• 86 results
  • 1
  • 2
Avatar image for rebel_scum
#1 Posted by Rebel_Scum (1233 posts) -

Personally I've always preferred Game Manuals in paper form. Some games out there have really long, tedious and drawn out tutorials that aren't necessary, e.g. when the game is a sequel and is showing the basics/features again.

Also when a pause menu has a control manual/tutorial I find is a good feature. What do you prefer?

Avatar image for blastroid
#2 Posted by Blastroid (289 posts) -

I am ok with in game tutorials as long as you can skip them. Paper manuals for me are only good when I buy the game and will not make it home for awhile. I can use it to increase my hype meter if it is a game I have been waiting to play.

Avatar image for dungbootle
#3 Posted by dungbootle (2502 posts) -

I don't read manuals and excluding them saves resources. I can't imagine a modern game without a tutorial either and that is not a bad thing

Avatar image for ch3burashka
#4 Posted by ch3burashka (6087 posts) -

I like to peruse a manual or two. Too bad that era is gone forever.

If I ever make a game, it will come with a manual... and a cloth map.

Avatar image for beachthunder
#5 Posted by BeachThunder (14576 posts) -

Neither is a substitute for the other.

Manuals are great to look through, if they're well designed. Some kind of (preferably skippable) tutorial should be in every game.

Online
Avatar image for gamer_152
#6 Posted by Gamer_152 (14479 posts) -

In this day and age they're not really made to be directly interchangeable; manuals are more for reference, while tutorials are actually more like a lesson in the game. I think tutorials have the potential to be much better than a manual at teaching you things, but even a lot of today's games have surprisingly bad tutorials. All in all though, people printing less paper manuals is good for the environment, and phasing them out means there's more pressure on developers than ever to actually make sure their tutorials are up to scratch.

Moderator
Avatar image for animasta
#7 Posted by Animasta (14903 posts) -

a paper manual is nice but trees are better.

Avatar image for bestusernameever
#8 Posted by BestUsernameEver (5026 posts) -

I wish tutorials were not a thing, just let the player figure it out with smart level design. EG: Classic metroids, super meatboy ect.

Avatar image for morbid_coffee
#9 Edited by Morbid_Coffee (974 posts) -

A big full color manual is the best thing to see when opening up a game box and every game that doesn't have one should be ashamed.

I'm also super bummed when a game comes with a huge manual but it's only 15 pages repeated in English, French, and Spanish.

Avatar image for zeforgotten
#10 Posted by ZeForgotten (10368 posts) -

If the manual is good. 
Like one of those manuals that have all kinds of stuff in it like story summary, character bios and stuff like that.  
If it's just "hit A/X/E to do whatever" then they're as useless as Tutorials in "FPS Shooter Game number 5 in the series"

Avatar image for zaccheus
#11 Edited by Zaccheus (1981 posts) -

No. Manuals are useless in this day and age.

Avatar image for _zombie_
#12 Posted by _Zombie_ (1483 posts) -

If it's a good tutorial? I'll pass on the manual. But if the tutorial is shit, I at least want a manual to explain the game basics in brief.

Avatar image for wemibelle
#13 Posted by Wemibelle (2388 posts) -

The Internet has replaced game manuals. If there is something about a game that is cryptic or poorly explained, the developers expect you to look online for the answers. It sucks but paper manuals aren't the answer. Better designed, streamlined tutorials are the way to go.

Online
Avatar image for nightriff
#14 Posted by Nightriff (7111 posts) -

Guess I'm indifferent. If there is a paper manual the game expects me to have read it and I can get to the action quicker so I'll go with that one. Some tutorials can be brutal....

Avatar image for truthtellah
#15 Posted by TruthTellah (9809 posts) -

I prefer when they work together. A quality manual getting you ready for a more thorough and hands-on tutorial.

Avatar image for vandersexxx
#16 Posted by VanderSEXXX (587 posts) -

Gawd I miss the days when game manuals we're thick and had additional lore within its contents. I always liked reading about the lore every game has to offer especially if get drawn into it.

Avatar image for tycobb
#17 Edited by TyCobb (2031 posts) -

Will it stop the first 5 hours of a game being one giant tutorial? If so, then yes. Yes I would. Nothing pisses me off the most than 1/3rd of a game feeling like an endless tutorial.

Avatar image for vinny_says
#18 Posted by Vinny_Says (5914 posts) -

I recently started playing the first mass effect again, and unless I'm missing something there is no way to know what the buttons do unless you look at the manual. I was too lazy to get up and look so I just fumbled around for a while until I figured it out.

Put the manual inside the video game, that's the way to do it.

Avatar image for mandude
#19 Posted by mandude (2827 posts) -

I like being naïve and innocent to a game's finer mechanics when I start playing. The sense of immersion and discovery is one of my favourite parts of a game, and forced tutorials kill every shred of that.

Could you imagine Minecraft with a tutorial? Fucking disgusting...

Avatar image for alexandru
#20 Posted by Alexandru (345 posts) -

no

Avatar image for gaminghooligan
#21 Posted by gaminghooligan (1821 posts) -

Only if the manual is loaded with awesome lore. Most games just need to cut the tutorials time in half, exploration and discovery can help a game immensely, just don't leave the player with too little information to actually play. One of my favorite experiences this generation was Dark Souls, it taught me the basics, then loosed me into the game. The more I played the more I learned, and that feeling of accomplishment just got more and more gratifying every time.

Avatar image for TechnoSyndrome
#23 Edited by TechnoSyndrome (1342 posts) -

Having a physical booklet I can look down at to see the controls is a lot more helpful than a tutorial or digital manual that I have to dig through four menus to get to every single time.

Online
Avatar image for starvinggamer
#24 Posted by StarvingGamer (11359 posts) -

In-game manuals, as long as they aren't laggy and janky as fuck.

Avatar image for marz
#25 Posted by Marz (6016 posts) -

no, but they should have a manual in game in the options menu.

Avatar image for humanity
#26 Posted by Humanity (16204 posts) -

I used to love paper manuals and missed them when console games mostly stopped supplying them - but recently when I thought about the days when a game just dropped you in the thick of it and you were consulting your manual about what button does what on your keyboard and how the game even works I don't want to go back to those days.

Avatar image for likeassur
#27 Posted by LikeaSsur (1752 posts) -

Yes! I'd rather have paper manuals any day. I always read a manual before putting a game in, but that's getting impossible to do now that the "manual" is just an epileptic warning and legal stuff.

Also, to everyone who's reasoning is "No, because I love trees!" I'm going to blow your mind by telling you that paper companies.....actually plant trees! Whooooa!

Avatar image for animasta
#28 Posted by Animasta (14903 posts) -

@LikeaSsur said:

Yes! I'd rather have paper manuals any day. I always read a manual before putting a game in, but that's getting impossible to do now that the "manual" is just an epileptic warning and legal stuff.

Also, to everyone who's reasoning is "No, because I love trees!" I'm going to blow your mind by telling you that paper companies.....actually plant trees! Whooooa!

yeah? that doesn't mean we should waste all that paper for something that doesn't even matter.

Avatar image for dagbiker
#29 Posted by Dagbiker (7041 posts) -

I would rather have nether I.e. super Mario 3.

Avatar image for video_game_king
#30 Posted by Video_Game_King (36564 posts) -

Hell yes, I would!

Avatar image for brodehouse
#31 Posted by Brodehouse (10827 posts) -

ABSOLUTELY NOT.

If it's in the game, it should be _in the game_. Paper manuals are the gameplay version of transmedia novels and comics that set up the narrative. They are this extra thing you need in order to understand the game. If you think a game doesn't need in game tutorials, it also doesn't require any sort of story setup, it should just say "World 1-1 start killing the Ravjaak, Tony!" And you're like "What are the Ravjaak, who's Tony?" "Get the iOS app to find out more!"

Avatar image for brodehouse
#32 Posted by Brodehouse (10827 posts) -

Tutorials are the exposition of gameplay.

Avatar image for negativecero
#33 Posted by NegativeCero (3140 posts) -

I would probably take in-game manuals after seeing how the Vita does them. Although manuals of the older games look terrible and illegible at points, so as long as they use decent high res images, I'm sold on in-game manuals.

Avatar image for likeassur
#34 Posted by LikeaSsur (1752 posts) -

@Animasta: If they're written well and actually explain things, they definitely matter. Dynasty Warriors and most old RPGs are a perfect example of this. There's almost no tutorial anywhere, and no indication in game that this button does this. The manual covers all of that. For all the complaints about long, boring tutorials, games could practically do away with them entirely when everything is explained in the manual.

Avatar image for ducksworth
#35 Posted by Ducksworth (671 posts) -

A good paper manual is awesome. Artwork, character bio's, maps and story bits are what used to draw me to them but now they barely qualify as a pamphlet.

Avatar image for karkarov
#36 Posted by Karkarov (3385 posts) -

Yes I would prefer an actual manual to a crap tastic in game tutorial. Too bad paper manuals cost money and game companies are going cheap these days due to over all rising costs in general and profits becoming more slim unless your name is activision or ea.

Avatar image for little_socrates
#37 Posted by Little_Socrates (5844 posts) -

There's no proper way to include tutorials that isn't "make your whole game a tutorial" a laBraid/Portal or have a super-retro game a laSuper Mario/Super Meat.

I very slightly prefer a good manual, but I also usually don't read the tutorial part. It's nice to have something to check against, though.

Avatar image for subjugation
#38 Posted by Subjugation (4963 posts) -

There isn't any need for the manual to be paper. Have it be a menu option or something.

Avatar image for morningstar
#39 Posted by Morningstar (2375 posts) -

Tutorials are okay. Handhelding through the whole game like Assassin's Creed is not.

Avatar image for alistercat
#40 Posted by AlisterCat (7362 posts) -

Absolutely not. Everything should be inside the game.

Avatar image for ravenlight
#41 Posted by Ravenlight (8057 posts) -

Only if the manual is a proper tome and not just a few legal pages and a "Notes" page.

Avatar image for petiew
#42 Posted by Petiew (1421 posts) -
@BestUsernameEver: That's the best way, but it doesn't work with every style of game. Some systems have to be explained in detail to be understood. 
Lots of gamers also want to have their hands held with games they aren't familiar with. Fighting game tutorials consist of; Here's how you block. Go do some trials that demonstrate what moves can be comboed together and then make your own. That's pretty much all you need to know to play, but people unfamiliar with the game obviously won't feel that's enough. 
Something like the Resonance of Fate mechanics or another JRPG couldn't really be explained the same way as in Super Meatboy.
 
I usually read through the manuals while the game is installing on the PS3. In game tutorials are generally better though, especially if you have to play through the examples. Having a little section in the menu where you can re-read the tutorials is a huge plus too.
Avatar image for bonorbitz
#43 Posted by BonOrbitz (2475 posts) -

Yes! It's a a pain in the ass to try to dig up an in-game manual when I can reach over and look up the information in the manual faster than having to dig through menus.

Avatar image for mtcantor
#44 Posted by mtcantor (984 posts) -

In game only. Paper manuals are a waste.

Avatar image for fattony12000
#45 Posted by Fattony12000 (8271 posts) -
No Caption Provided
No Caption Provided
Avatar image for animasta
#46 Posted by Animasta (14903 posts) -

@LikeaSsur said:

@Animasta: If they're written well and actually explain things, they definitely matter. Dynasty Warriors and most old RPGs are a perfect example of this. There's almost no tutorial anywhere, and no indication in game that this button does this. The manual covers all of that. For all the complaints about long, boring tutorials, games could practically do away with them entirely when everything is explained in the manual.

or, you know, there could just be a manual in the game like the vita does.

also not everyone likes reading, so tutorials would have to be there anyway

Avatar image for likeassur
#47 Posted by LikeaSsur (1752 posts) -

@Animasta:

also not everyone likes reading, so tutorials would have to be there anyway

Let them suffer in the game, then. Paper or electronic, if people can't be bothered to figure out how to play the game, they deserve every game over they ever get.

Avatar image for confusedowl
#48 Posted by ConfusedOwl (1161 posts) -

When the game world is well realized and it has a lot of game mechanics to go through I do prefer a manual. I think they are fun to read.

Online
Avatar image for ghost_cat
#49 Posted by Ghost_Cat (2041 posts) -

I liked when manuals had a lot of back-story content not found in the game, so that's the part I would like to bring back to physical copies. Other than that, brief in-game tutorials are good to get your hands a little dirty before taking on the game itself.

Avatar image for joey_ravn
#50 Edited by JoeyRavn (5218 posts) -

Fuck manuals* and fuck forced tutorials. Give me the option to practice the mechanic the game wants me to use or to review it later, but don't force it down my throat. Even if the whole mission is based around it.

*Because fuck physical copies of games, too.