Red Dead Redemption vs Mass Effect 2?

I'm guessing a lot of GOTY lists are going to be between these two?

ME2, simply because I think it's better and I enjoyed it more. I still thouroughly enjoyed RDR.

RDR, simply because I think it's better and I enjoyed it more.

Don't make me choose.

I really don't know if I can choose... I loved them both for much different reasons.

" Don't make me choose. "

Mass Effect 2 by far. I don't want to go into why, because there are so many reason, but yeah.

Mass Effect 2 was simply a better game, anyone who disagrees only owns a PS3 and n.ever played it on 360 or PC. Red Dead was awesome, I even 100% the game, and the scene when you first enter Mexico was sublime and may be my favorite gaming moment ever. But the gameplay in ME2 and the characters were near perfect. It is the best game this generation.

i'm commander shepard and this is my favorite game on the citadel.

" Mass Effect 2 was simply a better game, anyone who disagrees only owns a PS3 and n.ever played it on 360 or PC. Red Dead was awesome, I even 100% the game, and the scene when you first enter Mexico was sublime and may be my favorite gaming moment ever. But the gameplay in ME2 and the characters were near perfect. It is the best game this generation. "

I've played through ME2 twice and I'm taking a break on RDR after Mexico.

Although I absolutely LOVED Red Dead's environments and characters, I'm going to have to go with Mass Effect 2 for the complexity and art direction.

Since i tried Mass Effect several times and attempted to enjoy it but to no avail, since its too complicated and boring, i'll go with Red Dead Redemption

I haven't played Red Dead Redemption, but if it's anything like Rockstar's previous open-world games, Mass Effect 2.

Mass Effect 2 so far, but Vanquish is coming soon. And then there is Mafia II. But right now: Me2