Who's your favorite reviewer these days?

Avatar image for liquiddragon
#1 Posted by liquiddragon (3526 posts) -

Hey, I'm wondering who ppl really trust or align with taste-wise in regards to game reviews.

I've always been in this bubble and Gamespot before GB arrived and thought maybe I'd check out some other peeps.

Avatar image for fisk0
#2 Posted by fisk0 (6952 posts) -

Rob Zacny is probably the only one who does written reviews for the kinds of games I'm interested in these days. I also use Space Game Junkie and Indie Retro News to find out about new games, but that's more a preview than a review kinda thing.

Avatar image for therealturk
#3 Posted by TheRealTurk (576 posts) -

I dunno. The written review seems to be mostly on the way out and I generally don't pay much attention to who writes the review, since the churn rate seems to be pretty high.

Having said that, I usually agreed with Sterling back when he was actually writing reviews. He had the added bonus of at least having a style, love it or hate it, which is more than can be said than most reviewers these days. So many of them read like they are giving a 4th grade book report.

Recently, I randomly found Inside Gaming based on YouTube recommendations and found myself generally agreeing with their reviews. The sample size is pretty small though.

From this site, my tastes generally align with, of all people, Dan. I can only conclude he must be more sophisticated than he lets on.

Avatar image for inevpatoria
#4 Posted by inevpatoria (7467 posts) -

I used to be pretty defensive about the importance of the written review. But at this point I honestly can't tell you the last time I read a written review about a game. Or, frankly, even taken the time to watch a video review.

That isn't to say I don't care about game writing. I still read a lot of essays and critical pieces about gaming--whether at Vice or Polygon or Unwinnable, or even on Medium. But review-ass reviews are about as useless for me as they've ever been. Giant Bomb's Quick Looks, podcasts, plus a dash of general intuition is generally all I use to get me by.

Avatar image for humanity
#5 Posted by Humanity (18937 posts) -

Don't really read many reviews these days, not enough to have any sort of attachment anyway. When I do want to get a feel for a game I tend to just jump around a few sites and read the reviews there without paying much attention to who wrote them. I do actually prefer slightly more mechanical reviews though. Like I will go to Waypoint once in a while to see what Austin wrote on something, but you kind of know what you're getting into when you do that. GameSpot actually tends to have a lot of freelancers writing their stuff which is typically what I want - a by the numbers and to the point look at a game rather than an editorial deconstruction of the genre.

Avatar image for cikame
#6 Posted by cikame (2909 posts) -

I find that straight gameplay demonstrating the actual "gameplay loop" is way more valuable to me than a review, just a couple minutes of random gameplay is usually enough for me.
If it's a game that doesn't have much coverage usually IGN have a review so i might check that out, but Steam reviews, for as controversial as they may be, i think are a fantastic way to get the low down on a game, you just need to know how to parse it.
For the most part i'm watching reviews of older games for entertainment, documentaries from the likes of Raycevick and Gvmers, and TheGamingBritShow, who has a brilliant video on how RE6 isn't anywhere near as bad as everyone seems to think.

Avatar image for shiftygism
#7 Edited by Shiftygism (1063 posts) -

I'll usually check out various folks on YouTube to see what the general consensus is, if it's something Giant Bomb doesn't do much in the way of coverage. Especially this year after I added a few new "professional enthusiasts" to my shitlist.

There's too many misusing their platforms nowadays letting their own politics drive their criticisms and outlook on the medium. Unfortunately that's become an issue for film and television as well, and art will suffer for it if it hasn't already when creators bend the knee to every complaint of certain themes or flawed character. It's seriously weird how some younger folks won't let shit slide or look for underlying causes for story direction or characters acting a certain way and will make a mountain out of a molehill on social media regardless of which side of the aisle they side.

Those that let it drive their reviews and try to make a statement by tossing out an absurd score or use it as an opportunity to go on some out of left field rant of a game set in a fictional world from a Japanese developer and use it as fuel of what they wish that game was and what it would offer. I don't care. Anyone that does that, I don't fucking care.

This has been something that's bugged me since the EGM days and their review of Fable, it's not about what you want something to be, it's about what it IS and your ability to identify something truly being "bad" rather than it simply not being your cup of tea for whatever reason.

Avatar image for captain_insano
#8 Posted by Captain_Insano (3531 posts) -

All the reviewers I know nowadays are for board games only - Rahdo is my pick of those as my tastes most align to his

For video games I generally listen to the Bomb/Beast casts and watch Quick Looks and try to work it out from there.

Avatar image for nutter
#9 Posted by nutter (2287 posts) -

I don’t really read reviews. Games are generally pretty damned competent these days, so if it looks cool, I’ll check it out.

Even disappointing games are usually alright. It hasn’t always been like this.

Avatar image for skullpanda1
#10 Posted by SkullPanda1 (1631 posts) -

If Abby, Zandra, Danielle or Patrick have signed off on a game, odds are pretty good that I'll have a good time.

Avatar image for facelessvixen
#11 Posted by FacelessVixen (2664 posts) -

No one really, at least not in the "This new game came out. I wonder what my favorite reviewer has to say about it so that I know if it's good or not" sense, because I've been doing this gaming thing of over 20 years and I know what my likes and dislikes are about a game just by looking at them for the most part, thanks to YouTube. But to expand from just talking about reviews and reviewers to journalists and and games related entertainers, still Super Best Friends Play with their post-breakup ventures, Funhaus/Inside Gaming, and GB's Quick Looks are still fun to watch.

Avatar image for bobobones
#12 Posted by BoboBones (284 posts) -

I’m a crazy mix of Ben, Patrick, Jeff, Mike Mahardy, Dan, and Alex.

My taste is quite different from Dan Tack at Game Informer, but his reviews are fantastic.

Avatar image for finaldasa
#13 Posted by FinalDasa (3231 posts) -

Kallie Plagge at Gamestop is someone I'll always try to read no matter the game. She mixes that usual review tone with her own personality really well, in a way I'm very jealous of, and makes reading a review very worth while.

Avatar image for farleyslundgren
#14 Posted by FarleysLundgren (204 posts) -

I find myself agreeing a lot with Austin’s takes on games.

Avatar image for jaalmo
#15 Posted by Jaalmo (1752 posts) -

I don't really have a specific reviewer in mind, I generally follow the consensus of reviewers and the community and go from there. That’s probably a bad move on my part.

Avatar image for juantopo89
#16 Posted by JuanTopo89 (12 posts) -

Game Maker`s Toolkit, by far, nothing comes even close. It will change the way you see games and game development in general. The Last Guardian Review/Critique is my favorite.

Avatar image for onemanarmyy
#17 Edited by Onemanarmyy (4498 posts) -

Honestly, i feel like the only time i need a review nowadays if it's a very niche or obscure game. Last one where i had to do that with was The Next Big Thing.

In that case, my own gut is like 80% of the recommendation and the steam review section provides me with the information to know if i should go for it or not. I might check a video or 2 on top i guess, but hardly hunt for actual reviews on those games. Then again, i typically don't buy games at their release.

Avatar image for amzounslideslid
#18 Edited by amzounslideslid (2 posts) -

I've only seen a few but I like Phil Busardo the best.