Should I buy _____ or _____

There are way too many topics about whether someone should buy Brutal Legend or Uncharted 2, or whether they should buy Fallout 3 or Demon's Souls so why not mesh it all into one, uniform topic? 
 
Remember people, always give background information: whether you like heavy metal, whether you played (and liked) the first Uncharted or countless other relative variables.

Should I buy uncharted 2 or brutal legend?!?!?!??!?!?!

To be fair, you don't have to like heavy metal at all to completely enjoy Brutal Legend.

Should I buy WET or Katamari Forever?

That'll get quickly confused as people ask questions and answers get mashed together. Lets cut up Wikipedia articles, shuffle them together and then piece out the article we're looking for, yay! 
 
If my sarcasm has offended you in any way at all then you smell funny.

" Should I buy uncharted 2 or brutal legend?!?!?!??!?!?! "

" Should I buy WET or Katamari Forever? "

" Should I buy a PS3 or a couple of Games for the xbox 360? "

Should I eat an orange, or take my dog for a walk!?

" Should I eat an orange, or take my dog for a walk!? "

" Should I eat an orange, or take my dog for a walk!? "

" @Red: I'm probably going to get mass effect 2 when it comes out , Borderlands, maybe Brutal Legend, and Forza 3. I'm not sure though about that list and I'm upgrading my computer next year so I'm going to get borderlands on it instead. PS3 is tempting me with Last Guardian and Heavy Rain and I would watch Blu ray movies on it and use it to play what already came out in 08? Its not very clear but I'm most likely going to save up for a Ps3. "

How about life time supply of free porn and video games or the most beautiful lady in the world to love and marry?

" Should I buy a line6 UX1 or a line6 UX2?  I think you can still upgrade to PodFarm Pro with a UX1 but if you can't I guess I can always buy the tone packs separately anyway... "

Everyone should go buy Uncharted 2 for the next couple of requests.

Should I buy Forza 3 or Assassin's Creed II?

" Should I buy Forza 3 or Assassin's Creed II? "

Should I get cake or pie?

Should I try and stay up, or actually go to bed?

Uncharted 2 or Brutal Legend? 
 
I'm really leaning towards Brutal Legend because I never played the first Uncharted. Do you think it'll be necessary to enjoy the second one?

" Uncharted 2 or Brutal Legend?  I'm really leaning towards Brutal Legend because I never played the first Uncharted. Do you think it'll be necessary to enjoy the second one? "

" Uncharted 2 or Brutal Legend?  I'm really leaning towards Brutal Legend because I never played the first Uncharted. Do you think it'll be necessary to enjoy the second one? "

" @DanielJW said:

" Uncharted 2 or Brutal Legend?  I'm really leaning towards Brutal Legend because I never played the first Uncharted. Do you think it'll be necessary to enjoy the second one? "

Not especially, but once the holiday releases calm down, I definitely recommend picking up the first Uncharted and playing it back to back with Uncharted 2, so I guess you should wait for that pie by playing some cake, which also answers a previous question. "

" Should I buy Forza 3 or Assassin's Creed II? "

" Should I try and stay up, or actually go to bed? "

" @DanielJW: I say get Brutal Legend, and then when you have more money, get Uncharted 1 and Uncharted 2. "

Should I get a customized apron, or one of those five pound gummy bears?

" Should I get a customized apron, or one of those five pound gummy bears? "

I'm too busy playing my Wii to care about these games. Lolz... HD...

Should I buy a PS3 or Katamari Forever?

Should I buy a condom or a dildo? 
 
safety first, kids.

Hrm...
 
Pokemon Soul Silver or Pokemon Heart Gold?

The Brutal Legend vs. Uncharted is a much harder decision.  As much as Brutal Legend looks astoundingly awesome, Uncharted seems like you NEED to buy it if you're a PS3 owner.

As far as Fallout 3 vs. Demon's Souls, I'd say got with Fallout 3.  Especially if you're gonna go with the GOTY edition, it seems like Fallout is just an easier recommendation over the smaller target audience of Demon's Souls.

" Should I buy a condom or a dildo?   safety first, kids. "

" Hrm...  Pokemon Soul Silver or Pokemon Heart Gold? "

Well instead of buying ____ or ____ I preordered both, that solved the problem for me.