremely popular with a niche segment of the gaming community, but which was more or less universally praised by anyone who put time into them, which included one or two people on staff. Not enough to go higher, but enough to just make the cut.
See, in the context of games like Stardew valley and Rogue Legacy, Dream Daddy totally fits in the column of "loved by people who really liked it, but not everyone played it'.
Which is a shame. Cause I feel like some games (Stardew valley) are the sort that if every single person on staff was forced to put 50+ hours into it..would have hit a higher number. (Same with the witcher 3). But those games at #10 fit given how much they were played by GB staff, or how much one or two people who did play them loved them while no one else had anything/enough bad to say about them.
So yah, Dream Daddy in the larger context fits perfectly as a #10 on GB list. There, my best defense against what has increasingly just become an excuse by people in the GB community to rag on certain staff members for, at best, shady reasons.
I was looking down the list one by one thinking "Man these are some pretty solid hits. I could pick any one of these."
But then I got to 2015. The Witcher 3 is the best game I've ever played.
I totally understand why it is so low on the list. It's actually pretty cool they gave it enough recognition to be on the list at all considering 90% of the people either didn't care for it or actively disliked it. And I dig that Giant Bombs lists are always so different from the mainstream opinion.
But it will always be funny that a game that I would put ahead of any other game in any year just BARELY made it on a list of the best games in just one year.
I have only played Rayman Origins and Rogue Legacy. And I didn't really care that much for Rayman Origins, so Rogue Legacy it is.
Sleeping Dogs got 10th? On this site? The fuck else came out that year?
Yeah, it should have had first. Great game, Sleeping Dogs.
X-Com won that year, followed by 2. The Walking Dead, 3. Far Cry 3, 4. Fez, 5. Journey, 6. Mark of the Ninja, 7. Syndicate, 8. Mass Effect 3, 9. ZombiU, 10. Sleeping Dogs
The Witcher 3.
Don't get me wrong I love Sleeping Dogs, Rogue Legacy and Stardew Valley but it's TW3 we're talking about here.
That's a tough one.
Witcher 3 was amazing, but I'm unlikely to play it again like I would Stardew Valley. Hmmm...
- Witcher 3
- Stardew Valley
- Rogue Legacy
Honestly? The only game I REALLY liked out of this bunch is Dream Daddy. So that's what I picked. Rayman is the closest, but I burned out fast.
Wait, Nuts and Bolts was number 10 in 2008? I thought that was higher considering that everybody on GB LOVED that game. Gonna need to check the list myself.
I voted Stardew.
When I eventually play more of The Witcher 3, that is my answer. My answer today is the delightful and incredibly satisfying Rayman Origins.
@ntm: The Best Game Out of the GB GOTY Winners tho I'm curious to see what it'd look like with Battlegrounds included.
Sleepy Dogs only made 10 that year? Criminal! Best game on that list by a mile. Rayman Origins and Rogue Legacy are also very good. Although I haven't played Stardew and Dream Daddy.... yet.
Which is a shame. Cause I feel like some games (Stardew valley) are the sort that if every single person on staff was forced to put 50+ hours into it..would have hit a higher number. (Same with the witcher 3). But those games at #10 fit given how much they were played by GB staff, or how much one or two people who did play them loved them while no one else had anything/enough bad to say about them.
Forcing someone to play a game they don't want to play is not the way to get them to like it. I forced myself to get through the Witcher 3, and I would probably have had a more positive experience with it if I stopped after the Bloody Baron quest.
Did they have an ordered top 10 in 2008? I don't think they did, though my vote will go to Nuts and Bolts.
Sleeping Dogs is my second choice. And also the only other game on the list I have actually played. Of the ones I haven't played I think Witcher 3 is the only one that has a chance of becoming my personal favorite. Though I am sure I'd like them all.
I picked Rayman but that's because I confused it with Legends, which I thought was a much better game. The Witcher 3 is the obvious choice.
Yeah, it's The Witcher 3 for me. The Giant Bomb crew's near-universal aversion to lengthy RPGs is one of those things I've just kinda learned to accept, but it's easily one of my favorite games of the last 5 years. There isn't a whole lot else on this list that I've played or really love (Well, I'll put it this way: the Destiny that got #10 in 2014 is not the Destiny I ended up spending dozens of hours on in 2015) besides Nuts and Bolts, which I guess I'm kinda baffled was so low? Given that the GOTY battle that year was between GTA 4 and MGS 4, I sure do think it's a lot better than either of those.
@liquiddragon: Oh yeah, I already voted on that one. I'd still choose The Last of Us.
Considering the state of the games at the time of voting. Stardew Valley was the best of the number 10s. In their current state the best game is... Stardew Valley
The Witcher 3 "only" got number 10 on the list because of The Witcher 3. At release it was well liked, but basically the whole crew fell off it. But more importantly it. a) Ran like shit at the time, b) had a widely hated control scheme.
Still baffled at the dislike for Witcher 3 and then all the Zelda love when Witcher 3 does everything Zelda does but better.
I think there are similarities but the reasons people like Zelda aren't the things that it adopted from The Witcher. My favourite part of Zelda is the exploration, the novelty of having to climb high and look around to find interesting things, and you almost always do. The Witcher, while doing a lot of great stuff for RPG's, is still a map with a lot of icons on it, which is to its detriment. (I'm saying this as someone who really does love The Witcher 3, too).
For my money, Stardew Valley is the best game on that list. I think it's pretty obvious that most people are gonna vote Witcher 3, but jeez did I lose a lot of hours in a relatively short space of time to Stardew Valley. I keep repurchasing on different consoles, I keep playing it.
Still baffled at the dislike for Witcher 3 and then all the Zelda love when Witcher 3 does everything Zelda does but better.
I don't know how long it took you to write that sentence to be as triggering as possible, but you sure nailed it.
I'll attempt to not be the fuel you threw that burning match towards, but I will say that Zelda does a lot of things W3 does not do. The reasons for liking both or either can be wildly different.
Witcher by a mile. Destiny at the second spot. Everything else somewhere in the mud grappling for scraps.
That's a hard pick between Sleeping Dogs and Stardew Valley for me. Sorry Wei Shen but I'm going with my blueberry farmer.
Rogue Legacy hit me hard in a spot I didn't know I had and left me yearning for a genre that started and ended with the game. Sure there are similar games but none play like RL did. :(
Stardew Valley is pretty good. Looking forward to the multiplayer patch that the dev showed on twitter recently.
Sleeping Dogs also good - especially for a Hong Kong cinema fan.
The rest is hot trash. •‿•
Please Log In to post.
Log in to comment