I am someone who revisits old classics a lot. I rather replay something near and dear to my heart than play something entirely new I don't feel strongly about. I figure some people might be the same way. By 'older' for this thread I just mean 'didn't release this year'.
I am currently playing Kingdoms of Amalur: Reckoning. The story is quite bland, the world looks colorful, but every single NPC has no personality whatsoever, but the actual combat and leveling are a ton of fun. Good game if you're looking to scratch a certain RPG itch. I'm also playing The Secret World here and there, which is a fantastic MMO. Unfortunately no one is available to play it with me and it only stays fun by yourself for so long.
I'm very curious to hear what everyone else is playing.