• 83 results
  • 1
  • 2
Avatar image for cptmorganca
Posted by CptMorganCA (234 posts) 4 years, 1 month ago

Poll: The Greatest Console Shooter (this generation)? Let's be respectful :) (147 votes)

Call of Duty Black Ops II 3%
Call of Duty Black Ops 1%
Call of Duty 4: Modern Warfare 46%
Battlefield 3 10%
Battlefield: Bad Company 2 14%
Halo 3 14%
Halo Reach 5%
Halo 4 2%
Battlefield: Bad Company 1?? 2%
Call of Duty: Modern Warfare 2 6%

Now, first of all, every one of these games is great in it's own way if you ask me. Not looking for meaningless wars, just curious what people's favorite shooter is and why. Let's keep it purely conversational and respectful :) (and don't hesitate to point out what I left out of the choices)

I say BF: Bad Company 2, because of it's superb balance of weapons and excellent map design. I will take Battlefield's immense scale and teamwork-based gameplay over the more personal and twitch-based CoD games any day. I'm a big fan of Halo Reach, but I can never play more than a match or so at a time without getting bored.

Avatar image for animasta
#1 Posted by Animasta (14903 posts) -

so, uh, apparently the only shooters that exist are halo, call of duty and battlefield?

Avatar image for cptmorganca
#2 Edited by CptMorganCA (234 posts) -
@animasta said:

so, uh, apparently the only shooters that exist are halo, call of duty and battlefield?

Like I said, if your favorite isn't included, please point it out! Just didn't want to put 30 answers. :)

Avatar image for darthorange
#3 Posted by DarthOrange (4178 posts) -

You list is missing Bioshock, Alan Wake, Gears of War 3, Uncharted 3 (or Uncharted 2 as some prefer), MAG (the sheer scope of that game makes it deserve recognition) and Resistance 3. And that is just off the top of my head.

Avatar image for grimluck343
#4 Posted by Grimluck343 (1371 posts) -

As much as everyone likes to rag on CoD, I feel like the first Modern Warfare had the greatest overall impact on games this generation, not just shooters.

Avatar image for cptmorganca
#5 Posted by CptMorganCA (234 posts) -

You list is missing Bioshock, Alan Wake, Gears of War 3, Uncharted 3 (or Uncharted 2 as some prefer), MAG (the sheer scope of that game makes it deserve recognition) and Resistance 3. And that is just off the top of my head.

What I really forgot to do was say "Greatest Multiplayer Shooter", because that's what I meant lol. But yea, should've thrown Uncharted 3 and MAG in there.

Avatar image for cptmorganca
#6 Posted by CptMorganCA (234 posts) -

As much as everyone likes to rag on CoD, I feel like the first Modern Warfare had the greatest overall impact on games this generation, not just shooters.

I would mostly agree! It definitely helped shape modern standards for multiplayer in general, and was responsible for the idea of every game needing to have a MP component.

Avatar image for damisterchief
#7 Edited by DaMisterChief (612 posts) -

I'd say Modern Warfare 2, 60 Fps, streamling (COD4's) to the lustful ranking up (making Multiplayer last long and keep you playing endlessly. The hype train for this game was CRAZY, then of course COD is what it is today. Also i spent 600+ hours playing this game (I've stopped playing COD since then). I was sooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo hyped when this trailer came out.

Loading Video...

Avatar image for grimluck343
#8 Posted by Grimluck343 (1371 posts) -

@cptmorganca I guess another interesting question would be whether or not it's a positive impact on the industry.

Avatar image for cptmorganca
#9 Posted by CptMorganCA (234 posts) -

UPDATE: Hey everyone, it's important to know that when naming the poll I meant to say "Greatest Multiplayer Shooter", which is why there are obvious single player shooters absent like Bioshock and Alan Wake.

Also, some obvious omissions include Gears of War and Uncharted.

Avatar image for cptmorganca
#10 Posted by CptMorganCA (234 posts) -

I'd say Modern Warfare 2, 60 Fps, streamling (COD4's) to the lustful ranking up (making Multiplayer last long and keep you playing endlessly. The hype train for this game was CRAZY, then of course COD is what it is today. Also i spent 600+ hours playing this game (I've stopped playing COD since then). I was sooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo hyped when this trailer came out.

Loading Video...

I was also pretty bananas for MW2 when it came out. They improved on basically everything from 4, not to mention it was a big refresher after WaW.

Avatar image for miketakon
#11 Posted by Miketakon (535 posts) -

CoD4 is the only answer.

Avatar image for hiono
#12 Posted by hiono (71 posts) -

if were talking about impact then the only answer is cod4 but my favorite is shadowrun by far

Avatar image for cptmorganca
#13 Posted by CptMorganCA (234 posts) -

@hiono said:

if were talking about impact then the only answer is cod4 but my favorite is shadowrun by far

Shadowrun is a very interesting choice! I remember playing that a lot for a while. I really loved the powers and the Counter-Strikeness of it.

Avatar image for mistasparkle
#14 Posted by MistaSparkle (2285 posts) -

Torn between Halo 3 and CoD4...

Avatar image for fattony12000
#15 Posted by Fattony12000 (8273 posts) -

Borderlands was pretty cool.

Avatar image for aetheldod
#16 Edited by Aetheldod (3914 posts) -

@cptmorganca: Not to be a dick but most of those are available for PC as well .... so a Halo game wins by defeault (mine would be Reach)

Avatar image for joshthebear
#17 Posted by joshthebear (2704 posts) -
Avatar image for cptmorganca
#18 Posted by CptMorganCA (234 posts) -

@cptmorganca: Not to be a dick but most of those are available for PC as well .... so a Halo game wins by defeault (mine would be Reach)

You misinterpreted the title. Didn't mean to make it sound like these games are console exclusives, just games that are on consoles.

Avatar image for warfare
#19 Posted by Warfare (1683 posts) -

Rainbow Six: Vegas

Avatar image for thepencil
#20 Posted by ThePencil (395 posts) -

Team Fortress 2.

Hilarity? Check! Interesting classes and abilities? Check! A multiplayer I'm shite at but hey, there's 40 people in this game so I'm bound to kill som- OH GAWD DAMN SPIES!? Double fucking check! A Scotsman akin to those I grew up with, including patented Whiskey Bottle? Feckin aye! (and lets not forget loot, trading, the 'Meet The' videos and-and...oh wait 'The Greatest CONSOLE Shooter...thats also multiplayer)

*remembers TF2 on 360*

...

...

Fuckit, Gears of War 3...

Avatar image for randominternetuser
#21 Posted by RandomInternetUser (6805 posts) -

CoD4. Not even a hard choice for me.

BF3 is still fucking good, though, and would be the shooter I would play right now if I wasn't kind of tired of shooters for a bit.

Avatar image for bigboss1911
#22 Edited by BigBoss1911 (2835 posts) -

Very Original poll options......anyway Killzone 2

Avatar image for mandude
#23 Edited by mandude (2827 posts) -

I voted for Call of Duty 4 before I realised I've never played it on a console.

Avatar image for pillclinton
#24 Posted by PillClinton (3551 posts) -

CoD4, let's not be crazy here now. Biggest impact on the industry by a single game this gen, let alone FPS, bar none.

Avatar image for ll_exile_ll
#25 Posted by ll_Exile_ll (2696 posts) -

Even if the poll is meant to be multiplayer only, this is still a terrible list of options. How is this supposed to represent the entire generation when only games from three series are listed?

Avatar image for rpgee
#26 Edited by rpgee (775 posts) -

"Greatest" is such a nebulous term that it's not even really appropriate in most instances. Is it the best quality? Is it the most influential? Is it the most popular? It's kind of an overused term all round, to me.

That said, COD4 was the one that made multiplayer at all appealing to my young self, was ridiculously popular, basically changed the nature of what the standard for multiplayer shooters was for those following, did a lot of good shit. And hey, the campaign wasn't bad either.

Avatar image for bollard
#27 Posted by Bollard (7562 posts) -

It's COD4, there's no contest. No other game had such a knock-on effect on the way literally every game has been developed since.

Avatar image for vexxan
#28 Posted by Vexxan (4633 posts) -

I had a lot of fun with Gears of War 3. I vastly prefer co-op(fuck yeah horde mode!) to competitive gaming when it comes to shooter games.

Avatar image for dauthi693
#29 Posted by Dauthi693 (131 posts) -

I think CoD4:MW was the most important shooter this gen but my opinion would be Halo 3 and Battlefield 3 were better multiplayer shooters just they didn't have the impact of COD4:MW.

Avatar image for Levius
#30 Posted by Levius (1357 posts) -

I easily had the most multiplayer fun with Killzone 3 this generation, I think it was the best CoD varient come out. I had one of the best class systems outside of TF2. That being said I think I got the the fourth prestige on MW2 though.

Avatar image for cptmorganca
#31 Posted by CptMorganCA (234 posts) -

Even if the poll is meant to be multiplayer only, this is still a terrible list of options. How is this supposed to represent the entire generation when only games from three series are listed?

Like I said man, if your favorite isn't up there, I'm interested to see what it is. I only made it a poll to make it interesting, it's meant to be a discussion.

Avatar image for gogosox82
#32 Edited by gogosox82 (452 posts) -

What about TF2? I still have fun with that game and I've been playing it for like 3 years. I also thought killzone2's multiplayer was pretty good. BFBC was a fun game to play.

Avatar image for project343
#33 Edited by project343 (2895 posts) -

Okay. So multiplayer-only?

My poll: Rainbow Six Vegas 2; your poll: Modern Warfare.

(also, why wouldn't you have Gears of War 3 or Killzone 3 on there?)

Avatar image for authenticm
#34 Posted by AuthenticM (4301 posts) -

Bad Company 2, hands down.

Avatar image for mrcraggle
#35 Posted by mrcraggle (2877 posts) -

@bigboss1911: Oh man, Killzone 2 multiplayer was fantastic but then 3 really had to ruin it. To me they lost a lot of what was so special from Killzone 2. Fuck the haters who complained it felt too heavy, I really enjoyed the way it felt. It also had a very good match-making system as I actually got my PS3 in 2009 and picked up Killzone 2 with it but the scene was still alive and it did a very good job of putting equal level players in the same matches, something that KZ3 scrapped.

Avatar image for seppli
#36 Edited by Seppli (11232 posts) -

It was Battlefield Bad Company 1 that got me into playing FPS games on consoles and truely enjoying online multiplayer gameplay on consoles. So that has been the most impactful and important for me. Also love the extensive environmental destruction that it brought to the mix. Don't want to miss that in any of my shooters.

My absolute favorite online multiplayer FPS experience of this console generation however? BF:BC 2 Vietnam. Most fun choppers ever. And then the music! Nothing quite like it. To this very day.

Avatar image for happenstance
#37 Posted by happenstance (517 posts) -

Before my interest in shooters dropped off I probably had the most fun with COD 4 so im gonna go with that.

Avatar image for ares42
#38 Posted by Ares42 (3561 posts) -

The most influental is easily CoD4, however Far Cry 3 pretty much proved that "shooters" can be so much more than just corridor shooting and deathmatch multiplayer. If only the genre went back to it's roots of exploration over spectacle....

Still though, depending on how technical you want to be about it, Fallout 3 and Mass Effect are both "shooters" and easily quite superior to any of these traditional FPS's in my mind. Hell even the Uncharted series is way better when it comes to it's single-player content, but I would assume that's not what's in question here.

Avatar image for hiono
#39 Edited by hiono (71 posts) -

@hiono said:

if were talking about impact then the only answer is cod4 but my favorite is shadowrun by far

Shadowrun is a very interesting choice! I remember playing that a lot for a while. I really loved the powers and the Counter-Strikeness of it.

i was really into competitive shooters at the time, didnt have a good pc, and hated halo 3 so it was the perfect fit for me at the time. i only have good memories of it

Avatar image for crusader8463
#40 Posted by crusader8463 (14757 posts) -

I loved the story and cast of Bad Company so much that I was willing to try an over look my hatred for playing shooters on consoles just to play that game. So it gets my vote.

Avatar image for lego_my_eggo
#41 Posted by Lego_My_Eggo (1220 posts) -

Call of Duty 4 no question. It had a good single player campaign, and a fun, fast multiplayer with a leveling up and gun customization mechanic that every other online game (not even just shooters) stole from.

But Killzone 2 gets an honorable mention. It had good clan support, an interesting combination of class based characters that you could customize abilities for, a website to keep track of stats and a way to review battles, and the way they combined all the gametypes in warzone was awesome, and even tho everyone else hated the heavy fell of the controls i liked em. Then Killzone 3 had to mess it up.

Avatar image for epicsteve
#42 Edited by EpicSteve (6908 posts) -

Call of Duty 4 was this generation's GTA III.

Avatar image for awesomeusername
#43 Edited by awesomeusername (4606 posts) -

MW2 was shit. Also,

Call of Duty 4 was this generation's GTA III.

Avatar image for justin258
#44 Posted by Justin258 (14375 posts) -

UPDATE: Hey everyone, it's important to know that when naming the poll I meant to say "Greatest Multiplayer Shooter", which is why there are obvious single player shooters absent like Bioshock and Alan Wake.

Also, some obvious omissions include Gears of War and Uncharted.

Ah, and here I was about to settle in for some thinking on which shooter I enjoyed the most this generation. See, I'm stuck in this age-old mindset that when people say "greatest video game", I don't even think about multiplayer.

But that doesn't mean that I don't play multiplayer. I liked Halo 3 a whole hell of a lot, I played it with friends from high school for a couple of years. Another reason I would say it is because it was one of the last few big multiplayer shooters that didn't unlock new stuff as you progressed. I don't want to say that it didn't have a progression system per se because you could get new ranks and stuff, but you never unlocked anything. Generally, everyone started with the same gun and you picked up the rocket launcher from its spawn point, not from a menu. I think Halo Reach was the last big-name multiplayer shooter that was like that. CS:GO doesn't have unlocks either, but it does ask you to pay money if you die during a round for new guns.

Avatar image for donpixel
#45 Posted by DonPixel (2833 posts) -

I vote Battlefield 3, because I like Battlefield. There, solid argument.

Avatar image for blueneurosis
#46 Posted by blueneurosis (240 posts) -

Battlefield: Bad Company 2 for me. I played CoD MW 1&2 but wasn't quite happy with it. Probably my skills weren't meant for such twitch-and-dead things, but BC2 managed to take that twitch gaming that I enjoyed-despite-sucking and overlaid a layer of team-emphasis tactics that could transform a punk like me into an invaluable support player (repair, spotter, etc).

Avatar image for winternet
#47 Posted by Winternet (8397 posts) -

If you're going to try to make a somewhat serious poll, then you should be better prepared.

Also, it's obvious that COD 4 would take the most votes.

Avatar image for little_socrates
#48 Posted by Little_Socrates (5844 posts) -

If we're voting for multiplayer shooters, I'd be hard pressed to choose between Call of Duty 4, Halo 3, Team Fortress 2, and Left 4 Dead 2. Sure, TF2 and L4D2 are better on PC, but so is Battlefield 3, so, yeah.

Avatar image for youngfrey
#49 Posted by YoungFrey (1363 posts) -

I'd call this a longshot, but Dust 514 has crazy potential being both an MMO and tied to the craziest game out there EVE Online. But having played it, I can't say it's there yet.

Avatar image for warlordpayne
#50 Posted by WarlordPayne (774 posts) -

Probably Mass Effect 3. I can't get enough of the multiplayer in that game.