What's your prediction of where Brothers will land on Brads top 10?

Where did Diablo 3 land in his list last year :p

Brothers = Plural

Brother = Singular

Number 2.

@jimmyfenix: but what other game got him to say this is in his top 10. I may not recall one right now but I haven't heard anything recently. With that said I also think it'll be #2

it'll be either 2nd or 3rd, but wouldn't 10th be great?

Spots 1-10

It's the only way this won't end in blood

I kinda hope it doesn't show up. Or, I guess I should say I'd like to see it as an honorable mention at 11. Now that would be terrific!

@kirillorlov: Brad is unpredictable. NO one knew he would put Mass effect 3 at number 1 last year. I think he will put Dota 2 as number one this year.

11.

Two. One will invariably be DOTA 2.

Where's the option for "it won't" or perhaps "it shouldn't"?

So we think he'll take DOTA in his top 10 because technically it came out of beta and was released this year?

DOTA's gotta be number 1. And I cant name a specific game, but I'm sure that Brad had to like SOMETHING else more than he liked Brothers. So I feel fairly confident saying 3.

im bettin 6 or 7

I voted 1 but now that I think about it DOTA 2 will probably be 1, or it should be considering how much he seems to play it.

Maybe he shocks us all and it's not even in his Top 10. But who knows...

About 3 or 4.

At this point, I am guessing he would put it even if it felt undeserved. Since I don't know if there are many games he liked more this year (other than DOTA), I think it would be pretty high.

2 just to spite Jeff.

Hmm. 8 is the only spot no one has voted for. So its probably that, right.

I'm gonna guess 3. Dota 2 will most likely be #1, and 2 could be something like BioShock or Last of Us or possibly the new DMC.

I hope it's 10

Way too many people voted for 1 when every time it comes up Brad clearly says that he never claimed it was his GotY.

#1 - #3

4-6.

Didn't he explicitly say that he enjoyed Mario 3D World more during that Quick Look? Wouldn't surprise me if that, Brothers, Dota, and Last of Us made up his top four. Not certain the order.

@hatking: hmm I don't recall. But you maybe right about Mario. Agreed about those games in his top 5. Not sure what the 5th would be but top 5 for sure.

I think Brad will be so glad when this boring joke is no longer relevant xD

We can only hope he doesn't because that would be the most hilarious result.

You beat me to it.

Brothers won't be his 1, he already stated a couple games he liked more than Brothers (Mario is an example) plus he spent so much time with DOTA 2 I don't see how it won't be number 1 it's probably one of his all-time favorite games.

It's going to be number one hands down. He loved that game like his own brother. You could tell on the podcast when he was spurting nothing but praise for the game.

4-6. We know he likes Dota more, he said Gone Home was about equal so that could go either way, he was open to the possibility of Zelda being better as well. When Brothers came out he wasn't saying it was his favorite game of the year or anything either.

Dota's gotta be 1, so really we're looking at 2-10.

@kirillorlov: Oh, you know what? I think I was had my Nintendo games mixed up. I think he said that about Zelda, not Mario.

Won't be 1. No matter what. Better games for Brad or not, he won't be able to put it there sincerely without thinking of the long running stupid joke.

Also, lest we forget Brad recently started and probably by now has finished Last of Us. He seemed to be really into last we heard from him.

I'm guessing 3rd after Dota and The Last of Us.

Giant Bomb isn't really known for caving to peer pressure, though.

...I kinda hope it is number eleven. Or just not in his top ten at all.

I just hope I don't get too mad this year. I had to be taken away in a straight jacket in 2011 after what Brad did.

I'd have to guess number 3, with DOTA 2 being number 1 or 2. Like others have said though, it would be fantastic if it ended up with an "honorable" no. 11 :P.

At worst it has to be 3. Can't be 1 because that's DOTA. So 2 or 3. The way he's talked about that game if it were anything BUT 2 or 3, it would see hilariously foolish on his part.

Man seems like I should have made a poll of where DOTA was going to end up... So sounds like Brothers top 3 and DOTA top 2?

2 or 3, 1 is definitely dota

it will make eleventh place. Brad will drown his shame at his false proclamation by playing Dota 2 for days on end without sleep until he hallucinates the entire plot of Brothers in first-person.

I thought he said Mario 3D World was better than Brothers. I also thought he said that about a Zelda game but I don't remember which one. And of course there is DotA. So I voted for fourth but maybe some stuff he rushed to finish before the GotY discussions got to him and dropped it to five or six.

10

Frog Fractions 2 comes out, Brothers moves to 11th

If looking at the year when he got into SC2 that was also the year it was number two on his list and the number one went to Red Dead Redemption. I don't see any other game this year that had the same effect on Brad though that was the same as Red Dead Redemption and Dota 2 was the only thing that really maintained his interest for the entirety of the year and when asked if Brothers was better than Dota, he declined to give any definitive answer. I'm guessing Dota 2 takes his top spot and Brothers takes either third or second.

Either 2nd or 10th in my opinion. If anything, He kind has to put it in his top 10 now or it will be another thing that people won't let him live down, Especially next year when they do their Top games of 2014!

It won't be on the list at all because it would be too predictable.