Super Mario Galaxy or Super Smash Bros Brawl

Avatar image for kingkoopa
#1 Posted by KingKoopa (118 posts) -

After the two must buy nintendo games ( Super Mario Galaxy and Super Smash Bros. Brawl ) came out and were automatic hits on the system. They were the games that we were waiting for on the nintendo wii.

After those games came out on the wii which one do you think was the best and the one you were waiting for more?

Avatar image for brucie
#2 Posted by Brucie (136 posts) -

Brawl and Brawl.

Galaxy was overrated....

Avatar image for brucie
#3 Posted by Brucie (136 posts) -

Brawl and Brawl.

Galaxy was overrated...

Avatar image for termite
#4 Posted by Termite (2428 posts) -

Depends if you can get people to come over to your house all the time. If so then Brawl

Avatar image for comedy
#5 Posted by comedy (102 posts) -

If you feel like playing a fun platformer, galaxy. If you have friends or big on competition go with Brawl. Brawl has a lot of "hidden" depth to it.

Avatar image for i_smell
#6 Posted by I_smell (4221 posts) -

Galaxy.
My mates would laugh if I seriously suggested we play Super Smash Bros Brawl. Then beat me up.
I'd deserve it for sayin somethin so stupid.

Avatar image for blackwaterco
#7 Posted by BlackWaterCO (1685 posts) -

SMG by a long shot

Avatar image for twenty0ne
#8 Posted by twenty0ne (3056 posts) -

Brawl. I can't stand Super Mario Galaxy.

Avatar image for bladefire
#9 Posted by Bladefire (221 posts) -

Galaxy for sure I can't stand SSB, always just seemed like a crappy fighting game to me (much rather play something like Street Fighter).

Avatar image for bennyboy
#10 Posted by bennyboy (345 posts) -

Brawl for multiplayer, I guess. Galaxy got old after a while because of how easy it was.

Avatar image for thriteenthmonkey
#11 Posted by Thriteenthmonkey (80 posts) -

Galaxy by far

Avatar image for blackwaterco
#12 Posted by BlackWaterCO (1685 posts) -
Brucie said:
"Brawl and Brawl.

Galaxy was overrated..."

No. Hell No.
Avatar image for maguszxz
#13 Posted by maguszxz (6 posts) -

I find myself still drawn to Super Mario Galaxy. It can be frustrating at times but I would still suggest that game if someone asked me about it.

Avatar image for marthman7
#14 Posted by MarthMan7 (13 posts) -

galaxy is fun but brawl is the best wii game ever

Avatar image for tec3297
#15 Posted by tec3297 (1258 posts) -

I have to say Super Mario Galaxy...no Super Smash Bros Brawl...no it's wayy to hard to choose.

Avatar image for darklegend
#16 Posted by DarkLegend (1383 posts) -

Smash Brother Brawl... multiplayer.

Avatar image for worldsfastestshrimppeeler
#17 Posted by WorldsFastestShrimpPeeler (469 posts) -

Galaxy is  fun, but I prefer Brawl of it.

Avatar image for foil_charizard
#18 Posted by Foil_Charizard (350 posts) -

Every time I play Galaxy I get bored after 10 minutes, so Brawl ftw.

Avatar image for mikael
#19 Posted by Mikael (40 posts) -

Galaxy

Avatar image for ifnot
#20 Posted by Ifnot (61 posts) -

Dude that's so hard, depends what mood I'm in

Avatar image for marthman7
#21 Posted by MarthMan7 (13 posts) -

brawl is the best game ever galaxy doesn't even compare

Avatar image for ifnot
#22 Posted by Ifnot (61 posts) -

Yes it does, dude, galaxy is awesome when it comes to 1player, and brawl is awesome when it comes to multi player.

Avatar image for mushir
#23 Posted by Mushir (2630 posts) -

The games are very different. Both of them are must buys for the Wii. It doesn't matter which game you buy because both of them are awesome. Buy one and after some time buy the other one.

Avatar image for svglol
#24 Posted by svglol (30 posts) -

Dude though both awesome games, but for smash bros its really only a multiplayer game and is it better when your playing with friends in real life.
Super Mario Galaxy is Awesome I had so much fun playing it, and its got a good singleplayer and defienitly one of the best looking wii games.
I'd have to say Super Mario Galaxy is the better one, but considering Brawl was my first smash bros game I may not know enough about smash bros to really understand it all.

Avatar image for why_so_serious
#25 Posted by Why_So_Serious (880 posts) -

I would have to say Brawl. Galaxy doesn't have enough replay value. Brawl has online, infinite replay value, and a huge cast of characters.

Avatar image for tdot
#26 Posted by TDot (462 posts) -

Do you have to choose? I mean I wouldn't go cherry picking core Wii games. Brawl was just more smash bros but Galaxy at least was a new game intended for the wii so I'd have to pick that one. but really enjoy them both as much as you can... it doesn't look like anything else is on the horizon.

Avatar image for thordain
#27 Posted by Thordain (980 posts) -

Brawl is fun, but I'd easily choose Galaxy.

Avatar image for disen
#28 Posted by Knives (756 posts) -

I enjoyed Galaxy more.

Avatar image for rckbikes
#29 Posted by rckbikes (92 posts) -

i don't know how you can compare the two considering they're at different on different spectrum of genres, but if you had one in either hand, i'd go with brawl

Avatar image for met2609
#30 Posted by Met2609 (635 posts) -

I haven't played either, but the concept of Super Mario Galaxy interests me more.

Avatar image for scorched
#31 Posted by Scorched (772 posts) -

Galaxy

Avatar image for epic_pets
#32 Posted by epic_pets (1345 posts) -

Brawl!Galaxy is over rated

Avatar image for hazelnutman
#33 Posted by hazelnutman (1121 posts) -

If you're seriously asking people to make a purchase decision, it seems that you really need to get a game that's worth your money.

In that case, I suggest Brawl.

More bang for your buck.

Avatar image for colonel_cool
#34 Posted by Colonel_Cool (826 posts) -
Brucie said:
"Brawl and Brawl.

Galaxy was overrated...."
I disagree. I thought Brawl was very overrated, and Galaxy was refreshingly original. Brawl was fun, but I had already played the crap out of Melee years before. Its nice how it had a lot of content, but not much about the game felt new, only minor improvements. It honestly felt like more of an expansion pack to Melee with new characters, stages, and items than a whole new game.
Avatar image for solidphoenix
#35 Posted by solidphoenix (293 posts) -

If you want to play a great single-player game then go for Super Mario Galaxy, otherwise for the multiplayer experience go Super Smash Brothers Brawl.
That being said, I think Super Mario Galaxy is a better single-player game than Super Smash Brothers Brawl is a multiplayer game, primarily because the jump from Sunshine to Galaxy is a lot more drastic and resulting in a fantastic game than the jump from Melee to Brawl.

Avatar image for falkien
#36 Posted by Falkien (241 posts) -
solidphoenix said:
"If you want to play a great single-player game then go for Super Mario Galaxy, otherwise for the multiplayer experience go Super Smash Brothers Brawl.
That being said, I think Super Mario Galaxy is a better single-player game than Super Smash Brothers Brawl is a multiplayer game, primarily because the jump from Sunshine to Galaxy is a lot more drastic and resulting in a fantastic game than the jump from Melee to Brawl.
"

exactly
Avatar image for jonathan
#37 Posted by Jonathan (692 posts) -

Galaxy BY FAR. Brawl is one of the most overrated games ever created. It plays and looks almost identical to melee.

Avatar image for whisperkill
#38 Posted by Whisperkill (3044 posts) -

Galaxy >>>>>>>> SSBB

 

Brawl is not a very good game at all

Avatar image for willy105
#39 Posted by Willy105 (4935 posts) -

Galaxy was better than Brawl. But Brawl was still epic.

Avatar image for chazer127
#40 Posted by chazer127 (216 posts) -

Brawl, Nuff said.

Avatar image for manks
#41 Posted by Manks (862 posts) -

Super Mario Galaxy FTW!

Brawl was overrated I traded it in after 5 days with it.

Avatar image for dj_lafleur
#42 Posted by DJ_LaFleur (183 posts) -

both are amazing games, and I have played both for large quantities of time.

Playing brawl with others is more fun than Galaxy, but because I have not had many moments of playing Brawl with my friends, I will  say galaxy.

Avatar image for ssbabel
#43 Posted by SSbabel (1216 posts) -

Both great games plus i own both but im more of fan of Galaxy over Brawl.

Avatar image for hyper_hedgehog
#44 Posted by Hyper_Hedgehog (89 posts) -

Galaxy. It was better in all aspects, excluding multiplayer.

Avatar image for mario_galaxy_fan
#45 Posted by Mario_Galaxy_Fan (151 posts) -

Super Mario Galaxy it felt different to its predessors Brawl didn't feel much different from Melee.

Avatar image for timeshero
#46 Posted by TimesHero (974 posts) -

I enjoyed galaxy, but me not being a completest, just went through the "story", if you can even call it that.  But over all, I had more fun with Brawl.